Skip to Content

The 8 Best Restaurants in Carmel Indiana

Sharing is caring!

Travel is a time for self-discovery and personal growth. For me personally, exposure to new cultures, customs, and ways of life can broaden one’s horizons and challenge preconceived notions and biases. 

Our next destination to experience excitement exploring a new place, trying new food, and experiencing new cultures is a city that is a real tourist destination to visit and have a nice time. 

We traveled to Carmel, Indiana, a city located in Hamilton Country, Indiana, and we really liked the spirit this city has. It is a suburb of Indianapolis, the state’s capital and largest city. Wait till you see our list for the best restaurants in Carmel Indiana.

We managed to visit several theaters, art galleries, and museums. We fell in love with the cultural scene this city has and the fact that this city has vibrant art that makes you feel artistically richer. 

Carmel, Indiana, is a prosperous and family-friendly city that offers a high quality of life for its residents but also plenty of interesting options for those who travel here and explore the city.  

City hall building in Carmel, Indiana

When we were walking through the city, I was amused by the well-planned and well-maintained neighborhoods, with amenities such as community pools and tennis courts.

And since we are the people that care for your food needs and dreams come true, it will be pointless if we do not guide you through the adventure of visiting bars and restaurants in Carmel.

The city also has a variety of shopping and dining options, with several high-end shopping centers and numerous restaurants serving a range of cuisines. 

In addition, these are the best restaurants in Carmel Indiana, we recommend you visit to enjoy a meal. As always, we picked the best for you because we are one big family.

My Best Restaurants Three Bars in Carmel, Indiana

RestaurantTop PickOur Rating
Muldoon’s on MainFries5/5
Monterey CuisineSea bass4.5/4

Anthony’s Chophouse
Mac and Cheese4/5

The 8 Best Restaurants in Carmel Indiana

Juniper on Main

110 E. Main St., Carmel, IN 46032, United States  // +13175919254

In Juniper on Main, we had an amazing time, feeling the real culinary haven in the heart of Carmel, Indiana. 

I love the nice ambiance this restaurant has together with the stylish and modern interior. 

This is a  quaint little place in Carmel with good food.  The staff was terrific, and we enjoyed it very much. The deviled eggs were a clever twist on the usual and very tasty! 

We ordered fried chicken, shrimp and grits, and a meatloaf sandwich. My favorite is fried chicken. It was juicy and tender on the inside, with a crispy and flavorful crust on the outside. 

Fried chicken

Here you will meet attentive and polite staff, completely committed to providing great service and offering you locally-sourced and sustainable ingredients in the dishes. 

Juniper on Main is a must-visit restaurant in Carmel for anyone looking for delicious meals in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere.

You will love it so much, and I strongly believe that this will become one of your favorite restaurants in Carmel. 

Monterey Cuisine

110 W. Main St. Suite 135, Carmel, IN 46032, United States  // +13178532280

I still can’t believe what a lovely place the Monterey Cuisine is. It was unbelievably good; I am still figuring out whether it was a dream, as it was really so good. 

We had amazing food in this lovely place, with a great goat cheese dip together with crab cakes for appetizers. A very promising start to an amazing night. The level of food quality is high, and you will feel real pleasure when you recommend this place to your friends. 

We also ordered sushi and all I can say is that it was simply phenomenal. Also, the sea bass is something that you wouldn’t miss; it is out of this world. 

Sushi

After our group ordered and we passed dishes around, we can also recommend paella, empanadas, lamb chops, and shrimp scampi as other dishes that had our heart. 

And of course, you will have all these food masterpieces in stylish and modern decorated places with an elegant and upscale atmosphere. 

I love the nice ambiance this restaurant has, together with the interior. I love the mix of booth and table seating, with large windows letting the natural light warm your skin.

The full-service bar that offers a variety of cocktails, beer, and wine is something I personally would like to visit often when I visit this place. It has everything to make you feel special. 

Monterey’s Cuisine is an excellent choice for anyone looking for unique and flavorful dining  in Carmel. 

Savor Restaurant

211 W. Main St. Suite 102, Carmel, IN 46032, United States  // +13175644126

In Savor Restaurant, we had an amazing time, feeling the real culinary haven in the heart of Carmel, Indiana. 

