Skip to Content

The 5 Best Downtown Carmel Indiana Restaurants

Sharing is caring!

Downtown Carmel, Indiana, is a vibrant cultural hub with year-round festivals and events. Its location is north of Indianapolis.

With the combination of music, entertainment, food, and theater offered in this small town environment, from delicious restaurants to family-friendly activities, Downtown Carmel is genuinely one of a kind.

The downtown area of this city is the oldest part of the town, and it was curated to give the feeling of a historic downtown environment because the city actually didn’t have one.

The Arts and Design District is where local art can be found. It highlights shops and galleries where you can see and sell everything, from sculptures to modern pieces, to original works and many more. 

The downtown area of Carmel is divided into two areas, the north and the south side. The northern end of The Arts and Design District is home to many small shops and Downtown Carmel Indiana restaurants.

You can find everything from casual burger joints and pizza shops to upscale eateries.

 As you travel north on the Monon Trail, you will notice a significant change in scenery from the historical architecture of downtown.

You’ll see a lot of older buildings and fewer families as you make your way north. Around Midtown, there are some vacant lots and unoccupied buildings, but this area quickly fills in. There are plenty of things to do if you want to take a break and enjoy the outdoors.

There are ball courts, ping pong tables, picnic areas, and playgrounds for children. This is an excellent area for families to get out on weekends, exercise, and relax simultaneously.

Downtown Carmel is the perfect place to relax and unwind from city life. Whether you are looking for an interesting new dish to try or an old favorite brew, Downtown Carmel is the place to enjoy an Indiana craft brew. Also, enjoy live music, great food, and year-round festivals.

The 5 Best Downtown Carmel Indiana Restaurants

The historic city of Carmel, Indiana, is home to various events that bring the community together.

The Carmel International Arts Festival features live performances, while the Christkindlmarkt is a festive German market complete with an ice-skating rink and delicious food. It is a place where you always have some activity surrounding you.

One of the thighs that attracts tourists and locals the most is the quality of the food that is served and the fun and friendly experience that they receive at the restaurants that they visit. 

So if you want to try the delicious food served in Downton Carmel, Indiana restaurants, then here are some restaurants that you would definitely want to check out.

Juniper On Main

110 E. Main St., Carmel, IN 46032 // +13175919254

If you happen to be near the Arts and Design District, you should visit this eatery because it’s on of the best Downtown Carmel Indiana restaurants.

Southern Coastal is known for its traditional dishes found in the Low-country of Savannah and Charleston.

Juniper on Main brings the mouthwatering, belly-warming decadence of Southern comfort food to the heart of the Midwest. The fried prawns, salmon, and honey chicken are the most popular among the visitors. 

Downtown Carmel Indiana Restaurants: Jupiter On Main Honey Chicken

The inside of the restaurant is big and spacious, and it gives a very home-like feeling. And it also has outdoor seating, so you can choose where to enjoy your meal.

The shrimp recipes are one of the most popular dishes in this restaurant, from which you can order a wide range of different wines and beers that they serve. This is your place for southern comfort food in Carmel.

Monterey Cuisine

110 W Main St Suite 135, Carmel, IN 46032, the United States // +13178532280

Monterey Cuisine is a well-known Carmel restaurant. It boasts a really energetic and lively ambiance, making it ideal for family dinners, dates, and even large groups of friends catching up over wonderful food.

The food was very delicious. As for appetizers, we started with goat cheese dip and crab cakes. The dip was absolutely delicious. However, considering there is a lot of dip, they may increase the amount of bread that comes with it. We also tried the sushi, and it was simply phenomenal.

I chose the sea bass as my entree. This was hands down the greatest sea bass I’ve had in years.

They really hit the mark; I would have anticipated this caliber of quality from a seafood restaurant on the coast.

Make sure you run, not walk, to this location; it’s well worth a visit, and I’ll surely be back!

 Savor Restaurant 

211 W. Main St. Suite 102, Carmel, IN 46032 // +13175644126

Savor delivers innovation at every level through its unique culinary and service combination. The restaurant presents a contemporary twist on the classic Mediterranean/Italian restaurant through global influences and fine dining quality of ingredients.

It is very well decorated, and it has a very peaceful atmosphere so you can enjoy your meal feeling very relaxed. No wonder it’s one of the best Downtown Carmel Indiana restaurants.

Food is prepared with a focus on flame, flavor, and finesse.

Every item is crafted over a wood fire in an open kitchen, where you can watch them prepare your meal and their chefs engage in conversation with you.

Their menu offers all kinds of seafood, chicken recipes, pasta, various prime-aged beef selections, other side dishes, beautiful desserts, and a long list of cocktails and wines. But, of course, this place is also very famous for its coffee. 

Savor Restaurant  Prime-Aged Beef

The Pint Room Bar

110 W. Main St., Carmel, IN 46032 // +13175718400

The Pint Room Bar has been recently opened in the Art and Design District. It has a very relaxed and inviting atmosphere, delicious craft beers, and great food. It specializes in offering a wide range of craft beers on tap that you’re not likely to find elsewhere.

The menu is an alternative to your regular well-worn bar food offerings and includes everything from sandwiches to burgers to salads; they also offer daily specials.

With a spacious bar area that offers more than 100 different taps for craft beer offerings and a large dining area, The Pint Room is a great place to hang out and unwind.

The Pint Room Bar Burger

Their famous burger “The Triple” is stuffed with boneless short rib, creamy horseradish slaw, double-smoked bacon, and indy smoked cheddar. In addition, they serve an exciting appetizer called Bistro Fries, with Idaho potatoes, bbq short rib, sour cream, and Ohio creme, and on the top, you have a roasted vegetable relish.

The Pint Room Bar is a definite must-go because it is considered one of the top-quality restaurants in the Arts and Design District of Carmel. 


111 W. Main St. Suite 100, Carmel, IN 46032 // +13175711116

The atmosphere in this place can only be found in an authentic Irish pub. It has been called the best neighborhood bar by the local city voters.

The food menu is full of Irish classics such as the shepherd’s pie, fried cod fish ‘n’ chips, and Irish beef and potato stew. There are also many favorite local dishes, such as the tenderloin, which is Midwest breaded.

They have an impressive fireplace, where you can enjoy listening to live music or simply enjoy your meal. 

Muldoon's Irish Beef And Potato Stew

As is with all the famous Irish pubs, Muldoon’s is recognized not just for its food menu but also for the wide variety of beer that they offer. So no wonder it made the list of the best Downtown Carmel Indiana restaurants.

People that come here can enjoy their time with their family and friends while eating and drinking the high-quality food that is being served in this downtown Carmel Irish pub. 

Why Visit The Downtown Carmel Indiana Restaurants?

In the Arts and Design District, restaurants are booming because of all the live music and activities around, like Muldoon’s and The Pint Bar; people enjoy themselves and enjoy the food.

Besides the parties, it is recognized as a place of culture and art, with its world-class internationally renowned concert hall, The Palladium, where all kinds of music are played, jazz bands, country, symphony orchestra, and many more.

You can also visit The Midtown Plaza and the Monon Trail. It is a beautiful place where people enjoy and discover the art scene and enjoy all of the local food delicacies offered. 

Visiting other destinations in Indiana? Check out our other delicious guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.