Skip to Content

The 10 Best Marco Island Seafood Restaurants | Marco Island, FL

Sharing is caring!

If you’re reading this article,  you’re probably looking for the best Marco Island seafood restaurants.

Marco Island, located in southwest Florida, is a popular vacation destination known for its beautiful beaches, clear waters, and abundant marine life. As such, it’s no surprise that seafood restaurants are a staple on the island, offering a wide variety of fresh, locally caught fish and shellfish.

10 Best Marco Island Seafood Restaurants | Seafood on Marco Island, FL

From casual beachside eateries to fine dining establishments, Marco Island seafood restaurants have something to offer for every seafood lover. Some of the best seafood restaurants on the island that specialize in seafood include Oyster Society, which offers a variety of raw and grilled oysters, and Deep Lagoon Seafood, which serves seafood dishes made from the freshest catches of the day.

Visitors can also find Marco Island seafood markets and seafood trucks that offer fresh catches of the day. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a fancy dinner, Marco Island has plenty of options for those looking to indulge in the freshest seafood the Gulf of Mexico has to offer. Here are some of the best Marco Island seafood restaurants.

Top 10 Marco Island Seafood Restaurants

Lee Be Fish

350 Royal Palm Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393890580

This is one of the local Marco Island seafood restaurants that focus on basic dishes that showcase the freshness of the ingredients. They catch their fish from their commercial fishing boats right out there at Marco Island.

If you’re looking for a casual hangout with friends or family, definitely go here. They have the best tuna taco in town and very good fried shrimp.

Lee Be Fish Tuna Taco

Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House

760 N. Collier Blvd. Ste. 105, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12392357497

If you are on a romantic getaway with your partner, you must visit this place. It has such a romantic vibe and definitely the best sunset view and is great for insta-worthy pictures.

The family of Pinchers restaurants serves fresh fish and seafood at Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster Market. For a local restaurant, local fishermen fish in local waters. That is the epitome of a Southwest Florida experience!

Make sure to try the Crab Rangoon, which is handmade, fried dumplings stuffed with fresh Blue crab, cream cheese, and green onions. They are served with spicy mayo and sweet chili dipping sauce.

Make sure you try the Deep Lagoon during your visit.  It’s one of the best seafood restaurants on Marco Island. 

Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House Fried Dumplings

The Oyster Society

599 S. Collier Blvd. #218, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393943474

When discussing Marco’s best of the best seafood restaurants, there are a few restaurant names that are frequently mentioned, and The Oyster Society is always one of them.

It is frequently ranked as one of the greatest seafood restaurants on Marco Island and is a sister restaurant to Marco Prime, which is located immediately next door.

The interior of The Oyster Society is what you’ll notice right away. There is no place like it, with its stunning decor, huge bar, and mirror wall.

You’ll just enjoy the ambiance of The Oyster Society when matched with the live jazz music that is played there every weekend.

The Oyster Society Oysters

This restaurant, which offers both indoor and outdoor eating, is a great spot to unwind after a long, exhausting day. If you can’t decide what to start with, you could get the Chef’s Dozen, which is the Chef’s Daily Selection of four oyster varietals, accompanied by unique daily sauces.

Or, if you’re with a group of friends, get the Oceanic Platter and combine that with some Italian white wine. Whatever you choose, you won’t be disappointed while at this Marco Island seafood restaurant.

Kretch’s Restaurant

527 Bald Eagle Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393943433

On Marco Island, there is a hidden gem called Kretch’s Restaurant that, in my opinion, is underappreciated. You can always tell that every meal was prepared with great care because the seafood around here is always so fresh.

Their shrimp cocktail is amazing, and, as one of my favorite kinds of seafood, the steamed mussels here are so good they melt in your mouth.

They prepare them by steaming them in garlic and white wine butter sauce, with garlic bread on the side. Who doesn’t love garlic bread?

Kretch's Restaurant Mussels

Cocomo’s Grill

1069 N. Collier Blvd. #202, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393943600

Our next seafood dining on Marco Island destination is an old favorite and a new destination.

They left their old spot and reopened recently. Like the last location, the decor is familiar. The bar and high-top tables are immediately visible when you enter.

There is new outdoor seating to the left. The main dining room is far to the right.

You can’t go wrong with some calamari and shrimp cocktails, but my personal favorite is the Seared Tuna Nachos with sushi grade Ahi tuna rolled in sesame seeds, ginger root, and cracked black pepper.

Cocomo's Grill Seared Tuna Nachos

The tuna is seared rare, cubed, and served over seaweed salad and wonton chips, topped with ginger and scallions, then drizzled with wasabi mayo and sesame garlic sauce.

This is just one of the many marvels you will experience while dining at this Marco Island seafood restaurant. 

Fin Bistro

657 S. Collier Blvd., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12399706064

Fin Bistro is the next location in our tour of Marco Island seafood restaurants. There is a solid reason why this adorable small café is well-known and loved all across the island.