It is a modern American bistro in Carmel. We loved the flavors of all the dishes we had that made our night there memorable. 

I love the creative menu this restaurant has, featuring a mix of classic and contemporary dishes based on locally-sourced ingredients. 

We were sitting in a warm atmosphere enjoying the stylish and contemporary interior. 

We ordered lobster bisque, filet mignon, grilled salmon, and braised short ribs. The restaurant also offers a range of vegetarian and gluten-free options.

The highlight of my dinner was Blackberry Bourbon Smash. For dessert, I had Butter Cake which was amazingly tasty.  

butter cake

Savor Restaurant is a great choice for anyone looking for a Modern American bistro experience in Carmel.

Prime 47 Carmel

14300 Clay Terrace Blvd., Carmel, IN 46032, United States // +13176600720

Prime 47 Carmel restaurant is the right place for all of you who love premium cuts of steak. 

We were surprised by the quality of the dishes and the wide range of options when it comes to steak dishes that will take you to heaven.

This restaurant is an upscale steakhouse, and it is a place where you can come with your friends or bring your date for a special occasion or a romantic dinner. 

Our group tried the filet mignon, ribeye, and New York strip steak. All these dishes were made to perfection, garnering thumbs up from the table. 

filet mignon

The salads were very fresh with great dressings. I would recommend the field green salad. The candied walnuts in it were an amazing pairing with the cheese in it. The steak was divine with the smoked salt and balsamic reductions that came with it.

Prime 47 Carmel is a great choice for anyone looking for an upscale steakhouse in Carmel. The restaurant’s focus is on premium cuts of steak, supported by an extensive wine list, and exceptional service. 

Our dinner was beyond delicious, the drinks were strong, and the staff was on point. Everything was magnificent. Do not miss this place if you are going to Carmel, Indiana. 

Muldoon’s on Main

111 W. Main St. Suite 100, Carmel, IN 46032, United States  // +13175711116

Muldoon’s on Main is a traditional Irish bar where you can get a mix of classic Irish beers combined with American dishes, with a focus on hearty and flavorful comfort food.

The pub has a cozy and inviting atmosphere, with dark wood accents, exposed brick walls, and traditional Irish decor.

In Muldoon’s, you will feel at home and you will have a chance to try standout dishes such as fish and chips, shepherd’s pie, and corned beef and cabbage. The pub also offers a range of sandwiches, burgers, and salads, as well as a variety of appetizers and sides.

 fish and chips at one of the best restaurants in carmel indiana

The Paddy melt and Reuben were fantastic, and if you decide to have fries, we have to say that they are the crispiest you will have in your life. 

Initially, we came here for the beers, and we were not disappointed.  Muldoon’s on Main has an extensive selection of beers, including many Irish and local craft brews. 

We enjoyed the live music and entertainment as features this place should be proud of. The pub hosts live music on weekends, as well as trivia nights and other events throughout the week.

Muldoon’s on Main is a great choice for anyone looking for a cozy and welcoming Irish pub in Carmel. The pub’s mix of classic Irish pub fare, an extensive beer selection, and live entertainment make your food mood satisfied.

Anthony’s Chophouse

 201 W. Main St., Carmel, IN 46032, United States // +13177400900

In Anthony’s Chophouse, you will have an experience that will be unforgettable.  This place is an upscale Carmel steakhouse and has a sophisticated and elegant interior. 

Every meal here is made to perfection, and the food here is definitely top-notch.   

I got the best twin lobster tails ever. I could smell and taste how fresh they were. I felt like I was near the ocean. 

Also, I highly recommend having the restaurant’s Mac and Cheese. It was rich, creamy, and savory, with a smooth and velvety texture.  

mac and cheese

My friend had  Australian Wagyu steak and was blown away with how good it was! Also, I highly recommend their version of Mexican street corn. The drinks were also great, and they have a huge selection of top-shelf liquor.

We had our dinner in the dining room, perfect for business meetings, special occasions, or other events, offering a range of customizable menus and options. 

One of the standout features of Anthony’s Chophouse is their attention to detail when it comes to service. The servers are very nice, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu and wine list. They are striving to provide you with the best service. 

This restaurant was impressive, immaculate, and the staff was professional, swift, and friendly. And the food is heavenly good. 

