Skip to Content

The Best Seafood In St Pete, FL | 6 Must-Try Places

Sharing is caring!

If there’s one place on the map that has been making waves in the seafood scene, it’s none other than the sun-kissed city of St. Pete! 

Nestled on the shimmering coast of Florida, St. Pete isn’t just about the postcard-worthy beaches or the radiant sunsets that seem to set the skies aflame. This city is a haven for those with a penchant for the finest aquatic cuisine.

Now, we’ve all heard the saying, “There’s plenty of fish in the sea,” but in St. Pete, it’s more like, “There’s plenty of seafood on the platter!” This coastal gem has been drawing in both locals and tourists alike, eager to dive into plates of succulent shrimp, creamy crab, and mouthwatering mollusks. 

And guess what? I’ve embarked on the enviable task of fishing out the six must-try seafood spots in this city. Trust me, by the end of this gastronomic voyage, you’ll be hooked, line and sinker!

Whether you’re a seafood aficionado or just looking to dip your toes in the water, St. Pete’s food scene is a treasure trove waiting to be explored. 

So grab your forks and bibs, and let’s set sail on this flavorful adventure together!

My Top Three Picks of The Best Seafood In St Pete

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
Sea SaltSeafood Cavatelli5/5
Rocking Crab Seafood And BarMussels and Clams with Garlic Butter5/5
Fourth Street Shrimp StoreJumbo Shrimp Duo5/5

The 6 Best Seafood Restaurants In St Pete

Fourth Street Shrimp Store

1006 4th St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, United States // +17278220325

On my recent escapade to St. Petersburg, I stumbled upon a gem that’s worth more than its weight in golden seafood – the Fourth Street Shrimp Store! 

From the moment I stepped in, I was captivated. The casual ambiance melded seamlessly with artistic murals and wide windows that offered a cozy, inviting glow.

Now, being someone who thrives on discovering local haunts, I felt like I’d struck gold in the heart of St. Pete. With a menu that boasts an impressive variety, it was their shrimp dishes that truly caught my eye. And as the name might hint, how could I resist diving into a shrimp feast?

The Best Seafood In St Pete

I opted for the Jumbo Shrimp Duo – a harmonious blend of fried and scampi goodness. Paired with perfectly cooked new potatoes and a subtle Cole Slaw garnish, each bite was a delightful burst of flavor. 

But what sealed the deal? The remoulade sauce. It danced on my palate, leaving me wanting more with every bite.

And if you think that was the end of my culinary journey, think again! The onion rings served with a tangy horseradish sauce, were golden perfection. As for the clam chowder, let’s just say it’s a bowl of excellence.

The atmosphere? Vibrant and welcoming. The staff? Exceptionally warm and attentive. My overall experience at Fourth Street Shrimp Store was nothing short of remarkable. 

Fresh, delicious, and undoubtedly memorable, it’s a seafood restaurants in St Pete that’s a must-visit!

Crab Shack Restaurant

11400 Gandy Blvd N, St. Petersburg, FL 33702, United States // +17275767813

A quaint, unassuming establishment in St. Pete caught my eye: the Crab Shack Restaurant. No glitzy sign, no flamboyance – just the promise of some genuine seafood in St Pete.

Inside, it’s like stepping into a fisherman’s cozy den. You half expect to hear sea shanties echoing. 

Here, it’s clear that crab is king. The menu made my choice tough but the Snow Crab? Pure poetry on a plate. 

Snow Crab

To round off the meal, the hush puppies were little golden nuggets of joy and the rice? A comforting backdrop to the crab’s flavorful drama.

And as every food connoisseur knows, the atmosphere is the unsung hero of dining. At Crab Shack, it’s more like an underground club for seafood aficionados. The energy? Electric. Every table seemed to echo laughter, chatter, and the clinking of glasses.

But what truly sets this place apart is its crew. With the crowd buzzing, they moved with a mix of precision and grace, ensuring everyone was having a ball.

For those who fancy a deep dive into the heart of St. Pete’s seafood world without the frills, the Crab Shack Restaurant is your spot. It’s raw, it’s real, and it’s ridiculously delicious!