Here, the ambiance, service, and seafood are all simply of the highest caliber. The purpose of Fin Bistro Marco Island is to provide only the freshest seafood.

In fact, the seafood served at Fin Bistro is all freshly caught that same morning. The Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa and the Marriott’s Crystal Shores are direct across the street from Fin Bistro, which is situated off South Collier Boulevard.

Fin Bistro Charred Octopus

If you’re looking for seafood restaurants nearby and are in the neighborhood, it’s a great place for intimate dinners and casual seafood lunches.

Try Uncle Jeff’s barbecue spiced white shrimp grilled and served with corn relish and chipotle vinaigrette as a starter, and continue on with the Charred Octopus with roasted beets, goat cheese, arugula, and lemon verbena.

Quinn’s on the Beach

400 S. Collier Blvd., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393942511

The iconic oceanfront restaurant on Marco Island, Quinn’s on the Beach offers breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico in a relaxed atmosphere.

Their Caribbean-inspired dishes are the ideal addition to any tropical beach getaway! There are alternatives on the extensive menu for even the pickiest eaters, including seafood, steak, sandwiches, and pizza.

Additionally, every night there is a LIVE fire dance show, so guests may enjoy supper and a performance!

Be sure to try their crab cake sandwich and if you are in for a dessert, try the key lime pie, it’s amazing!

Quinn's on the Beach Crab Cake

Marco Prime Steak and Seafood Restaurant

599 S. Collier Blvd., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393892333

A traditional American steakhouse with French, Italian, and Asian elements is Marco Prime Steak and Seafood Restaurant.

It is situated in the center of Marco Island and takes pride in its cutting-edge wine, cuisine, and drinks. This restaurant serves the freshest seafood and top-tier choice slices of Angus beef, as its name suggests, making it the epitome of surf and turf.

Starting off with the tuna tartare, pair that with some arugula salad.

For your main dish, I recommend one of their house specialties, the Charred Salmon with smoked mashed potatoes, broccolini, and kimchi butter sauce, or if you are a pasta lover try their Lobster Fettucine with homemade fettuccine pasta. Yummy!

Marco Prime Steak and Seafood Restaurant Lobster Fettucine

Café de Marco

44 Palm St., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393946262

The most varied range of fresh seafood is served at Marco Island’s favorite seafood restaurant, Cafe de Marco.

This award-winning restaurant is well-known for its enormous selection of fresh seafood, which is prepared every day using its chef’s unique recipes and sauces. Dine inside or on their deck outside.

As an entree, try the Shrimp Lenny, which is a crab-stuffed shrimp wrapped with bacon and honey barbeque sauce. From their main dish seafood selections, I recommend the Florida Gulf Shrimp Scampi with diced red and green peppers, garlic butter, white wine, and seasonings.

You will love everything about this Marco Island seafood restaurant.  Be sure to bring your appetite!

Café de Marco Shrimps

Mango’s Dockside Bistro

760 N. Collier Blvd. # 109, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393932433

On Marco Island’s Esplanade shopping and entertainment complex, Mango’s offers a pleasant indoor and outdoor setting for breakfast, lunch, supper, and cocktails while overlooking the marina.

Its menus are upbeat and oh, so islandy, offering something for everyone to enjoy. You can start with a delightfully inventive breakfast menu or catch dinner with fresh sushi, homemade soups, burgers, and daily Florida catch.

It advertises its “Marco’s Best Salads” options, including a salad bar and dishes such as king crab and avocado salad.

Mango's Dockside Bistro King Crab


Does Marco Island have crabs?

Florida’s Paradise Coast, which includes Naples, Marco Island, and the Everglades, is one of the largest producers of stone crab claws – second only to the Florida Keys.

Does Florida have the best seafood?

It’s no surprise that seafood in Florida is top-notch, but did you know that the Sunshine State is one of the top 12 US states for fresh seafood production? Florida also produces 84% of America’s grouper, stone crab, pink shrimp, and more!

What is the best eating fish in Florida?

Most freshwater fish caught in Florida can be eaten without harm. Bream (such as Bluegill, Redear sunfish, Redbreast sunfish, or Spotted sunfish) and marine fish such as Mullet, Snappers, Pompano, Flounder, and Dolphin are generally low in mercury.

Conclusion: Marco Island Seafood Restaurants

In conclusion, there are many seafood restaurants on Marco Island that provide a variety of dining options. There is something for every taste and budget, ranging from inexpensive seafood stands to luxury fine dining venues.

With a range of different seafood selections available, including oysters, scallops, and crab, visitors may enjoy fresh, locally caught seafood like grouper, snapper, and shrimp. For people who want to alter their diet, several of the restaurants on the island also serve a variety of non-seafood dishes.

Overall, when dining, Marco Island’s seafood establishments provide a distinctive and tasty culinary experience that is not to be missed. The seafood selections are suitable for both casual dining and formal occasions.

While in Marco Island don’t miss our guides for:

Visiting other destinations in Florida? Check out our restaurant guides to the following cities:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.