Skip to Content

The 6 Best Italian Restaurants In Bar Harbor, Maine

Sharing is caring!

Bar Harbor is surrounded by picturesque landscapes, including rocky coastlines, lush forests, and pristine lakes. The town’s location offers breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean and nearby islands.

It’s known for its stunning coastal beauty and outdoor activities, and we completely enjoy them. It also offers a variety of dining options, including Italian restaurants. 

These restaurants aim to provide a relaxing dining experience with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is typically cozy and welcoming, often featuring views of the ocean.

Best Italian restaurants in Bar Harbor

While seafood is often the star of the dining scene, and we are truly lovers of seafood, Italian restaurants in Bar Harbor offer a delectable departure, introducing a taste of Italy’s rich gastronomic heritage to this coastal haven.

The marriage of Italian flavors and Bar Harbor’s coastal ambiance creates a fusion that tantalizes both the palate and the senses. Among the collection of dining restaurants, a handful of Italian restaurants have carved out their niche, enriching the town’s culinary diversity.

In addition, we prepared a list for you of the best Italian restaurants we visited in this lovely city. Hopefully, you will have a chance to visit them and enjoy the touch of Italy in the heart of Bar Harbor.  

Top Three Italian Restaurants in Bar Harbor

RestaurantTop PickOur Rating
La Bella VitaStrawberry Burrata Salad5/5
Rosalie’s PizzaGarlic Bread4.5/5
testa’s bar & grillseafood alfredo4/5

The 6 Best Italian Restaurants in Bar Harbor

La Bella Vita

2 Academy Pl, Orleans, MA 02653, United States  +17743164454

La Bella Vita at Bar Harbor Regency stands as a testament to the harmonious blend of two worlds – coastal Maine and the Italian countryside. 

We thoroughly enjoyed sourced seafood offered in a simple venue with a covered terrace. The ambiance was lovely and brought back memories from the time we visited Italy. 

As one steps into this Italian oasis, the inviting aroma of herbs and sauces immediately transports visitors to the heart of Italy. With a commitment to using locally sourced ingredients, the restaurant offers a tantalizing array of pasta dishes, each crafted with meticulous attention to detail. 

We ordered Arancini and Strawberry Burrata Salad together with fried artichokes, margarita pizza which was delicious, thin crispy crust and flavorful toppings.

Strawberry Burrata Salad

For dessert, we had tiramisu which was insanely good and exceeded our expectations for a five-star tiramisu.  

The sound of gentle waves outside serves as a backdrop to a dining experience that encapsulates the essence of both coastal Maine and the Mediterranean. 

La Bella Vita is a culinary haven in Bar Harbor that masterfully marries the essence of Italy with the coastal charm of Maine. It’s an invitation to savor life’s finer moments, revel in flavors that transcend borders, and create memories that linger long after the last bite. 

If you’re seeking a dining experience that’s both elegant and heartwarming, La Bella Vita is the destination you’ve been searching for.

Mama Dimatteo’s

34 Kennebec Pl, Bar Harbor, ME 04609, United States  +12072883666

From the moment we stepped into Mamma DiMatteo’s we realized that this restaurant  presents a more casual take on Italian-American comfort food. 

The warm and convivial atmosphere echoes the spirit of family gatherings, where hearty pasta dishes and generously topped pizzas are meant to be shared among loved ones. 

This restaurant encapsulates the idea that food is not just sustenance but a conduit for togetherness and connection, echoing the Italian philosophy that nourishment extends beyond the plate.

Embodying the nice ambiance and the friendly vibes of the restaurant staff, we enjoyed delicious cocktails together with elevated pasta dishes.

We ordered Fettuccine Alfredo, Mushroom Crostini, and Sauteed Vegetables and clam chowder. Our standout was this beloved American soup.

It had simple yet satisfying ingredients. It consists of tender minced or chopped clams, a mix of quahogs and ocean clams, combined with diced potatoes, onions, and sometimes celery.  Very tasty.

clam chowder

Another dish we recommend is Pan Browned Gnocchi. It was soft, pillowy dumplings traditionally made from mashed potatoes, flour, and often eggs. It was crispy and tender, simple yet rich in flavor.

Mamma DiMatteo’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an embodiment of the Italian spirit of togetherness and culinary heritage. With its inviting ambiance, classic dishes, and heartwarming pizzas, it’s a place where flavors mingle and memories are made. 

If you’re seeking a taste of Italy’s soulful comfort in the heart of Bar Harbor, Mamma DiMatteo’s is the place to be. It’s a treasure trove of flavors that will leave you craving not just the food, but the feeling of being part of something truly special.

Rosalie’s Pizza

46 Cottage St, Bar Harbor, ME 04609, United States  +12072885666

In the heart of Bar Harbor, Rosalie’s Pizza adds a touch of Italy to the town’s pizza scene. 

