Skip to Content

The 6 Best Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana

Sharing is caring!

Carmel, Indiana, is an excellent alternative for getting away from it all and relaxing. You’ll appreciate the vibe this little Indiana town gives, with plenty of wildlife to explore and art institutions to visit.

Carmel is also a fantastic spot to eat. You will undoubtedly love your meals in Carmel, Indiana, with the most exquisite restaurants and delectable culinary outlets. If you are looking for Mexican restaurants in Carmel, Indiana, you have come to the right spot!

I’ve chosen the best Mexican restaurants in Carmel, Indiana, that provide authentic Mexican cuisine. I have put together this list to give you the best Mexican dining experience possible.

Visiting other destinations in Indiana? Check out our other delicious guides:

The 6 Best Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana 

La Hacienda Mexican Restaurant

12480 N. Meridian St., Carmel, IN 46032, the United States // +13175669563

This is the spot to go if you’re looking for Mexican restaurants in Carmel, Indiana. La Hacienda has a long history of providing beautiful meals to the residents of Carmel and the surrounding areas.

The staff will advise you on how best to enjoy your meal. The environment is relaxed, and the service is courteous and quick. The restaurant has previously been featured on CBS television, so you’ll be in great company if you visit.

However, to enjoy your excellent lunch, you must make a reservation at La Hacienda Mexican Restaurant.

They serve fantastic seafood and fruit cocktails, Chili’s chicken fajitas, and tacos. They also serve sangria and Margaritas to cool you off on a hot day! 

Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana:  Chicken Taquitos

Caliente Mexican Restaurant

1400 S. Guilford Rd., Carmel, IN 46032, the United States // +13175692223

Caliente Mexican Restaurant has a friendly staff and excellent service. However, this restaurant’s success would not be possible without its attractive environment and delectable menu. The comfortable atmosphere and lovely design will undoubtedly appeal to you.

The cooks of Caliente Mexican Restaurant will wow you with their delectable burritos, nachos, and enchiladas!

You might want to start with Fajita Nachos, topped with grilled green peppers, onions, tomatoes, chicken or sirloin steak, and cheese dip.

Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana: Fajita Nachos

For the main meal, you should order the Burrito De Carne Asada, which is filled with sirloin steak, beans, and onions topped with salsa verde and cheese dip, which is also served with rice. It’s mouthwatering!

There is also a children’s menu which will definitely make your kid happy!

Loren & Mari Mexican Grill

2293 E. 116th St., Carmel, IN 46032, United States // +13178101078

Some may argue that there is no better spot to savor authentic Mexican cuisine than Loren & Mari Mexican Grill. Their courteous staff works hard, keeps you happy, and contributes to the success of this establishment. I really enjoyed their service because the staff was very attentive. It definitely is one of the most unique Mexican restaurants in Carmel Indiana.

We had the chips and salsa, which were excellent. I ordered the chicken quesadilla Suiza, their specialty in a “Suiza” sauce. It had chicken, pico de gallo, and a dollop of sour cream. It was fantastic!

Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana: Chicken Quesadilla

Mi Hacienda Mexican Restaurant

819 W. Carmel Dr., Carmel, IN 46032, United States // +13178101219

Mi Hacienda Mexican Restaurant is conveniently located near Carmel in a nice neighborhood. Their dining room has a charming and warm feel and is extremely big, making it ideal for hosting family gatherings, business meetings, or even party celebrations.

They provide delicious enchiladas, tacos, and fajitas. The Super Mi Hacienda Enchilada, five enchiladas with cheese, beans, meat, shredded beef, lettuce, sour cream, and rancho sauce, is one of the most fantastic menu items.

Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana: Enchiladas

If you want to sample a taco, get the Cancun Special, which is loaded with pieces of chicken grilled with onions, bell peppers, and their special sauce, and comes with rice and guacamole salad.

They also have an amazing bar where you can order amazing Lime Margaritas and sangria.

Los Arroyos

11503 Spring Mill Rd. #100, Carmel, IN 46032, United States // +13178101747

Mexico may be found anywhere. Los Arroyos Mexican Restaurant offers a fantastic menu to pick from, and you will like their meals. This place’s bright atmosphere and helpful personnel will make you feel right at home. The pleasant atmosphere will make you feel at ease making it one of best Mexican restaurants in Carmel Indiana.

Los Arroyos focuses on authentic and tasty Mexican food. Tacos, enchiladas, burritos, and guacamole have been cornerstones of my diet for virtually my entire life. Los Arroyos has the best-tasting nachos and guacamole I’ve ever experienced.

Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana: Nachos And Guacamole

And, whether you’re celebrating or simply need something to get you through the day, Los Arroyos has a large selection of exquisite tequila and margaritas crafted to perfection. Patron, Don Julio, and Gran Centenario tequilas are among the options. You can’t go wrong with any of these quality tequilas.

Sun King Carmel

351 Monon Blvd., Carmel, IN 46032, the United States // +13178436250

Sun King is the place to go if you’re searching for a terrific Mexican restaurant in Carmel, Indiana. This family-owned restaurant in Carmel has been open for 24 years and is eager to serve you. The atmosphere is warm and attractive.

I enjoy eating here because they have delicious food and serve large portions.

They provide delicious appetizers such as Chicken Taquitos and Mexican Nachos, followed by the delightful handmade Tres Leches Cake!

Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana: Chicken Taquitos

Summary About The Best Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana

Are you tired of the same old tacos? Even though this is Indiana, there are several excellent Mexican restaurants in Carmel. These restaurants definitely know how to make authentic Mexican cuisine. Enjoy!


Which of these Carmel Indiana Mexican restaurants will you try first? Let us know in the comments section below!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.