Skip to Content

The Best Italian Food In Amarillo, TX | 10 Best Italian Restaurants In Amarillo, Updated February 2024

Sharing is caring!

Ah, Amarillo, Texas. Known for its iconic Cadillac Ranch, sweeping plains, and, of course, its growing culinary scene that could make a foodie feel like a kid in a candy store. 

But let’s forget barbecue and Tex-Mex for a moment—did you know Amarillo has some of the best Italian food this side of the Mississippi? Yeah, you read that right! We’re talking authentic pasta dishes that transport you straight to Rome, pizza that would make a Neapolitan proud, and desserts—oh, the desserts—that could make even your Italian grandma nod in approval.

Now, you might be wondering, “Amarillo? Really? For Italian food?” Trust me, I was skeptical, too, until I delved into the local food scene. 

Let’s face it: Amarillo is a city of surprises. Among those surprises is a cluster of Italian restaurants that stand as culinary oases in this Texan desert.

So, grab your fork and put on your stretchy pants because we’re embarking on a delectable journey through the Amarillo streets. 

I’m going to give you the inside scoop on six must-try Italian restaurants that will leave you craving for more. 

Whether you’re a local, just passing through, or planning a gastronomic road trip, this list is your treasure map to Italian food heaven. Ready to dig in?

My Top Three Picks of The Best Italian Food In Amarillo

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
Valore Italian Restaurant and GrillCannelloni5/5
Vince’s Italian PizzaPepperoni and Italian Sausage Pizza5/5
Toscana Italian SteakhouseChicken Fettuccine Alfredo.5/5

The 10 Best Italian Food Restaurants In Amarillo, Texas

Napoli’s

700 S Taylor St, Amarillo, TX 79101, United States // +18062202588

Nestled in the heart of Amarillo, this family-owned gem offers so much more than just a meal; it’s a culinary experience that sticks with you. The moment I stepped into this rustic, earth-toned haven, I knew I was in for a treat.

Opting to sit outside, my taste buds were already dancing in anticipation. Before we even dive into the entrées, let’s talk appetizers. 

Have you ever had garlic knots that made you close your eyes and savor each bite? Because that’s precisely what happened here. The garlic knots, paired with their house-made marinara sauce, were out-of-this-world good.

But let’s not forget the main course: Eggplant Parmigiana and Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo. The eggplant was tender, flavorful, and layered with cheesy goodness that only elevated its richness. 

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo. Where To Find The Best Italian Food In Amarillo

As for the fettuccine? Creamy Alfredo sauce clung to perfectly cooked pasta, creating a dish that was pure comfort food. Even the breadsticks on the side felt like they were made to spoil you, warm and soft, right out of the oven.

Oh, and wine aficionados, you’re in for a treat too. A great glass of wine here just rounds out an already spectacular meal.

Top it off with service that makes you feel like part of the family, and you’ve got yourself a dining experience to remember. 

Napoli’s doesn’t just serve food; it serves moments, each plate a lovingly crafted work of art. So, make sure to put Napoli’s high on your must-visit list!

Fire Slice Pizzeria

Summit Shopping Center, 7306 SW 34th Ave space 10 rear, Amarillo, TX 79121, United States // +18063312232

Located in a location that turned our dinner plans into a delightful treasure hunt, Fire Slice Pizzeria revealed itself as a hidden haven of artisanal pizza and craft beers, complete with gluten-free options to welcome all.

Inside, the warm, inviting vibe of the place was palpable. Its clean and aesthetically pleasing interior set the stage for what was to become an unforgettable dining experience. The staff, notably Matt, exuded friendliness and expertise, guiding us through the menu with recommendations that promised to tantalize our taste buds.

