Skip to Content

The 7 Best Italian Restaurants in Park Slope Brooklyn

Sharing is caring!

After living near Park Slope for more than a decade, I have come to know some of the best restaurants in the area, especially the Italian ones, as Italian is one of my favorite kinds of cuisine. 

Whether you’re craving some pasta or classic Italian entrees, the Italian restaurants in Park Slope have what you need! 

Most of the Italian restaurants in Park Slope are located along 7th and 5th Avenue. I would recommend taking the subway or walking to avoid having to drive around for a parking spot or having to pay a parking meter. 

The Seven Best Italian Restaurants In Park Slope

Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats

1657 8th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY // +17187888001

Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats is known for “Real Italian dishes made from real Italian family recipes, prepared and served in a restaurant created and run by an owner raised in a real Brooklyn Italian household.” I don’t know if it could get more Italian than that. That’s one of the reasons why it’s one of the best Italian restaurants in Park Slope.

The menu is very extensive, so I’d recommend looking online to view all of the options before dining. I am going to highlight some of the dinner options here, but there is also a lunch and brunch menu (Saturday & Sunday 11 am-4 pm).

Appetizer options include the “Calamari fra diavolo” and “Gio’s garlic bread.” 

The pasta options available are plentiful and include the “Tagliatelle ai carciofi,” with artichoke hearts in a tomato cream sauce finished with fresh mascarpone cheese, and “Tagliatelle alla Bolognese,” made with country-style ground beef ragu with carrots and celery finished with fresh ricotta cheese, to name a few. 

Italian Restaurants In Park Slope: Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats Tagliatelle alla Bolognese

This restaurant has a variety of seating options with tables both indoors and outdoors. 

Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats is definitely a place you should visit if you’re looking for authentic Italian cuisine in Park Slope! 

This restaurant is usually pretty crowded, especially during the summertime when the weather is nice. 

Da Nonna Rosa

140 7th Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11215 // +17187886225

If you’re in Park Slope Brooklyn and are looking for Italian food, Da Nonna Rosa is the top choice among all Italian restaurants in Park Slope. I love this restaurant because it is casual, yet elegant. The staff always welcomes you as if you’re part of the family. I always look forward to the complimentary bread basket that is brought to the table as soon as I sit down. Although I probably end up eating too much of it before I even order my entree, I think it is a great offering, especially if you’re dining on a budget and do not feel like splurging on an appetizer. 

However, I usually end up ordering appetizers as well because they are just that good. My favorite is the “Arancini,” which are rice balls made with arborio rice, peas, San Marzano tomatoes, and Parmigiana. I sometimes order the rice balls as my entree since the order comes with five pieces and they are very filling.  I also really enjoy the “Zucchini Sticks” and the “Eggplant Rollatini,” made from herbed ricotta, Pomodoro sauce, and mozzarella cheese. 

I don’t typically order a salad when at an Italian restaurant, but I do love Da Nonna Rosa’s “Park Slope Salad” which is made with spring mix, candied walnuts, dried cranberries, tomatoes, goat cheese, and raspberry vinaigrette.

I don’t think an Italian restaurant would be complete without pasta and pizza. Da Nonna has some great options in those areas. I especially love their specialty pizzas, including the “Vodka Ravioli Pizza” which is topped with cheese ravioli, vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, and shredded mozzarella, as well as the “White Eggplant Pizza,” topped with breaded eggplant, creamy ricotta, plum tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

Da Nonna Rosa White Eggplant Pizza

My favorite pasta dishes offered are the “Pesto” and the “Primavera.” I like how many different kinds of pasta options are available, including gnocchi, which I feel can sometimes be a rare find. 

If you’re wanting to visit, I would recommend coming on a weekday to avoid heavy crowds. Weekends, especially during dinnertime, can get pretty busy. This goes to show how great this restaurant is! 

WANT TO ENJOY FOOD TO THE FULLEST? 

Get my free checklist with 15 tips on how to eat like a real foodie and enjoy an authentic culinary experience!

Screen%20Shot%202022-09-13%20at%2014.08.44.png

We respect your email privacy

Pasta Louise

1114 8th Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11215 // +13477253883

Pasta Louise in Park Slope is a great Italian eatery among the Italian restaurants in Park Slope for those who are specifically looking for delicious pasta. Each day, their chef selects a special pasta shape that is used as a base for the pasta dishes. There are a plethora of add-ons (for an additional charge). I usually add burrata.

However, there are so many other choices including Calabrian chiles, roasted cannellini beans, spicy crispy prosciutto, house-made whipped ricotta, arugula, or breadcrumbs. If you’re looking for gluten-free pasta, it can be requested. The best-selling dish is “Cacio E Pepe.” This is the one I always order and is made with cracked black pepper and salty pecorino. 

Pasta Louise Cacio E Pepe

If you want to dine at the sit-down location, log on to Resy to make a reservation in advance. Although walk-ins are accepted if time and space allow, I would recommend playing it safe to ensure that you have a table waiting for you when you’re looking to eat. 

This restaurant is definitely worth it,with its delicious pasta and beautiful atmosphere filled with hundreds of flowers. The atmosphere is perfect for a family dinner or a catch-up meeting with some friends. 

