Skip to Content

Where to Find The Best Pizza in Temecula, CA| 10 Must-Try Places

Sharing is caring!

If you’re anything like me, you know that pizza is more than just a meal – it’s a full-blown love affair. It’s the ultimate comfort food, a reason to get together with friends, and the perfect cure for a case of Mondays. 

That’s why, when I ventured into the sun-drenched vineyards and picturesque hills of this delightful city, I simply couldn’t resist the temptation to uncover the best pizza spots Temecula offers. 

So, come along as I take you on a personal, fun-filled journey through the most incredible, drool-worthy, and downright heavenly pizza in Temecula’s restaurants.

I know what you’re thinking – why would anyone go to the heart of Southern California’s wine country looking for pizza? 

Well, dear readers, it turns out the most unique culinary surprises can be found in the most unexpected places. And let me tell you, the pizza in Temecula is a true hidden gem just waiting to be discovered.

My quest began when I picked up my rental car, feeling the warm breeze in my hair and the excitement of cheesy indulgence in my soul. 

I had my trusty notepad, a rumbling stomach, and an unwavering determination to find the best pizzerias Temecula had to offer. 

So, buckle up, fellow pizza aficionados, because we’re about to embark on an epic adventure that’ll have your taste buds singing and your belly craving more.

Together, we’ll uncover those tucked-away treasures and hometown hotspots where the crust is perfectly crisp, the sauce is bursting with flavor, and the cheese is a gooey masterpiece. 

We’ll chat with the passionate pizza maestros and uncover the secret techniques that set their pies apart from the rest. 

And, of course, we’ll have a blast along the way because what’s a foodie escapade without some good ol’ playful banter?

So, slip into your comfiest eating attire, raise a slice in salute, and join me on this unforgettable gastronomic journey through Temecula’s pizza wonderland. 

Here’s to our shared obsession with everything cheesy, saucy, and oh-so-delicious! Let’s get this pizza party started!

My Top 3 Picks of the Best Restaurants Pizza in Temecula

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
Blaze Pizza Self-assembled pizza5/5
Vail PizzeriaBBQ chicken pizza4.5/5
Pizzeria de MilanoAlfredo chicken pizza 4.5/5

The 10 Best Restaurants for Pizza in Temecula

Blaze Pizza

32240 Temecula Pkwy., Temecula, CA 92592, United States // +19517893202

Have you ever dreamt of a place where the pizza possibilities are as vast as your wildest cravings? A place where you can mix and match flavors like a true culinary Picasso? 

Well, let me tell you about my recent mouth-watering escapade at Blaze Pizza in Temecula – a canvas of endless combinations where I unleashed my inner pizza artist and indulged in a symphony of flavors.

Located in the heart of Southern California’s wine country, Blaze Pizza is a haven for pizza lovers who yearn for something more than just your ordinary pie. 

As I set foot into this wonderland of deliciousness, I was instantly captivated by the tantalizing aroma and the vibrant colors of fresh, high-quality ingredients just waiting to be transformed into my very own pizza masterpiece. 

The atmosphere was buzzing with excitement as fellow adventurers embarked on their own personal quests for the perfect slice. 

The toppings they offer are unlimited, so I could let my pizza imagination run wild without worrying about extra fees. 

I loaded up on all my favorites and even tried a half-and-half pizza to satisfy my ever-changing cravings.

The staff at Blaze Pizza were like my personal pizza cheerleaders, guiding me through the endless possibilities and making sure my pie was exactly what I wanted. Their kindness and expertise made my pizza-making journey a truly memorable experience.

But, oh, it didn’t stop there! Blaze Pizza also offers drool-worthy desserts. I couldn’t resist indulging in their heavenly s’mores dessert, which was the perfect sweet finale to my pizza escapade.

Now, let me tell you about the pizza itself. The variety of toppings blew my mind. As a certified cheese enthusiast, I was thrilled to find goat cheese, feta, gorgonzola, and, of course, the classic mozzarella and Parmesan. 

Pizza in Temecula: Blaze Pizza

Meat lovers and veggie fans alike will rejoice in the plethora of options available. And let me tell you, as someone always on the lookout for something a little different, their cauliflower crust was an absolute delight.

So, my fellow pizza aficionados, I wholeheartedly recommend a visit to Blaze Pizza in Temecula.

It’s a place where you can take control of your pizza destiny and let your taste buds explore creative combinations. 

Trust me; it’s time to embark on your own blazing adventure and have a blast doing it!