We kicked off with the calamari, a dish that set a high standard for what was to follow. Deciding between Matt’s top pizza recommendations—Honeybomb, the Americano, or the Fire Slice Combo—was no small feat. 

calamari

In a happy twist of fate, a slip of the tongue led us to order a half-and-half of the Americano and FS Combo, with an accidental yet serendipitous side of Honeybomb

Although we were too full to dive into the Honeybomb after indulging in the appetizers and our original choices, the mere taste of the Americano and FS Combo was enough to confirm the prowess of Fire Slice’s pizza chefs. 

The crust, in particular, was nothing short of perfection, striking the ideal balance between crispy and chewy that every pizza aficionado dreams of.

 It’s a must-visit for anyone craving a slice of Italy in the heart of Texas.

Pescaraz Italian Restaurant

3415 S Bell St, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States // +18063505430

Tucked away in Amarillo, this casual spot has been serving up authentic Italian vibes and flavors for over a decade. And let me tell you, one visit was all it took for me to see why it’s got such a stellar reputation.

First off, let’s talk atmosphere. Walking into Pescaraz is like stepping into a charming Italian villa, complete with an old-world ambiance that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. 

And the live music? Just the cherry on top. Nothing complements a plate of pasta like the strum of a guitar in the background.

Now, onto the real star of the show: the food. I went with the chicken piccata, which was nothing short of divine. Tangy, buttery, and exquisitely cooked—it was the sort of dish you’d happily daydream about long after you’ve left the restaurant. 

chicken piccata

One more thing that won me over was their thoughtful gluten-free options.  A place that’s not only delicious but also inclusive—what more could you ask for? Just ask for their gluten-free menu and prepare to be pleasantly surprised by the variety.

Pescaraz is a local treasure doing everything right, from the food to the atmosphere to the live tunes. If you’re ever in Amarillo, make sure Pescaraz is on your culinary bucket list!

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4121 I-40, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States // +18063559973

This place, known for its hearty embrace of Italian cuisine, welcomed me into an ambiance that was immediately inviting. 

The atmosphere struck a perfect chord between casual and refined, setting the stage for a dining experience that promised both comfort and delight.

Their genuine care in ensuring our drinks were always refreshed and our dining needs met without intrusion added a layer of hospitality that elevated the meal beyond mere sustenance.

The allure of unlimited soup, salad, and those legendary breadsticks is an offer that speaks directly to the soul of anyone with an appetite for endless comfort food. And truly, who could resist such an invitation to indulge?

Chicken Parmesan

The Chicken Parmesan with meat sauce was my choice for the evening—a classic dish that Olive Garden executed with a finesse that honored its traditional roots. 

Alongside, the Spaghetti with meat sauce and the Pasta Fagioli Soup complemented the meal, each dish showcasing the rich, hearty flavors that define authentic Italian cuisine. 

The breadsticks, soft, garlicky, and endlessly arriving at our table, were the perfect accompaniment, tying the entire meal together in a warm, doughy embrace.

It’s a place where the spirit of Italian dining is celebrated with every dish, making it a cherished stop for those in search of a taste of Italy in the heart of Texas.

Valore Italian Restaurant and Grill

900 S Tyler St, Amarillo, TX 79101, United States // +18065457372

If there’s one word that encapsulates the essence of Valore Italian Restaurant and Grill, it’s “intimate.” But let’s not get ahead of ourselves; this Amarillo gem deserves a proper introduction. 

Valore Italian Restaurant is an experience steeped in Italian tradition and local charm.

Once you’re in, you’ll realize it’s not just the lighting; the entire atmosphere is deliberately crafted to make you feel like you’re sitting down for dinner at a friend’s home—assuming your friend is an Italian chef extraordinaire.

Speaking of dinner, I can’t recommend enough that you scour the menu before you visit. Trust me, you’ll need some time to decide; the options are plentiful and utterly tempting. 

But if the menu overwhelms you, don’t sweat it. Our server was both friendly and a walking encyclopedia of Italian cuisine, effortlessly guiding us through our food journey. Her recommendations? Spot on.