Casual Clam Seafood Bar & Grill

3336 Dr. M.L.K. Jr St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33704, United States // +17278952526

Browsing through St. Pete’s streets, I was drawn to an endearing spot, hidden like a pearl inside its shell: The Casual Clam Seafood Bar & Grill. It’s got the allure of those old-world, hole-in-the-wall places where stories flow as smoothly as the drinks.

The moment I stepped inside, the aroma led me straight to the blackened shrimp. Paired with fries that had just the right crunch, it was sheer brilliance on a plate. 

fried clam strips

But wait, there’s more! The clam chowder beckoned next, a delicious dance of flavors that left me craving more. And just when I thought I had peaked, in came the fried mushrooms. “Some of the best I’ve ever had” might be an understatement.

Feeling adventurous, I then dove into their fried clam strips. My taste buds thanked me profusely. And I also noticed that they whip up specials every single day. A new treat with every visit? Sign me up!

Whether you opt for their indoor charm or enjoy the breeze outside, it’s all part of the Casual Clam experience.

For those moments when you’re torn between grabbing a drink with friends or indulging in a seafood fest, this joint lets you do both. 

Rocking Crab Seafood And Bar

391 34th St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33713, United States // +17272028287

Brace yourselves, seafood lovers, for a flavorful voyage at the Rocking Crab Seafood And Bar in St. Pete! This is not your conventional seafood dining; it’s an adventure, and trust me, it’s hands-on and gloriously messy.

The first thing you notice? The laid-back, nautical charm of the place. It’s as if you’ve sailed into a haven where seafood is celebrated with fervor. Now, when they handed me the menu and told me I could make my own seafood combo, my heart did a little jig. 

mussels plate

I dived headfirst into mussels, clams, and scallops. The verdict? An explosion of flavors, thanks to that divine garlic butter seasoning with just the right amount of kick.

But the game-changer for me was the mild rockin’ sauce. If there’s one thing I’d return for (apart from everything!), it’s this sauce. It’s like a hug for your taste buds.

And don’t even get me started on the drinks. Top-notch and won’t have you digging deep into your pockets. 

Every bite at Rocking Crab whispers tales of fresh ingredients, seasoning expertise, and sheer culinary passion. You’ll be digging into your feast before you even realize it.

Wrapping up my meal, I was pleasantly shocked at the bill. Quality without burning a hole in your pocket? It’s a win-win. 

Next time you’re in St. Pete, let the waves guide you to Rocking Crab. Dive in and let the flavors rock your world! Definitely one of the best seafood restaurants in St Pete.

Sea Salt

183 2nd Ave N, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, United States // +17278737964

When one steps into St. Pete’s “Sea Salt,” the world outside fades. The 22-foot wine cellar stands like a beacon for wine lovers, while the sprawling 80-foot raw bar hints at the culinary treasures that await!

Our gastronomic voyage started with the octopus appetizer, a symphony of tenderness paired harmoniously with a zesty sauce. Next, our table brimmed with the freshest oysters from their happy hour selection.

But the showstopper was the Seafood Cavatelli. Laden with succulent lobster chunks and immersed in a sauce that dreams are made of, it was a palate’s delight.

Seafood Cavatelli

Drinks? Oh, the cocktails weren’t just mixed; they were crafted. Each sip had a tale accentuated by the bartender’s personal touch. If I could, I’d pen an ode to those delightful concoctions.

The ambiance? It’s like a seafood lover’s version of Narnia – beautifully adorned interiors complemented by alfresco seating, balancing elegance and ease seamlessly. 

Navigating through the menu, every bite was a nod to the freshness of ingredients and the artistry of preparation. When our plates were finally empty, there was a unanimous sentiment: culinary euphoria.

To top it all, the service was the cherry on this delightful sundae. Prompt, courteous, and always on point, making our dining experience sail smoothly.

In the landscape of seafood restaurants in St Pete’s, “Sea Salt” is not just a restaurant. It’s an experience – where flavors crescendo, atmospheres enchant, and every meal feels like a standing ovation!

Leverock’s Great Seafood

840 Pasadena Ave S, St. Petersburg, FL 33707, United States // +17273674588

Strolling into “Leverock’s Great Seafood,” it’s evident you’re in for an odyssey of taste. Spanning more than six decades, their culinary legacy looms large, promising a seafood fiesta for the senses.