Spuntino Pizzeria Italia

31891 Rancho California Rd., Temecula, CA 92591, United States // +19516997722

Spuntino Pizzeria Italia is a cozy little haven with rustic charm, delightful ambiance, and mouth-watering brick oven pizza in Temecula. 

It is a gem of a pizzeria that has stolen a pizza my heart (pun intended)! 

Inside, I was enveloped in a warm, welcoming atmosphere that transported me straight to the heart of Italy. 

I decided to sit near the pizza oven, and oh boy, was that a great decision! I was treated to an aromatic symphony of garlic and herbs that made my stomach rumble with anticipation.

I kicked off my meal with some garlic bread, and let me tell you; it was hands down the best I’ve ever had. Soft, buttery, and bursting with garlic goodness, it was the perfect way to whet my appetite for the main event.

Regarding the pizza, I opted for a simple, classic pepperoni. Sometimes, you just can’t beat the classics, right? And Spuntino Pizzeria Italia did not disappoint. 

Spuntino Pizzeria Italia Classic Pepperoni

The pizza was a dream come true: a perfectly baked crust, rich, flavorful sauce, and just enough pepperoni to satisfy my craving.

But it wasn’t just the food that left a lasting impression. The exceptional service truly made the experience one to remember. 

The lone waitress working that day was a superstar, tirelessly attending to all the tables while keeping a bright smile on her face. Her dedication and hard work truly embodied the spirit of Spuntino Pizzeria Italia.

So,  if you find yourself in Temecula, I wholeheartedly recommend visiting Spuntino Pizzeria Italia. 

Trust me; it’s a place where you’ll be swept off your feet by Italian charm and tempted by the tantalizing aromas of brick oven pizza. Don’t miss out on this cozy corner of pizza in Temecula!


Get my free checklist with 15 tips on how to eat like a real foodie and enjoy an authentic culinary experience!


We respect your email privacy

The Pizza Press

30010 Temecula Pkwy. #104, Temecula, CA 92592, United States // +19513650727

If you’ve ever longed for an authentic New York-style pizza experience right here in sunny California, I’ve got some mouth-watering news for you. 

On a recent foodie escapade in Temecula, I discovered a little slice of the Big Apple that left me absolutely enamored. 

The Pizza Press is a charming joint specializing in thin-crust pies, friendly vibes, and fantastic service.

The lively ambiance reminded me of the colorful streets of New York, and the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza made my tummy flutter with excitement. I had no idea that my pizza fantasies were about to come true.

One of The Pizza Press’s distinguishing traits is the speed with which they offer their delectable dishes. I found myself clutching a piping hot pie, ready to be devoured, after only a few minutes of waiting.

Those who prefer to dine in will be pleased to find a fantastic selection of drinks to complement their meal.

I can’t say enough about the excellent staff at The Pizza Press. Their attentiveness, warm smiles, and commitment to crafting the perfect pizza made my experience truly memorable. 

They took their time to ensure every detail was just right, and I never felt rushed during my pizza-building adventure.

When it came to creating my custom pizza, I opted for the build-your-own feature with a zesty, spicy sauce and a generous heap of toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and a medley of other delights. 

The Pizza Press Pepperoni Pizza

Each bite was a flavor explosion that had me grinning from ear to ear. The attentive and courteous staff only added to my overall enjoyment.

Best of all, The Pizza Press offers an affordable taste of New York, so you can indulge in deliciousness without emptying your wallet.

So, my fellow pizza enthusiasts, the next time you’re in Temecula and hankering for a taste of the Big Apple, make your way to The Pizza Press. 

This delightful spot offers a unique opportunity to craft your dream pizza while soaking up the dynamic energy of New York City!

Bongiorno’s New York Pizzeria

32459 Temecula Pkwy Ste 105, Temecula, CA 92592, United States // +19513027400

In the quest for an authentic New York-style pizza, I stumbled upon a hidden gem in the heart of Temecula, California—Bongiorno’s New York Pizzeria. 

This unassuming eatery instantly transported me to the bustling streets of the Big Apple, offering not only thin-crust pies but also an array of subs, salads, and classic Italian mains. 

As I approached Bongiorno’s, its unassuming exterior adorned with a Statue of Liberty caught my eye. 

Although it appeared closed, my curiosity got the best of me, and I gently pushed the door open. To my delight, I found a cozy interior bustling with customers, and the compelling sight of freshly baked pizza pies awaiting eager patrons.

The aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped the air as I eagerly ordered a slice each of the Meat Lover’s and Combo pizzas

The moment I took my first bite, I knew I had found something special. The thin, crispy crust gave way to a symphony of flavors, perfectly balanced with savory meats, tangy sauces, and an abundance of melted cheese.

Impressed by the quality and authenticity, I couldn’t resist returning for two more slices. Each visit reaffirmed my belief that Bongiorno’s was a cut above the rest. It’s a testament to the owners and staff who pour their passion into every pie they create.

One of the highlights of my experience at Bongiorno’s was the warm hospitality of the owners and the entire team. 

Their genuine enthusiasm for their craft and their customers shone through in every interaction. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, they make you feel like part of the Bongiorno’s family—a testament to the true essence of a neighborhood pizzeria.

Bongiorno’s New York Pizzeria in Temecula, CA, stands out as a slice of authenticity in the realm of pizza joints. 

With their dedication to crafting delicious New York-style pies, along with a variety of mouthwatering subs, salads, and classic Italian dishes, Bongiorno’s captures the spirit and flavors of the iconic city. 

From the moment you step inside, you’ll be greeted by the irresistible aroma of freshly baked pizza and the warm hospitality of the owners and staff.

If you’re searching for a taste of New York right in the heart of Temecula, look no further than Bongiorno’s. 

Trust me when I say that their pizza will satisfy even the most discerning palates. So, next time you find yourself craving an authentic slice, make your way to Bongiorno’s and indulge in a culinary experience that transports you to the bustling streets of New York City.

Temecula Pizza Co.

44535 Bedford Ct., Temecula, CA 92592, United States // +19516949463

This is a local treasure that has quickly become another one of my all-time favorite pizza joints.

Allow me to introduce you to the culinary gem that is Temecula Pizza Company, where mouth-watering flavors, a warm ambiance, and friendly staff come together to create a truly unforgettable dining experience.

The inside has a cozy atmosphere adorned with old western movie posters and the enticing aroma of their heavenly pizza creations. 

With plenty of indoor seating and a delightful outdoor patio for those warm, sunny days, this is a spot where you’ll want to linger with friends and family over a delicious meal.

Now, let’s talk pizza. I fell head over heels for Vinella’s Pugilist with added pepperoni, a masterpiece that I can confidently declare the best pizza in Temecula. 

The pièce de résistance? Their house-made semi-pickled jalapeños, soaked in a scrumptious oil that added the perfect spicy kick. Trust me, your taste buds will be singing with joy!

But the deliciousness doesn’t end with their pizza. Temecula Pizza Company’s house salad is a revelation – so good, in fact, that I might even prefer it to the pizza! And if you’re looking for an extra treat, their pepperoni chips will definitely hit the spot. For those who dine in, you can also enjoy a fantastic selection of local brews and wines to complement your meal.

Temecula Pizza Co. Pizza

So, if you find yourself in Temecula, do yourself a favor and make a beeline for Temecula Pizza Co. 

This delightful establishment serves up a heavenly fusion of flavors, ambiance, and hospitality that will leave you craving more. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in this local treasure!

Vail Pizzeria

32123 Temecula Pkwy. Suite B, Temecula, CA 92592, United States // +19519724775 

This hidden gem is perfect for satisfying your pizza cravings and creating cherished memories. Say hello to Vail Pizzeria, a cozy spot nestled in the Western-themed plaza of the Walmart/Ross/Kohl’s shopping center. 

This charming Temecula pizzeria offers a unique and customizable pizza experience that will have you returning for more.

As I approached Vail Pizzeria, I was instantly smitten with the white picket fence surrounding the outdoor picnic bench seating. 

It felt like I had stumbled upon a secret garden – a serene oasis where mouth-watering pizzas are the star of the show. 

Inside, the seating options were just as inviting, with a mix of regular-height tables and high-top seats to accommodate any dining preference.

Stepping up to the counter, I immersed myself in the pizza-making process, reminiscent of the popular Subway sandwich experience but with a delightful twist – it’s all about pizza! 

With a tempting array of dough options, I was already salivating at the thought of crafting my perfect pie.

For just $8.99, you can indulge in a whole pizza with unlimited toppings, choosing from various sauces, cheeses, meats, and veggies. 

Then, the magic happens as your creation is baked to perfection in a fire oven. I opted for their BBQ chicken pizza, which felt like a personalized and unexpected twist on a classic favorite.