Take the seafood-stuffed mushrooms I kicked off my meal with, for instance. Every bite was a flavorful burst, heightened by the sauce that was clearly crafted with love and expertise. And the breadsticks? Let’s just say they didn’t last long on the table.

cannelloni

As for my main course—the cannelloni—each mouthful felt like a comforting hug, tasting as fresh and well-made as they come.

Oh, and let’s not forget the drinks. Equally as excellent, they paired wonderfully with the food and only amplified the overall dining experience.

But what really ties it all together is the owner, who’s often around and very much hands-on. You can genuinely feel the love and care that go into not just the food but also the entire operation.

Fazoli’s

2512 Soncy Rd, Amarillo, TX 79121, United States // +18064579996

With a reputation for serving up a comforting array of baked pastas, subs, pizza, and more, Fazoli’s beckoned with the promise of homemade flavors in a fast-casual setting.

The warmth of the staff amplified this inviting atmosphere, making me feel appreciated and well taken care of throughout my visit.

The menu at Fazoli’s, rich with options, presented a delightful dilemma. Yet, drawn by the allure of classic Italian comfort food, I opted for their lasagna—a decision that proved to be nothing short of culinary bliss. 

Each layer of tender pasta, rich meat sauce, and creamy cheese was a testament to the care and authenticity Fazoli’s puts into its dishes. 

lasagna

And oh, the breadsticks! Warm, garlicky, and utterly addictive, they were a highlight in their own right, setting a gold standard for what casual Italian dining could offer.

Not to be overlooked, the crispy chicken ranch salad offered a refreshing counterpoint to the hearty lasagna. 

The innovative substitution of traditional croutons with pieces of their signature breadstick was a stroke of genius, adding a delightful crunch and flavor that tied the salad together beautifully.

My experience was a reminder that great food doesn’t need to be complicated to be memorable. For anyone craving Italian fare in Amarillo, Fazoli’s stands as a beacon of delicious food, impeccable cleanliness, and outstanding customer service. 

Vince’s Italian Pizza

2413 S Western St, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States // +18063522656

Vince’s Italian Pizza in Amarillo is the kind of place where you walk in and instantly feel like you’ve discovered the city’s best-kept secret. 

Let’s break it down: this counter-serve spot is unpretentious to its core, zeroing in on what matters most—utterly scrumptious, heartwarming food. The vibes are old-school Italian pizzeria all the way, a rare find in this Texan town.

So, about the pizza. Guys, it’s incredible. I went for the Pepperoni and Italian Sausage Pizza, and let me just spill the beans: it was a masterpiece. The crust hit that elusive balance between thin and soft. 

Pepperoni and Italian Sausage Pizza

But what really made it a showstopper was the real tomato sauce—yes, actual tomatoes, not the canned paste variety. Topped off with gooey, slightly greasy (in the best way possible) cheese and a sprinkle of Italian herbs, this pizza was everything you’d hope for and more!

Now, if pizza isn’t your thing (although, after trying Vince’s, it just might become your thing), their menu doesn’t stop there. They’ve got some ridiculously tasty gyros that could easily give any specialty gyro spot a run for its money. 

That’s the beauty of Vince’s: whether it’s a hearty sub, mouthwatering pasta, or those to-die-for gyros, everything is generous in portion and rich in flavor.

I mean, what’s not to love? The place practically screams “good times and full bellies ahead.” So, if you’re cruising through Amarillo, carve out some time to stop by Vince’s Italian Pizza.

La Bella Pizza Hillside

7230 Hillside Rd, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States // +18063521600 

This long-standing establishment, known for its vast selection of salads, calzones, and both thin- and thick-crust pizzas, offers more than just a meal; it delivers an experience. 

With options for delivery, La Bella makes it easy to enjoy their culinary creations from the comfort of home, but dining in presents an ambiance and warmth that delivery just can’t match.

My anticipation was high as I stepped into La Bella Pizza, a place where the name only scratches the surface of what’s on offer. 

The notion that this was merely another pizza joint was quickly dispelled the moment I glimpsed their menu. 