Now, let’s talk menu. One word: vast. With such a plethora, even the pickiest of eaters is bound to strike gold. My journey commenced with a refreshing tomato salad punctuated with briny capers.

 A tantalizing beginning, no doubt, but just a prelude to the star of my afternoon: the salmon

Grilled salmon

Oh, that salmon! Cooked to perfection, it danced on the palate, paired impeccably with a baked potato so soft, it could only be described as heavenly.

Now, I’d heard tales of their clam chowder, the stuff of legends, some said. But my adventurous spirit settled on the lobster bisque. Rich, creamy, and decadently delicious, it made for an indulgent choice.

Just when I thought the culinary journey had peaked, the dessert menu beckoned. Amidst the sumptuous offerings, the peanut butter pie stood tall, calling out to my sweet tooth. And boy, did it deliver! A slice of that pie, and you’re teleported straight to dessert paradise.

But here’s the real clincher: “Leverock’s” isn’t just about great food. It’s a testament to enduring quality and the art of preserving flavors through generations. 

It’s a St. Pete institution, with the weight of years only adding to its charm. Dining here is like embracing a piece of the city’s history, one delightful bite at a time!

Questions Foodies Ask About Seafood In St Pete

What makes seafood in St. Pete’s so unique?

St. Pete’s Seafood is renowned for its freshness and quality. Thanks to its proximity to the Gulf, restaurants have access to a daily catch, ensuring dishes are as fresh as they can be!

Do St. Pete’s seafood restaurants cater to dietary restrictions?

Most restaurants in St. Pete are quite accommodating and offer options for vegetarians, vegans, and those with gluten-free needs. It’s always a good idea to check in advance or inform the staff when you arrive.

Is waterfront dining common in St. Pete?

Yes! Given its beautiful coastal location, St. Pete has numerous restaurants offering scenic waterfront views, creating a magical ambiance, especially during sunsets.

Are there seafood restaurants that offer more than just seafood?

Definitely, while seafood is the main attraction, many establishments also serve steaks, chicken, and vegetarian dishes to ensure there’s something for everyone in your party.

What types of seafood are commonly found in St. Pete?

St. Pete is blessed with a rich marine ecosystem. You can commonly find grouper, snapper, shrimp, oysters, crabs, and scallops, among others, gracing the menus of many local restaurants.

Is there a particular season when seafood is freshest in St. Pete?

While seafood is available year-round, certain species have peak seasons. For example, stone crab season runs from October to May, while grouper is typically freshest in the summer months.

Are there seafood markets in St. Pete?

Absolutely! St. Pete boasts several seafood markets that offer fresh catches daily. It’s a great way to experience the local seafood, even if you prefer to cook at home.

Wrapping Up: The 6 Best Seafood Restaurants In St Pete, Florida

Sailing through the culinary waters of St. Pete, FL, one thing becomes crystal clear: this city is a seafood lover’s paradise!

With the shimmering Gulf waters serving as a backdrop, St. Pete isn’t just about dining; it’s about experiencing a symphony of flavors, textures, and traditions that tell a story as old as the sea itself.

It’s this rich blend of fresh catches, traditional recipes, and innovative culinary techniques that set St. Pete apart. Here, every plate isn’t just a meal; it’s a narrative of the fishermen, chefs, and local communities who bring it all together. 

Whether it’s the succulent allure of a freshly caught grouper or the tangy zest of oysters straight off the boat, St. Pete’s seafood is a testament to the city’s commitment to quality and authenticity.

Dining here is an experience punctuated by gentle sea breezes, sun-kissed horizons, and the distant murmur of waves—a harmonious ballet that complements every bite.

As we conclude this gastronomic journey, let’s take a moment to appreciate the essence of St. Pete’s seafood scene. 

So, the next time you find yourself craving seafood, remember that in St. Pete, you’re not just getting a dish; you’re getting a piece of the ocean’s soul. And that, dear foodie, is an experience that stays with you long after the plate is empty.

Check out some my other guides for this foodie haven:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.