Skip to Content

18 Best Italian Restaurants In OKC | 8 Must-Try Italian Restaurants In OKC

Sharing is caring!

Welcome to the heart of OKC, where the culinary scene isn’t just about the famed steaks and barbecues but also a secret haven for those who carry a torch for authentic Italian cuisine.

In this cozy city corner, Italian restaurants are not merely dining spots; they are portals whisking you straight to the cobblestone streets of Italy, offering a tantalizing escape with every bite.

From the rich, hearty lasagnas to the delicately crafted pizzas adorned with the freshest of ingredients, the Italian restaurants in OKC stand as a testament to the city’s diverse and ever-expanding food scene.

Best Italian Restaurants in OKC

As we embark on this gastronomic journey together, exploring the 7 best Italian Restaurants in OKC, prepare to be enveloped by tales of culinary mastery, secret recipes passed through generations, and the unparalleled joy of a perfectly twirled forkful of spaghetti.

Ready to dive into a world where every meal tells a story, and every story is a journey to Italy and back? Let’s go, amico!

My Top Three Picks of the Best Italian Restaurants In OKC

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
Bellini’s Ristorante & GrillPollo Spiedino5/5
Vito’s RistoranteChicken Carbonara4.5/5
Stella Modern Italian CuisineBlistered Shishito & Cauliflower, an exclusive find anywhere else appetizer in the menu.4.5/5

The 8 Best Italian Restaurants In OKC

Patrono

305 N Walker Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73102, United States // +14057027660

Under the soft, ambient lighting of Patrono, nestled in the heart of Oklahoma City, a culinary love story unfolds with every plate and pour. 

The moment you step into this haven of rustic Italian cuisine, you’re not just a guest; you’re family, embraced by the casually elegant atmosphere that whispers tales of distant Italian coasts and homely kitchens.

Pause your scrolling, dear friend, and allow me to whisk you away on a journey through an evening at Patrono, where the symphony of flavors and the warmth of hospitality intertwine to create more than a meal – an experience. 

A place where every reservation is a ticket to a delightful escapade into the rich, hearty soul of Italy, right here in OKC.

The first greeting comes not from the staff, but the tantalizing aroma of authentic Italian dishes, wafting through the air, promising a feast for the senses. 

And oh, what a feast it was! The bar, a stage where the bartender, with a magician’s finesse, crafts cocktails that are a harmonious blend, each sip a melody of perfectly balanced notes.

grilled octopus

The appetizers, a prelude to the culinary journey ahead, featured scallops and grilled octopus that danced with flavors so profound, they stopped the show before it even began. 

Each bite, a harmonious blend of the ocean’s freshness and the grill’s smoky kiss, was a revelation of what rustic Italian cuisine truly embodies.

And then, the steaks, a symphony of succulent, perfectly-seared beef that whispered secrets of Italian meadows and age-old cooking traditions, harmonizing beautifully with the delectable sides. 

Every dish, a chapter of its own, narrating stories of Italian landscapes, age-old recipes, and the unbridled joy of sharing a meal crafted with love and expertise.

Stella Modern Italian Cuisine

1201 N Walker Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73103, United States // +14052352200

A gentle murmur of lively conversations, the subtle crackling of a brick oven, and the rich, comforting aroma of baking dough envelop you as you step into Stella Modern Italian Cuisine, a gem tucked away in the bustling heart of midtown OKC. 

With its elegant room adorned with plush red banquettes and spacious seating, Stella doesn’t just invite you to dine; it welcomes you into an embrace of warmth, elegance, and culinary wonder.

Let’s stroll together down this flavorful lane, shall we?

The evening unfolded like a well-scripted play, where each dish made a grand entrance, captivating the senses with every bite and aroma. 

The Blistered Shishito & Cauliflower, a dish that surprisingly stole the spotlight, didn’t just please the palate but performed a mesmerizing dance of textures and flavors, leaving behind a longing for just one more bite. 

Oh, how I wish I had captured that moment with a photo, but some experiences are so rich, they etch themselves into your memory, needing no digital reminder.

Roasted Salmon

As the culinary journey continued, the Roasted Salmon gracefully swam onto the stage, its delicate seasoning whispering secrets of distant seas and its melt-in-your-mouth texture crafting a tender, flavorful narrative that lingered long after the plate was cleared.

And then, the pizza, a true ode to Italian culinary artistry, with a crust that was a cloud-like fusion of thin, soft perfection, and toppings that transported you straight to a quaint pizzeria in the heart of Europe. 

Each bite, a harmonious blend of authentic Italian flavors and modern culinary techniques, was a reminder of what happens when tradition and innovation dine at the same table.