Anthony’s is a must-visit restaurant in Carmel, Indiana.

Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine

11529 Spring Mill Rd. Suite #300, Carmel, IN 46032, United States // +13175644670

We love Italian food and the carefree attitude of the people in Italy, always smiling and with rose-colored glasses in their eyes. 

Therefore, we loved eating at Italian Artisan Cuisine.  It is an upscale Italian restaurant in Carmel, Indiana. I liked the modern and sophisticated interior with an open kitchen and a welcoming atmosphere perfect for a special occasion or a romantic dinner.

In this lovely place, you will find authentic Italian cuisine with a focus on using fresh and seasonal ingredients. 

We enjoyed the range of antipasti, pasta dishes, and main courses, with an emphasis on homemade pasta and traditional Italian flavors. Some of the standout dishes include the agnolotti stuffed with braised beef short rib and the fettuccine with lobster.

Agnolotti

The pasta is made fresh in-house and tastes exceptionally good. Meatballs are also good. The bread they brought out before the meal was excellent as well.

In addition to the food, Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine also has an extensive wine list, with a focus on Italian wines and a range of options to suit every taste and budget. 

One of the unique features of Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine is its focus on artisanal products and techniques. The restaurant makes many of its own ingredients in-house, including bread, pasta, and sauces. 

Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine is a great choice for anyone looking for upscale Italian dining in Carmel.

Pad Thai Restaurant

110 W. Main St. #140, Carmel, IN 46032, United States  // +13178188272 

When I think about Pad Thai Restaurant, I think about Thai-inspired cocktails and beer, as well as a rang of non-alcoholic beverages like Thai iced tea and coconut water, 

I loved the colorful decor this palace has, and comfortable seating makes it a great spot for a casual lunch or dinner. 

In this restaurant we managed to try traditional Thai dishes, with an emphasis on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. 

We ordered Pad Thai, Thai green curry and tom yum soup, and they were the standout dishes for us.  The restaurant also offers a range of vegetarian and vegan options as well as gluten-free dishes.

Pad Thai

We also ordered several other dishes for the table, including:

– Chicken Satay

– Pad See Ewe

– Green Curry

– Hawaiian Fried Rice

– Deep Fried Tilapia

Everything was beyond great. 

The staff is friendly and attentive, and they strive to make every guest feel welcome and comfortable. The restaurant also offers takeout and delivery services for those who prefer to enjoy their Thai food at home. 

Pad Thai Restaurant in Carmel is a great location for anyone looking for authentic Thai cuisine in Carmel.

FAQ

What kind of restaurants can we expect? 

You can expect a restaurant that offers a diverse range of dining experiences, with many featuring locally-sourced ingredients and creative menus. You can expect to find a variety of cuisines, including American, Italian, French, Japanese, and more. And regarding the decor these restaurants have, you can expect to find rooftop dining, farm-to-table dinners, and chef’s tables. 

Are these restaurants expensive?

It depends on the restaurant you choose and the dish you order. If you want some specific dining experience for some special occasion, these restaurants are likely to be more expensive than casual restaurants.  You can find a range of restaurants with varying price points, so there are options for those on a budget as well as those looking for an occasional meal. 

Do these restaurants have live music?

We really love live music, so we are happy to say that many of the restaurants in Carmel, Indiana offer live music, particularly on weekends. If you are a music lover, do not worry, this city has restaurants that offer live music that fits different preferences such as jazz and blues or country and rock. The types of music and performers vary depending on the restaurant and the day of the week. 

Conclusion: The Best Restaurants in Carmel Indiana 

You already know that we really love the best for you; therefore, these restaurants we picked for you are really the best from the culinary scene in Carmel, Indiana. You will be happy and satisfied with the diverse range of dining experiences, from casual to fine dining, with a variety of cuisine options to choose from. You can choose if you want to have rooftop dining, or outdoor seating that allows you to enjoy the beautiful surroundings of Carmel.

And you get all this while eating high-quality food with creative menus based on local-sourced ingredients. 

So, what are you waiting for? Don’t think twice, book your flight and visit this amazing city with a rich culinary scene. 

Visiting other destinations in Indiana? Check out our other delicious guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.