Vail Pizzeria BBQ Chicken Pizza

The best part? My delicious pizza arrived at the table in under eight minutes, and it was every bit as mouthwatering as I had imagined. 

To top it all off, unlimited refills on soft drinks and iced tea made for a genuinely satisfying and thirst-quenching meal.

Vail Pizzeria is not only a haven for pizza lovers but also an ideal setting for relaxation or family time. 

Its kid-friendly atmosphere and charming location make it a perfect spot for creating fond memories over slices of pizza goodness.

This enchanting spot offers a customizable pizza experience and a charming atmosphere that will make you feel right at home. Don’t miss out on this delightful little oasis – your taste buds will thank you!

Times Square Pizza & Bagels

29760 Rancho California Rd. #110, Temecula, CA 92591, United States // +19516993200 

Thus charming eatery whisks you away to the city that never sleeps with every bite. Let me take you on a culinary journey to Times Square Pizza & Bagels, where the magic of New York-style pizza comes alive in our beloved SoCal town.

Upon entering Times Square Pizza & Bagels, the tantalizing aroma of hand-tossed pizza dough and the sight of fresh ingredients assured me I was in for a delicious experience. 

The warm and welcoming staff greeted me with beaming smiles, adding to the inviting atmosphere of the restaurant.

The star of the show at Times Square Pizza & Bagels is undoubtedly their commitment to creating the ultimate NY-style pizza. 

Each mouthwatering bite of the light, thin, and crispy crust transported me right to the bustling streets of Times Square. 

The savory sauce and high-quality cheese brought each slice to life, creating an unforgettable taste sensation.

For those seeking inspiration for their pizza feast, some must-try creations include the White Pie, Buffalo Chicken, BBQ Chicken, Chicken Siracha, and the ever-classic Margherita Basil. Every option is a masterpiece that will leave you craving more!

Times Square Pizza & Bagels Buffalo Chicken Pizza

What truly sets Times Square Pizza & Bagels apart is its exceptional staff, who go the extra mile to ensure that your order is nothing short of perfect. Be sure to ask about their top-secret dipping sauce – it’s a game-changer!

So, if you’re longing for a slice of New York in Temecula, Times Square Pizza & Bagels is the destination for you. 

This delightful spot masterfully combines East Coast flavors with West Coast charm, resulting in a pizza experience that will linger in your memories – and your taste buds.

Papa’s Pizza Grotto

45440 Pechanga Pkwy. #504, Temecula, CA 92592, United States // +19516953663

Prepare yourselves for a mouthwatering journey to Papa’s Pizza Grotto, where the cheese takes center stage, and the flavors are simply irresistible.

Inside I was greeted by the warm smile of the lovely young lady behind the counter. Her friendly demeanor and helpful suggestions made me feel right at home in this cheese-lovers paradise. 

With reasonable prices and generous portions, I knew I was in for a delectable treat.

 At Papa’s Pizza Grotto, it’s not just a matter of piling on the toppings. Each ingredient is carefully selected for maximum flavor, resulting in a pizza experience that’s truly one-of-a-kind. 

Fresh, flavorful mushrooms, melt-in-your-mouth sausage, authentic pepperoni, and the star of the show – real, creamy, melty mozzarella cheese (none of that plastic stuff here!).

Papa's Pizza Grotto Pizza

What really sets Papa’s Pizza Grotto apart is its perfect crust. It’s not tough or chewy but has just the right amount of firmness to support the mountain of delicious toppings. 

Trust me; this is the kind of pizza that you’ll be dreaming about long after the last slice has disappeared.

With its friendly atmosphere, fresh ingredients, and generous portions, it’s the ideal spot to indulge your cheesiest cravings. Don’t miss out on this Temecula pizzeria!

Pizzeria de Milano

28276 Old Town Front St., Temecula, CA 92590, United States // +19516768880

If you’re yearning for a taste of Italy right here in sunny Temecula, I’ve got the perfect spot for you.

Pizzeria de Milano boasts an extensive menu, offering pizzas by the slice or as whole pies. From the classic Margherita to the more adventurous Alfredo Chicken, Shrimp Scampi, and Barbecue Chicken pizzas, there’s truly something for everyone. 

And if you’re craving something extra, the appetizer menu features delicious options like calamari, cheese sticks, wings, and salads.

I decided to try the Alfredo Chicken pizza – and oh, what a treat it was! Each bite was bursting with flavor, leaving me wanting more. 

Pizzeria de Milano Alfredo Chicken pizza

The freshness of the ingredients was evident, and I could tell that this was a pizza crafted with love.