Stella, with its inventive pastas, entrees, and that heavenly pizza, isn’t merely a restaurant; it’s a stage where culinary arts take the spotlight, enchanting you with every act, from appetizers to desserts.

Papa Dio’s Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar

10712 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73120, United States // +14057552255

Under the unassuming exterior of Papa Dio’s Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar, a world of culinary enchantment quietly unfolds, hidden in plain sight amidst the vibrant tapestry of OKC’s dining scene. 

Stepping inside, you’re greeted not just by the welcoming staff but by an aroma that promises a feast of authentic Italian delights, each dish a melody of flavors that sings of distant, sun-kissed Italian landscapes.

The atmosphere, particularly in the wine bar, is a comforting blend of elegance and homeliness, where glasses clink in cheerful toasts and the murmur of contented diners creates a melody that pairs perfectly with every bite and sip.

Navigating through their expansive menu, from pastas to veal & chicken entrees, each dish is a surprise, a delightful twist on classic Italian fare. 

shrimp pizza

Take, for instance, the shrimp pizza – a seemingly audacious culinary venture that marries the ocean’s bounty with Italy’s iconic dish, crafting a combination that is not just good but memorably exquisite. 

And the Italian sausage? A harmonious blend of spices and textures, it’s a testament to the perfection that arises when tradition meets expertise.

But beyond the plates and glasses, what truly defines Papa Dio’s is the warmth that permeates every interaction, every smile. 

Candace, with her friendly demeanor and genuine hospitality, doesn’t just host you; she welcomes you into a space that feels like a gathering at a friend’s home, where every meal is a celebration and every guest is cherished.

Whether you’re a reservation holder or a walk-in, a delightful Italian escapade awaits you here, where every dish is a journey and every visit is a cherished memory in the making.

Vito’s Ristorante

7628 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73116, United States // +14058484867

Next on the list is Vito’s Ristorante, a haven where refined Italian cuisine and conviviality blend seamlessly, crafting not just meals, but memories.

Nestled in the vibrant heart of OKC, this dinner-only trattoria and bar is not merely a restaurant; it’s a warm embrace, welcoming you into a world where every dish is a celebration of authentic Italian flavors, crafted with love and served with joy.

Let’s wander together through an evening at Vito’s, shall we?

The atmosphere, cozy and brimming with genuine hospitality, invites you to unwind and indulge, while the promise of great Italian food, expertly crafted by Kathy and her team, beckons tantalizingly from the kitchen.

And oh, the bread – a symphony of simplicity and homeliness, with its homemade charm and a garlic olive oil companion that whispers rather than shouts, enticing you to linger over every bite.

Journeying further into the menu, the calamari takes center stage, lightly breaded, boasting a flavor and texture that dances delightfully across the palate, accompanied by a marinara that is more a partner than a side, elevating each bite into a harmonious duet of sea and sauce.

seafood stew

Salads, fresh and vibrant, pave the way for the heartier tales of the menu to unfold. 

The seafood stew, a potpourri of the ocean’s finest offerings, bathes in a broth that is both comforting and exhilarating, each spoonful a gentle tide that carries flavors of distant shores and homely kitchens. 

Meanwhile, the Chicken Carbonara, with its creamy sauce cascading over penne pasta and enveloping the lightly breaded chicken, tells a story of Italian countryside and culinary traditions, passed down through generations.

And as the curtain falls, the Tiramisu takes a bow, a towering masterpiece of nearly 6 inches, each layer a verse of its own, singing of rich mascarpone, delicate coffee, and the sweet embrace of cocoa. Paired with a coffee, it’s a finale that lingers sweetly, long after the last bite.

Vito’s Ristorante, with its largest Irish whiskey selection of any Italian restaurant globally, isn’t just a dining destination; it’s a place where culinary artistry and heartfelt hospitality converge, creating an exquisite dining experience that transcends the ordinary.

Bellini’s Ristorante & Grill

6305 Waterford Blvd STE 100, Oklahoma City, OK 73118, United States // +14058481065

Tucked away behind the unassuming guise of a parking garage, Bellini’s Ristorante & Grill quietly whispers an invitation to a culinary journey where traditional Italian entrees, pizza, and a dash of American cuisine are the stars of a delectable show. 

This elegant hideaway, nestled in the vibrant heart of OKC, is not merely a restaurant; it’s a secret waiting to be discovered, where every dish is a treasure and every moment is steeped in warm, Italian hospitality.

Navigating through the initial maze, the reward is immediate – a welcoming embrace of nice ambience that gently nudges away the hustle of the outside world. 