Beyond the classic pizzas, their specialty selections promised a journey of flavors that was too tempting to resist.

We dove headfirst into the adventure with orders of the supreme, all meat, and jalapeño popper pizzas

Each pie was a revelation, but the supreme stood out with its generous heap of toppings, marrying flavors in a symphony of taste that had us reaching for slice after slice. 

The cheese, a crucial component of any pizza, was lavishly layered on all three, creating a gooey, mouthwatering masterpiece that left us in awe of what could be achieved with a simple pizza.

jalapeño popper pizza

The idea of tackling their 24″ pizza seemed like a challenge for another day, but one I’m eager to return for. 

The sheer size is a testament to La Bella’s commitment to serving up hearty, satisfying meals that don’t just feed the body but the soul as well.

The ambiance of La Bella Pizza on Hillside was matched only by the warmth and friendliness of the staff. 

Their laid-back, patient, and fun approach to service made us feel at home, turning the meal into an event that was as enjoyable for the company as it was for the food.

 It’s a place where every visit is a promise of a new favorite dish waiting to be discovered.

Macaroni Joe’s

1619 S Kentucky St, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States // +18063588990

Stepping into Macaroni Joe’s is like crossing an invisible threshold into a charming Tuscan village. And no, that’s not hyperbole; it’s precisely how this Amarillo haven makes you feel. 

Designed to resemble an Italian villa, the atmosphere here effortlessly blends refined with relaxation, setting the stage for a dining experience that transcends the ordinary.

Now, can we talk about their wine list? Because, my goodness, it’s extensive. With over 600 award-winning selections, you’d be hard-pressed to find a wine they don’t have. 

Whether you’re a casual sipper or a seasoned connoisseur, Macaroni Joe’s has got you covered. And the best part? Their wine prowess translates into the food pairing.

As for the menu, it’s equally impressive. Think pasta, fish, steak, and a dinner salad lineup that could stand on its own. My culinary journey began with a tuna appetizer that boasted just the right amount of black pepper kick. 

Lemon Butter Shrimp

For the main course, I opted for the Lemon Butter Shrimp, and yes, it lived up to every syllable of its tantalizing name. Also, a nod to my dining companion’s steak—it was cooked to a flawless medium.

But it’s not just the food and wine that steal the show; it’s the whole atmosphere. If romance were a place, it would be this dining area. The decor is as enchanting as a moonlit gondola ride in Venice.

So whether you’re in for date night or just want to unwind in an Italian paradise, Macaroni Joe’s is your Amarillo sanctuary.

Next time, I’m saving room for dessert, but for now, I’m happily savoring the lingering flavors of a meal that felt like a mini-vacation.

Toscana Italian Steakhouse

600 S Polk St, Amarillo, TX 79101, United States // +18064142200

Imagine combining Italy’s bold, iconic flavors with the robust spirit of West Texas—Toscana delivers this fusion in spades.

Before I even dive into the menu, let’s give a shout-out to the locally sourced ingredients. We’re talking beef so magnificent it could make even the most discerning Panhandle rancher tip his hat in approval. Pair that with an inspired selection of local and international wines and spirits, and you’re set for a grand feast.

My experience kicked off with Skillet al Formaggio. If you’re a cheese lover, this is your heaven. Melted to perfection and gloriously rich, it was the ideal precursor to what lay ahead. For the main event, I opted for the beef short rib over polenta

beef short rib over polenta

Guys, this dish was like a flavor firework show! The rib was tender and succulent, and the polenta served as its dreamy sidekick. And let’s not forget the veggies—brussel sprouts and carrots, cooked to absolute perfection.

Just when I thought I was delighted, dessert arrived. Cannolis and Italian doughnuts danced their way into my culinary heart, and it was nothing short of sensational.

As for the ambiance, it was just the cherry on top. Cozy yet sophisticated, it adds another layer of allure to an already magnetic dining experience. 