One aspect that really stood out at Pizzeria de Milano was the warm, welcoming atmosphere. Even though I arrived just an hour before closing, I never felt hurried or unwelcome. 

The old-school pizzeria vibe transported me straight to Italy as if I were enjoying a meal in a cozy Italian kitchen.

So, if you’re seeking fast and friendly service combined with mouthwatering Italian cuisine, look no further than Pizzeria de Milano in Temecula. 

This charming spot is guaranteed to satisfy your pizza cravings and leave you with a smile on your face. 

Don’t wait any longer – head over to Pizzeria de Milano and treat yourself to a slice of pizza paradise!

Stadium Pizza

27314 Jefferson Ave. #1, Temecula, CA 92590, United States // +19512962400

31950 Temecula Pkwy., Temecula, CA 92592, United States // +19513023333

I had the chance to visit a local Temecula pizza restaurant that’s been around long enough to remember the days when cows and goats grazed nearby. 

Let’s step up to the plate and explore the legendary Stadium Pizza, where excellent customer service and delicious pies come together for a winning combination!

My taste buds tingled with anticipation as I ordered the Spicy Chicken Buffalo Sauce and Pepperoni pizzas. And let me tell you, Stadium Pizza did not disappoint! 

Stadium Pizza Pepperoni Pizza
Thin peperoni pizza with melted cheese closeup

The crust was a home run – crispy, flavorful, and the perfect foundation for the delicious toppings. Paired with a freshly prepared, generously portioned Greek salad, this meal was a grand slam!

What really sets Stadium Pizza apart is the warmth and kindness of the staff. They go above and beyond to make every visit special, ensuring each bite is a culinary delight. 

It’s no wonder this Temecula pizzeria has won the hearts of locals for so many years.

If you haven’t had the pleasure of visiting Stadium Pizza yet, I can’t recommend it highly enough. 

And don’t just take my word for it – all of their locations, especially the one on Jefferson Avenue, are worth checking out. 

So grab your friends and family, and get ready to experience a Temecula pizza tradition that hits it out of the park every time!


Do any of the pizza places in Temecula offer gluten-free or vegan options?

Yes, many pizza restaurants in Temecula cater to dietary preferences and restrictions. For instance, Blaze Pizza and The Pizza Press offer gluten-free crusts, while Spuntino Pizzeria Italia and Temecula Pizza Co have vegan cheese and toppings available.

Which Temecula pizza spots are best for families or large groups?

Temecula Pizza Company, Stadium Pizza, and Vail Pizzeria are excellent choices for families and large groups, as they offer spacious seating areas and a welcoming atmosphere. Plus, their diverse menus will have something to please everyone in your party!

Which pizza places in Temecula have a unique dining experience or ambiance?

For a unique dining experience in Temecula, check out The Pizza Press, where you can customize your own pizza with a newspaper-themed twist. 

Spuntino Pizzeria Italia also offers a charming atmosphere, complete with brick oven pizzas and an Italian-inspired setting.

Wrapping Up: The 10 Best Restaurants for Pizza in Temecula

Well, pizza aficionados, our scrumptious journey through Temecula’s top pizza spots has reached its conclusion! 

From customizable pies at Blaze Pizza and The Pizza Press to the charming atmosphere of Spuntino Pizzeria Italia, we’ve discovered that Temecula has no shortage of delicious pizza offerings.

We’ve been wowed by the New York-style delights of Times Square Pizza & Bagels, the cheesy goodness of Papa’s Pizza Grotto, and the warm hospitality of Temecula Pizza Co, Vail Pizzeria, and Stadium Pizza. And let’s not forget the hidden gem, Pizzeria de Milano, where we felt right at home.

As we wrap up this flavorful adventure, let’s celebrate the incredible chefs, staff, and fellow pizza lovers who made our journey unforgettable. 

Whether you’re a local or just visiting, we hope you’ll explore Temecula’s pizza scene and savor every delicious bite.

So here’s to the endless pursuit of the perfect pizza in Temecula! May your crusts be crispy, your cheese be melty, and your toppings abundant. Happy pizza munching, dear friends!

If you liked this article or found it helpful and you are interested in learning and exploring more about places to visit and things to do in Temecula, please check out our articles:

Visiting other destinations in California? Check out our other delicious guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Sunday 16th of April 2023

Seriously Pachinos is far better than most of them on the list. Doesn't seem you actually went and tried them sad to say.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.