The atmosphere, a harmonious blend of comfort and elegance, invites you to settle in, whether in the cozy interior or on the cherished covered patio, a personal favorite spot of many a regular.

Bellini’s, with its wonderful food, great drinks, and commendable service, isn’t just a dining spot; it’s a place where every meal is a cherished memory in the making. 

Arancini

The Arancini, a delightful prelude, sets the stage for a culinary narrative that unfolds with each subsequent course. 

And oh, the Pollo Spiedino – a dish so enchanting, it beckons you back, time and time again, even as the rest of the menu tempts with its myriad of tantalizing options.

But beyond the plates and glasses, what truly defines Bellini’s is the heartfelt hospitality and the genuine joy that permeates every interaction, every shared laugh, and every clink of glasses in cheerful toasts.

Osteria

6430 Avondale Dr, Oklahoma City, OK 73116, United States // +14052545058

A serendipitous Saturday evening led us to the welcoming embrace of Osteria, a phenomenal nook in OKC where Italian culinary tales are woven with flavors, aromas, and the kind of hospitality that turns first-time visitors into regulars. 

This wonderful spot, perfect for a leisurely late lunch or a heartwarming dinner, isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a canvas where exquisite dining experiences are crafted and cherished memories are painted.

From the moment we stepped in, the friendly and helpful staff ushered us into a world where every dish is a journey through the rustic Italian countryside. 

The Cornish hen and mushrooms, a plate where simplicity met sophistication, was a melody of flavors that sang of homely kitchens and age-old recipes. 

Each bite, a perfect harmony of savory and earthy notes, was a gentle nod to the authenticity that defines Osteria’s menu.

Cornish hen

On the other side of the table, the slow-braised beef ravioli whispered tales of Italian meadows and slow, simmering pots, each morsel a tender embrace of rich, hearty goodness that left a lingering warmth with every bite.

The atmosphere, casual yet imbued with an understated elegance, crafted a backdrop where the food took center stage, yet every detail, from the swift, attentive service to the ease of online reservations, played a supporting role that elevated the overall experience into something truly memorable.

Osteria, with its fair prices and a menu where quality and authenticity shine through every dish, is more than a dining destination; it’s a place where culinary dreams are realized and where every visit is a celebration of true Italian flavors.

Frankie’s Italian Restaurant

2724 W Britton Rd, Oklahoma City, OK 73120, United States // +14058496565

For the last place on the list we got Frankie’s, which is a genuine gem that sparkles with warmth, friendliness, and the kind of Italian cuisine that transports you straight to a family kitchen in the Italian countryside. 

This isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a homecoming, where every dish is a hearty welcome and every moment is steeped in familial warmth.

From the very first step inside, the cozy and warm ambiance wraps around you like a gentle hug from an old friend, while the outstanding food promises not just a meal, but an experience, a journey through the rich, hearty landscapes of Italian culinary traditions.

The pasta, oh, the pasta! A reminiscent echo of a bygone Italian adventure, it’s arguably the best since the homeland of pasta itself. 

The homemade rolls, airy and kissed with a hint of pizza oven char, whisper tales of family recipes and shared meals around a bustling kitchen table.

Pasta Tuscany

And then, the Pasta Tuscany – a dish that doesn’t just satisfy your palate but enchants it, weaving a tapestry of flavors with penne, chicken, and large shrimp, all basking in a sauce that is a nostalgic nod to a classic vodka sauce. 

It’s a plate so divine, it compels you to share the joy, to invite others into this delightful secret you’ve discovered.

Frankie’s, family-owned and radiating a homely charm, is more than a dining spot; it’s a place where every bite is a memory, every dish is a story, and every visit is a cherished chapter in your own culinary journey.

So, here’s an invitation, not just to a restaurant, but to a family, to a home where Italian flavors are celebrated, shared, and savored with every visit.

Bring your friends, share the joy, and let’s give this lovely family all the appreciation their culinary artistry deserves.

Tellers

120 N Robinson Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73102, United States  // +14059006789

Nestled in Oklahoma, we found a place with a very interesting name, especially because we found many interesting and and inspirational stories inside this place.

 Tellers serve up truly authentic Italian cuisine in Oklahoma with a commendable wait staff and an emphasis on dishes with brandy. The menu boasts classics such as Rigatoni al Forno, Margherita Pizza and Spaghetti Cacio e Pepe.

Many people have told me that the dishes are considered as reminiscent of those in Italy and comparable to their Italian grandmother’s home cooking.

