Skip to Content

The Best Pizza in Carmel Indiana | 9 Must-Try Carmel Indiana Pizza Restaurants 

Sharing is caring!

Carmel, Indiana, is a unique city with a lot to offer. One thing that many people love about the area is the excellent pizza.

Carmel is a great place to enjoy Italian cuisine, and the residents have many options when it comes to delicious pizza. 

Whether you want to grab a slice at a local pizzeria or order delivery, you need to know where to go. And, with so many options available, it might be challenging to select the best place for your meal. That’s where we come in! We will list out the best places with the most delicious pizza in Carmel Indiana.

Each place has its own flair and flavor, so you should have no problem finding something you’ll love on this list. Just make sure to come hungry!

We just had to try them all out and narrow it down to the best ones in town. So, check out what we found, and let us know if you agree.

The Best Pizza in Carmel Indiana

Rosati’s Pizza

890 E. 116th St., Carmel, IN 46032 // 317-983-3638

Rosati’s Pizza is proud to serve the best pizza in Carmel Indiana.

Their authentic family recipe has been passed down through five generations. Their quality ingredients ensure that you will enjoy the same experience today as their first customers did over a century ago.

Whether you love Chicago deep-dish or thin crust, or if you just can’t choose because they’re all so delicious—you will love the pizza at Rosati’s.

There’s something for everyone at Rosati’s. They offer traditional thin crust, double dough crust, and deep-dish pizza, as well as stuffed crust options. Choose from their many toppings to create your own masterpiece.

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: Deep-Dish Pizza

Or, if you’re indecisive, just go for one of their favorites, such as Rosati’s Monster or BBQ Special.

But besides delicious pizza, you’ll be surprised to find a wide variety of other dishes, such as salads, pasta, wings, dessert, and more.

Whatever your choice is, you only get the best quality in every bite at Rosati’s Pizza.

Crafter’s Draft House

2430 E. 146th St., Carmel, IN 46033 // +13177982056

Crafted with the highest quality ingredients, Crafter’s Pizzeria is where gourmet meets pizza!

Come and enjoy their menu of traditional pizzas, their signature pies, and various craft beers and bourbons. They assemble the pizzas with care and bake them to perfection.

Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty, cheesy pie or a small bite prepared with care and creativity, you won’t be disappointed.

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: Cheesy Pie

Try their Jerry Jones pizza for an experience like no other. This pizza is a real treat, prepared with hickory BBQ sauce, mozzarella, smoked Texas brisket, ham, peppadew peppers, pickled onions, and cilantro.

Their menu has options for every palate. With original recipes for everything from appetizers to desserts, you’ll have plenty of tasty choices to make this your new favorite place for dining out.

Another primary reason you should visit Crafter’s is that their service is outstanding.

Crafter’s has become an established mainstay in its community through consistent quality service, an innovative menu, and great food!

Mellow Mushroom

2340 E. 116th St., Carmel, IN 46032 // +13178462400

Craving a memorable meal? It’s time to meet Mellow Mushroom on 116th Street in Merchants Square. They’re the renowned destination for pizza, munchies, salad, and burgers that Carmel locals rave about.

At Mellow Mushroom, you can order anything off the menu and know you’ll get the best possible experience. They designed their menu with the freshest ingredients possible, including their original pizza dough that is hand-crafted daily.

They offer a variety of delicious pizzas and hoagies that will please everyone’s taste buds. Don’t forget to try one of their unique flavors like the Great White or Buffalo Chicken served with a swirl of blue cheese or ranch dressing.

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Complement your delicious pizza with one of their Magic Mocktails or Enchanted Teas. My personal favorite? The Cherry Springer, a fun blend of cherry juice and fresh lemon-lime house-made sour mix accented with vanilla and caramel flavors.

Come to Mellow Mushroom for a quick bite or a relaxing evening out with friends and family.

Lou Malnati’s Carmel

11435 Spring Mill Rd. Suite 170, Carmel, IN 46032 // +13179751980

Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria is a family-owned and operated restaurant chain that serves some of the best pizza in Carmel, Indiana. Not only have Lou Malnati’s restaurants spread throughout Indiana, but they’ve also expanded to include locations in Arizona, Wisconsin, and Illinois.

Lou Malnati’s history is as rich as their pizza is in flavor. Malnati’s success stems from its dedication to excellence. Every Lou Malnati pizza is handcrafted only from the best and freshest ingredients.

Every year, the Malnati team handpicks California vine-ripened tomatoes for their sauce’s ideal sweet and tangy flavor. In addition, their unique sausage combination is seasoned precisely to produce the tastiest pizzas.

And let’s not forget their fresh mozzarella cheese, which is provided by the same local dairy that has been supplying Lou Malnati’s for over 40 years.

They are known for their excellent Chicago-style pizzas and their secret family recipe, which they use to prepare the amazingly delicious dough. One of the tastiest pizza in Carmel Indiana.

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: Chicago-Style Pizza

When ordering or stopping by, make sure to try their Deep Dish, The Lou. I’m sure you’ll enjoy every bite!

