Skip to Content

The 8 Best Marco Island Pizza Restaurants | Marco Island, FL

Sharing is caring!

Florida’s Marco Island is a well-liked holiday spot because of its stunning beaches and relaxed atmosphere. Pizza is one of the island’s most popular dishes. On Marco Island, pizza restaurants thrive, each serving a different twist on the traditional dish. 

There is something for everyone, from classic Neapolitan-style pizzas to original toppings and gluten-free options. Many of the pizzerias on Marco Island make their pizzas with top-quality, freshly made ingredients.

There are several Marco Island pizza restaurants, so you can choose one that suits your tastes whether you’re searching for a more informal place to get a slice or a more premium dining experience. So if you’re looking for a tasty and satisfying meal, be sure to stay tuned on this Best Pizza on Marco Island journey with us!

8 Best Marco Island Pizza Restaurants | Where to Eat Pizza on Marco Island, FL

Top 8 Marco Island Pizza Restaurants To Visit

Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House

257 N, Collier Blvd., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393892433

Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House is a great place to go if you’re craving some delicious pizza on Marco Island. Since 1997, Joey’s has been a family-run business. The pizza served here is unquestionably made with love using only the best and most recent ingredients. 

They provide a variety of delicious Italian food, all created from scratch, in addition to pizza. Joey’s serves unique pizzas in a variety of sizes, including 12 and 16 inches.

Stromboli and calzones are also available. In addition to their extensive selection of pizza, they also provide a variety of dinner meals, salads, sandwiches, cold and hot subs, and more.

They even provide a dessert menu and a kids’ menu. Joey’s provides catering, carry-out, delivery, and online ordering in addition to other services. You can eat inside or outside while watching the TV, and you can drink from the full bar while dining!

Joey's Pizza & Pasta House


227 N. Collier Blvd., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393897499

Sami’s Pizza is a fantastic pizza place that delivers to Fiddler’s Creek from Marco Island. Stop by to experience the delicious meals and nostalgic decor.

Sami’s offers a variety of pizza options in addition to other Middle-Eastern, American, and Mediterranean cuisines. Everyone is welcome in this warm, home-like environment.

You’ll also love Sami’s gourmet dining experience, which is available at night.


Italian Deli and Market

 902 Park Ave., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393949493 

Many people come here to have a little taste of Italy. You’ll love the food in this Italian restaurant, especially the excellent pasta, Italian sandwiches, and meatballs.

This is one of the best Marco Island pizza restaurants stands out for its delicious cheesecakes, tiramisu, and peanut butter pies. It’s time to taste some delectable marsala or fine lager. You’ll be also served delicious lemonade.

Pizza is made in New York style and offered in both regular and Sicilian pizza varieties. Additionally, they have a selection of white pizzas, such as pizza with artichokes.

The option to order food for takeout makes Italian Deli a great choice if you want to have dinner quickly.

Italian Deli and Market Sicilian Pizza

Davide Italian Cafe 

 688 Bald Eagle Dr. #2541, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393932233

You’re considered family at Davide Italian Cafe on Marco Island, so you are very welcome there anytime! If you want to get amazing pizza and other Italian dishes, this is the place to go.

You can choose from a variety of 13″ and 18″ pizzas, as well as stromboli and calzones, all of which are handcrafted with fresh ingredients. Additionally, a large selection of appetizers, paninis, pasta, meat dishes, desserts, and wines are available at this modest cafe.

Davide Italian Cafe is a popular eating choice for pizza and other dishes because of its straightforward, welcoming atmosphere, wonderful food, and reasonable costs.

Davide Italian Cafe 

Tony’s N.Y. Pizza

145 S. Barfield Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States  +12399700027

This Marco Island pizzeria offers delicious Italian food. You can rely on Tony’s N. Y. Pizza for perfectly cooked pizza, meatballs, and calzones. This is the closest you will ever find to a New York City-style pizza on Marco Island. 

The crust is really thick and well-cooked, and the cheese and toppings are delicious. The sauce is light which makes the pizza not messy. The meatball appetizers are among the favorites!

Tony's N.Y. Pizza

Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano

599 S. Collier Blvd., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393891888

Italian cuisine is waiting for you; seize the day. At this Marco Island pizza restaurant, you can get tasty veal marsala, shrimp spaghetti, and spicy salmon, among other things.

Enjoy your time here with your friends while you share delicious crepes, gelato, and apple crumble. You can choose from mouth-watering draft beers, coffee martinis, or marsala.

You’ll probably visit here again later to sample some excellent espresso, ginger beer, or lemonade. This restaurant’s delivery service is a huge advantage. All year long, the cheerful hostess extends a warm welcome to all.

Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano


 551 S. Collier Blvd., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393891995

Next on our list is a casual restaurant serving fine food all day. Their menu offers so many selections that it can be difficult to choose from, but you can never go wrong with pizza. Not to mention, their pizza is homemade!

Get garlicky with their white pizza with garlic and ricotta cheese, or a very delicious one is their Buffalo chicken pizza with spicy chicken in a Buffalo hot sauce.


Mario’s Bar and Grill

845 Bald Eagle Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145, United States +12393892863

Italian cuisine is offered at this Marco Island tavern as well. Mario’s Bar and Grill’s tasty burgers, bacon, and pizza might win you over. Make sure you taste some draft beer with your pepperoni pizza!

This hidden gem is also known for its friendly and welcoming staff. If you are on a budget, this is the right place for you because the prices are pretty fair and average.

Mario’s Bar and Grill


What is the number one best pizza?

Una Pizza Napoletana in NYC has officially been named the best pizzeria in the world

Who is the best pizzaiolo?

Franco Pepe. Nowadays, Franco Pepe is one of Italy’s preeminent pizzaiolos. He is constantly developing his craft.

Conclusion: Marco Island Pizza Restaurants

Overall, Marco Island is a great destination for food lovers, offering a wide variety of dining options to suit every taste and budget. From the best Marco Island seafood and steakhouses to pizza and casual eateries, there’s something for everyone.

While in Marco Island don’t miss our guides for:

Visiting other destinations in Florida? Check out our restaurant guides to the following cities:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.