Spaghetti Cacio e Pepe at Tellers

I praised the quality and preparation of their meals, particularly the Pork Chop alla Cacciatore, which was highlighted as an “outstanding preparation on a great cut of meat.”

The place has extensive Italian wine list as another testament to Tellers’ commitment to authentic Italian experiences. Comments also commended the service as being high-quality and attentive, contributing significantly to their overall dining experiences.

Overall, Tellers was praised as one of the best Italian restaurants in Oklahoma City, offering a blend of exquisite cuisine, a wide array of wines, and top-notch service.

Best Italian Restaurants in Oklahoma: To Visit List

1. Spazio Ristorante

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 10600 S Pennsylvania Ave #10, Oklahoma City, OK 73170, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.1 out of 332 reviews 

2.  Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 1844 Northwest Expy, Oklahoma City, OK 73118, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.3 out of 3100 reviews 

3. Italian Express

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 119 W Main St #101, Oklahoma City, OK 73102, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.8 out of 241 reviews

4. Fazoli’s

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 6821 Northwest Expy, Oklahoma City, OK 73132, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.5 out of 1600 reviews 

5. Pepperoni Grill – Memorial Rd

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 5620 W Memorial Rd, Oklahoma City, OK 73142, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.3 out of 384 reviews 

6. Cafe 7

  1. Cuisine: Italian, Cafe
  2. Location: 14101 N May Ave #117, Oklahoma City, OK 73134, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.6 out of 951 reviews

7. Falcone’s Pizzeria

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location:  6705 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73116, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.6 out of 1275 reviews

8. Emma Elle’s Italian Kitchen

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 4401 Grant Blvd ste 3, Yukon, OK 73099, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.3 out of 319 reviews 

9. Italia Express Pizza & Pasta

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 12203 Warwick Dr, Oklahoma City, OK 73162, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.3 out of 238 reviews

10. Johnny Carino’s

  1. Cuisine: Italian
  2. Location: 7900 S Walker Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73139, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Reviews: 4.0 out of 2100 reviews 

FAQs

What makes OKC’s Italian restaurants stand out in the culinary world?

The Italian restaurants in OKC bring a delightful blend of authentic Italian flavors and Oklahoman hospitality to the table. 

It’s a unique fusion where traditional Italian recipes meet local ingredients, creating a dining experience that’s both familiar and exotic. In this family-style and Italian-americAmerican restaurants you will find perfect carbonara, gnocchi, perfectly cooked mussels featuring another amazing entree proving that Italian food in Oklahoma City is a neat. 

From family-owned trattorias to elegant dining spots, OKC’s Italian food scene is a rich tapestry of culinary artistry and genuine warmth.

What Italian dishes are a must-try when visiting an Italian restaurant in OKC?

While each restaurant will have its own signature dishes, classics like Margherita Pizza, Osso Buco, Tiramisu, and various pasta dishes like Carbonara or Bolognese are often crowd-pleasers. 

Don’t forget to explore the chef’s specials and seasonal offerings for a unique culinary adventure!

Can I expect a good wine selection at Italian restaurants in OKC?

Oh, most certainly! Italian cuisine and wine go hand in hand, and many Italian restaurants in OKC boast an impressive selection of wines. 

From robust reds and crisp whites to everything in between, you’ll find wines that beautifully complement your meal, enhancing every flavor and note.

Wrapping Up: The 8 Best Italian Restaurants In OKC

Embarking on a culinary journey through the vibrant Italian food scene in Oklahoma City has been nothing short of a delightful escapade, where every bite tells a story and every dish is a celebration of authentic, heartwarming flavors. 

From the cozy, family-run trattorias to the elegant, upscale ristorantes, OKC unfurls a rich tapestry of Italian dining experiences that beckon to both the curious foodie and the seasoned gastronome. 

It’s a city where Italian culinary traditions are not just preserved but are blooming, intertwining seamlessly with the warm, welcoming spirit of Oklahoman hospitality, as evident from the brandy-infused dishes served by well-trained wait staff. 

As we sauntered through the myriad of flavors, from the robust, hearty pastas to the delicately crafted pizzas and the sweet, lingering kisses of traditional desserts, it was evident that the Italian restaurants in OKC are not merely establishments; they are portals to Italy, offering a slice of its rich culinary heritage right here in the heartland of America. 

So, whether you’re seeking a casual, hearty meal, a romantic, candlelit dinner, or a lively, family feast, the Italian restaurants in OKC await, ready to transport you to the cobblestone streets of Italy with every bite. 

Here’s to many more delicious adventures in the charming culinary landscape of Oklahoma City!

Visiting other destinations in Oklahoma? Check out our other delicious guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.