Blaze Pizza

12697 N. Pennsylvania St., Carmel, IN 46032 // +13173439193

Blaze Pizza is the perfect place to grab a quick lunch or dinner with friends.

Blaze Pizza can put a fresh spin on your favorite slice by allowing you to personalize your order. Their menu of freshly made dough, sauces, cheeses, and mouth-watering toppings allow you to create your own perfect pizza.

You can choose from an assortment of crusts like a gluten-free cauliflower crust or keto crust. Next, you pick your sauce – if you like to mix things up, be sure to give their spicy red sauce or garlic pesto sauce a try.

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: Garlic Pesto Pizza

With a variety of cheeses to choose from, including vegan cheese, you’ll be able to please the whole crew with a pizza from Blaze. Top it off with some meats and veggies, then end it with a delicious finish like their balsamic glaze, and you’ll have yourself the perfect pizza slice!

Blaze Pizza is the place to be if you’re looking for pizza in Carmel Indiana that’s not just great but also fast.

Bazbeaux Pizza

111 W. Main St., Carmel, IN 46032 // +13178484488

When you’re looking for a restaurant with outstanding food and friendly service, Bazbeaux is the only name you need to know! They offer an upscale dining experience with a rustic atmosphere that’s warm and welcoming. 

Their menu at Bazbeaux Pizza in Carmel Indiana offers a variety of specialty pizzas like The Luke and Tchoupitoulas, so you’re sure to find something that delights your taste buds.

The Luke specialty pizza features Buffalo chicken and blue cheese, red onion, and fresh celery for an explosion of flavors you’d never experienced!

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: The Luke Pizza

Their menu also includes starters like the cobb salad, crab salad, fresh mozzarella plates, and a wide choice of sandwiches.  

You’ll love Bazbeaux Pizza in Carmel’s Arts District if you like trying new things! 


13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy. Ste. 180, Carmel, IN 46033 // +13178442550

Pizzology is the real deal—a local pizza joint specializing in creating wood-fired pizzas with high-quality ingredients in Carmel.

They have several unique pizzas that are sure to satisfy any palate. On the top of my list is the Pepperoni Piquante topped with pepperoni, peppadew peppers, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, and fresh oregano.

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: Pepperoni Piquante

And let’s not forget their famous Bee Keeper, a delicious pizza made with soppressata, honey, jalapenos, and fresh mozzarella. It’s an absolute masterpiece!

And not only does Pizzology have a unique menu that includes creative pizzas, but they also have a huge variety of starters, pasta, and tasty desserts.

From the tried-and-true classic to adventurous new flavors, this unique pizzeria has something for everyone.

Greek’s Pizzeria

120 E. Main St., Carmel, IN 46032 // +13178481969

Greek’s has one of the best pizzas and breadsticks in town! They are fast and friendly, and you can always count on excellent service.

They make all of their food fresh and use the freshest ingredients. The pizza sauce is incredible, and the crust is hand-tossed and baked to perfection in a brick oven, making them very crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.

The veggie pizza is one of my favorites, but they also have gourmet meat pizzas if you feel more adventurous.

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: Gourmet Meat Pizza

Order the Greek’s Special Pizza with their unique Italian sauce, a blend of cheeses, Italian sausage, Spanish onions, baked ham, green bell peppers, sliced domestic mushrooms, and extra sliced pepperoni. It’s a fantastic explosion of flavor!

Their fresh ingredients, mouth-watering sauce, and amazing crust make this restaurant a must-try! So come and get some of the best pizza in Carmel Indiana.

Pies & Pints

14550 Clay Terrace Blvd. Suite 100, Carmel, IN 46032 // +13176887477

When you want something different but also a great bite, then this is the place with the right pizza in Carmel Indiana!

Pies & Pints is a family-owned and operated brewery, pizzeria, and pub offering a wide range of beer styles and food. It is a great place to grab some good food and beer. 

They have really creative pizza choices that are unlike anything you will find at other restaurants in Carmel. This pizza place serves its pies with gourmet toppings and unique sauce options. They also serve salads, sandwiches, and appetizers.

Pizza in Carmel Indiana: Pizza

There are plenty of options to choose from, especially for people who just want to try something new, like my personal favorite, the Chicken Gouda, made with applewood smoked bacon, red onions, chipotle crema, and scallions. So tasty!

Their inventive flavors, friendly service, and great location make this a special place to meet friends for a drink and some delicious food.

If you decide to pay this pizzeria a visit, don’t forget to wash everything down with a local craft beer.

Summary Of The Best Pizza In Carmel Indiana

When you think of Italian food in Indiana, a few things come to mind: great pizza and pasta! Carmel has long been known as a hidden gem when it comes to the different types of Italian cuisine. They have some of the best pizza places in all of Indiana.

From pizzerias serving traditional Italian dishes to creative combinations of both classic and modern toppings, this list has something for every type of eater. And, with so many options out there, you’ll have no trouble finding the right place for your pizza craving.

Check out our recommendations above, and let us know what you think.

Visiting other destinations in Indiana? Check out our other delicious guides:

Which of these pizza restaurants in Carmel Indiana will you try first? Let us know in the comments section below!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.