So, if you’re on the hunt for something extraordinary in Amarillo, Toscana Italian Steakhouse should be at the top of your must-try list. Trust me, it’s worth every bite!

Best Italian Restaurants In Amarillo, TX: To Visit List

1. Rotini & the Alfredo’s

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 7701 I-40 #212, Amarillo, TX 79106, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 5.0 out of 17 reviews.

2. Palio’s Pizza and Bar

  1. Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
  2. Location: 3562 S Soncy Rd, Amarillo, TX 79119, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Rating: 4.5 out of 693 reviews.

3. Pizza Planet

  1. Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
  2. Location: 6801 Bell S #100, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Rating: 4.3 out of 294 reviews.

4. Cicis Pizza

  1. Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
  2. Location: 6605 I-40 Ste 1, Amarillo, TX 79106, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.0 out of 1158 reviews.

5. Giovanni’s Pizzeria

  1. Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
  2. Location: 5807 SW 45th Ave, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.3 out of 289 reviews.

6. Pizzeria Nomad

  1. Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
  2. Location: 19151 I-40 Frontage Rd, Amarillo, TX 79124, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Rating: 4.7 out of 288 reviews.

7. Joe’s Pizza & Pasta

  1. Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
  2. Location: 2648 SW 34th Ave, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Rating: 4.5 out of 343 reviews.

8. Mr Gatti’s Pizza

  1. Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
  2. Location: 4412 S Western St, Amarillo, TX 79109, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.1 out of 2177 reviews.

Questions Foodies Ask About The Best Italian Food in Amarillo

Are there Italian restaurants in Amarillo suitable for a romantic date night?

Absolutely! Places like Macaroni Joe’s and Toscana Italian Steakhouse offer a romantic ambiance that’s perfect for a date night. Soft lighting, elegant decor, and an impressive wine list can easily set the mood for a memorable evening.

I’m a vegetarian. Do Italian restaurants in Amarillo offer plant-based options?

You’re in luck! Most Italian restaurants in Amarillo have vegetarian-friendly options like pasta primavera, Margherita pizzas, and various salads. Just be sure to ask the server about customizing dishes to fit your dietary needs.

Can I find gluten-free Italian dishes in Amarillo?

Yes, many Italian restaurants in Amarillo offer gluten-free pasta and pizza options. Pescaraz Italian Restaurant, for example, even provides a separate gluten-free menu. However, it’s always best to call ahead to confirm.

Wrapping Up: Where to Find The Best Italian Food In Amarillo

The joyous journey through the Italian food scene in Amarillo comes to an end, but let’s be real—the exploration of flavors, aromas, and culinary delights never truly ceases, does it?

Whether you’re a dedicated foodie or someone who appreciates a good meal, Amarillo offers a medley of Italian experiences that can satisfy any palate.

And hey, let’s not forget the power of a stellar Italian meal to turn any ordinary day into a mini-vacation to Italy—right here in the heart of Texas!

What strikes me the most is how Amarillo masterfully merges the old with the new. The city has an incredible way of maintaining the classic, comfort-food aura of Italian cuisine, all while introducing modern twists that surprise and delight. 

We’re talking about menus that boast time-honored staples and imaginative fusions, presented in settings ranging from rustic Italian countryside vibes to stylish, contemporary atmospheres.

Italian culture is woven into these establishments’ very fabric, from the servers’ warmth to the carefully curated wine lists. And let’s not underestimate the universal appeal of Italian cuisine; it’s as perfect for a family feast as it is for a romantic night out. Factor in the local ingredients and Texas hospitality, and you’ve got yourself a winner!

So, if you’re yearning for a journey through the hills of Tuscany, the bustling streets of Rome, or the serene coasts of Amalfi without leaving Amarillo, you know where to go. Keep this Italian adventure alive, and until next time, buon appetito!

Check out some of my other guides for this foodie haven:

Visiting other destinations in Texas? Check out our other delicious guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.