La Villa Pizzeria

261 5th Avenue Brooklyn, NY // +17184999888

La Villa is a wonderful option if you’re looking through the Italian restaurants in Park Slope that have an elevated vibe. I always enjoy the complimentary bread, as it is always served warm and I find it to be very flavorful. 

Appetizer options are plentiful and include “Fried Calamari,” “Baked Clams Oreganata,” and “Homemade Meatballs.” 

I usually order the classic Parmigiana with chicken or the pasta “Alla Vodka” and end up having to ask for a to-go box because I order too much food! I have probably been to La Villa at least fifteen times since I’ve lived in NYC, and every experience is always equally amazing. 

La Villa Pizzeria Parmigiana With Chicken

If you’re not someone who typically eats leftovers, I would recommend sharing an entree with another person. I find the portions to be quite large! 

Provini

1302 8th Ave. at 13th St. Brooklyn, NY 11215 // +17183692154

Provini is one of the great Italian restaurants in Park Slope serving Italian cuisine. What is great about Provini is that all of its kinds of pasta are organic and house-made. As I mentioned before, gnocchi is my favorite kind of pasta. Provini has a  “Gnocchi Al Pesto” dish that is comprised of house-made gnocchi with basil pesto, string beans, stracciatella, and crispy prosciutto. 

If you’re looking for a dish that is meat-centered, the “Piccata Di Pollo A Limone” is a great choice and is made with organic chicken, string beans, roasted potato, and lemon caper pan sauce. 

You can’t leave Provini without trying one of their desserts. The “Panna Cotta” and “Tiramisu Della Casa” are great options if you’re wanting to satisfy a sweet tooth. 

Provini Panna Cotta

Please note that this restaurant is open for lunch Monday-Friday from 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm and for dinner Monday – Thursday from 4:30 pm – 10:00 pm and Friday and Saturday from 5:00 pm – 10:30 pm. If you’re looking to try Provini for brunch, you can head over on Saturday or Sunday between 11:00 am – 4:00 pm.

Ottava

1123 8th Ave.  Park Slope, Brooklyn, NY 11215 // +17183690493

If you’re looking for artisanal pizza in Park Slope, Ottava is the perfect restaurant for you! From red pizza to white pizza to signature pizza, Ottava has got you covered!  

If you’re in the mood for pizza with red sauce, you could try the “Marinara” pizza topped with anchovy, garlic, capers, olives, basil, oregano, and lemon zest, or the “Polpette” topped with provolone, beef and pork meatballs, caramelized onion, basil, and shaved Parmesan. 

If you would like a white pizza, you can try the “Carciofi” pizza, topped with fior di latte mozzarella, spinach, and roasted red peppers or the “Pesto” pizza with buffalo mozzarella, tomato confit, zucchini, basil pesto, and Parmesan.

Ottava’s signature pizza should not be overlooked. The “Di Mare” pizza is topped with shrimp, clams, chorizo, garlic, peppers, onion, saffron beurre blanc, crème fraîche, and oregano. I am a fan of extravagant pizzas when all of the flavors mesh well together. 

Ottava Di Mare Pizza

Ottava also serves some classic Italian desserts such as “Tiramisu” and “Buttermilk Panna Cotta.” 

Pino’s La Forchetta

181 7th Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11215 // +17189654020

Pino’s La Forchetta is well-known for its pizza, but they also have other offerings as well including calzones, eggplant, spinach, broccoli, and sausage rolls. 

I particularly like the spinach rolls and think they are a good option if you’re looking for something cheesy that is not pizza. 

Pino's La Forchetta Spinach Rolls

Although this restaurant is more of a casual pizzeria, it is still a great place to visit if you’re looking to get out of the house and enjoy a slice or socialize with friends. 

This restaurant is fast-casual, meaning there are no servers, and is a more budget-friendly option. I find it very convenient to order food and have it ready for you within about ten minutes. 

This restaurant has great hours and is open daily from 10:30 am – 11:45 pm (and closes at 12:00 am on Fridays and Saturdays). I love that this restaurant provides great food at an affordable price. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Do Italian restaurants in Park Slope offer takeout or delivery options?

Yes, many Italian restaurants in Park Slope offer takeout and delivery options.

Some of the restaurants include:

  • Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats
  • Provini
  • La Villa Pizzeria
  • Ottava
  • Pino’s La Forchetta Pizza

What types of Italian dishes can I find in Park Slope?

You can find a wide variety of Italian dishes in Park Slope’s restaurants. From different types of pasta, risottos, pizzas, and seafood dishes, to an array of antipasti, there’s something for every taste. Additionally, many establishments have extensive dessert menus featuring classics like tiramisu, panna cotta, and cannoli.

Are there any vegan or vegetarian Italian options?

Absolutely! Italian cuisine has many dishes that are naturally vegetarian, such as pasta pomodoro or margherita pizza. Several restaurants in Park Slope offer vegan alternatives too, with options like vegan cheese for pizza or pasta dishes, and plant-based alternatives for traditional ingredients.

Is it necessary to make a reservation at Italian restaurants in Park Slope?

While walk-ins are welcomed at most Italian restaurants in Park Slope, it’s generally a good idea to make a reservation, particularly on weekends or for larger groups. Some popular restaurants can be fully booked days in advance.

Visiting other destinations in the region? Check out our other delicious guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.