While not exclusively Italian, the restaurant pays homage to Italian flavors through its thin-crust pizzas that are generously adorned with a medley of toppings. 

Rosalie’s embodies the casual spirit of Italian trattorias, where locals and tourists alike gather for a satisfying and flavorful meal.

We really like the attention the restaurant’s staff gives to all restaurant guests. Due to their recommendations, we ordered Sausage Mushrooms Onion Pizza, House Veggie Pizza, Garlic Bread, and Calzone. 

Jalapeños pizza

Green pepper and Jalapeños pizza are also must-try if you are a fan of pizza and want to explore different tastes and toppings. 

We really care for you and your food needs, whenever you are traveling, so if you are lucky to visit Bar Harbor, don’t waste your time, go and visit this place. 

Rosalie’s Pizza is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts in Bar Harbor. With their commitment to authenticItalian pizza, generous portions, and friendly service, they have become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. 

Testa’s Bar & Grill

53 Main St, Bar Harbor, ME 04609, United States  +12072883327

Nestled in the heart of Bar Harbor, Testa’s Bar & Grill is a true gem that captures the essence of exceptional dining. 

From the moment you step through its doors, you’re transported into a world of flavors, ambience, and hospitality that leaves an indelible mark on your senses.

From mouth watering appetizers that awaken your senses to main courses that elevate comfort food to an art form, Testa’s culinary offerings are a testament to the chef’s skill and creativity.

All my praises go to Lobster Mac and cheese as a standout. The beauty of this dish  lies in the harmony between the contrasting textures and flavors.

The lobster was tender and tender, and  meat added an elegant, briny sweetness that complements the creamy cheese sauce. 

They also make great  chicken alfredo with homemade sauce. 

We also have seafood alfredo and we truly loved it. Great flavorful seafood portion with shrimps, lobster and scallops in a rich and creamy sauce.

The lobster cargot is also amazing and the presentation of the oysters is true art.

seafood chowder

The seafood chowder is a standout, marrying the freshest catch with a velvety, flavorful broth that warms both the heart and soul.

The lobster dishes, a quintessential coastal experience, are prepared with a masterful touch that pays homage to Maine’s rich maritime heritage.

Testa’s Bar & Grill is more than a restaurant; it’s a destination that invites you to immerse yourself in a world of culinary delights and exceptional service.

From the carefully curated menu to the inviting ambiance and the warmth of the staff, every element of Testa’s is designed to create an unforgettable dining experience. 

Whether you’re indulging in seafood by the coast or savoring a perfectly prepared steak, Testa’s is a place where every moment is a celebration of taste, ambiance, and the joy of sharing a meal with loved ones.

La Bella Vita at Bar Harbor Regency

123 Eden St, Bar Harbor, ME 04609, United States  +12078013979

I had the pleasure of experiencing the exquisite charm and unparalleled luxury of La Bella Vita at Bar Harbor Regency.

Upon entering La Bella Vita, I was greeted by a warm and professional staff that made me feel like a cherished guest. The attention to detail was evident in every aspect of the resort, from the elegantly decorated lobby to the thoughtfully designed rooms.

I had omelet for breakfast and fish and chips for dinner.

We are grateful that we had a chance to visit this place twice during our stay in Bar Harbor. Whether indulging in a sumptuous breakfast with a view of the sunrise or savoring a romantic dinner under the stars, each meal is a masterpiece of flavors and presentation.

We had a very good tomato salad with burrata cheese, wood oven pizza and an awesome desert!

tomato salad

The combination of stunning scenery, impeccable service, and luxurious amenities creates an atmosphere that is both enchanting and rejuvenating. 

Whether you’re looking for a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a place to unwind, this resort promises an unforgettable escape into the lap of luxury. My stay at La Bella Vita will forever be etched in my memory as a perfect example of the “beautiful life.”

Pat’s Pizza of Bar Harbor

6 Pleasant St, Bar Harbor, ME 04609, United States  +12072885117

Upon entering Pat’s Pizza, the cozy and casual ambiance set the tone for a relaxed dining experience. The restaurant exudes a welcoming charm, making it an ideal spot for families, friends, or even solo diners looking to enjoy a scrumptious meal.

The menu at Pat’s Pizza is diverse, offering a range of options beyond just pizza. While the main focus is undoubtedly their pizza offerings, the menu also features appetizers, salads, subs, and pasta dishes. 

Now, onto the main star: the pizza. I opted for a classic pepperoni and mushroom pizza, and it certainly didn’t disappoint.

The crust was a perfect balance of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, with just the right amount of chewiness.

The tomato sauce had a delightful tanginess that paired well with the generous toppings, and the cheese was melted to perfection. Each bite was a burst of flavors that showcased the quality ingredients used.

mushroom pizza

Aside from the pizza, I sampled their garlic knots as an appetizer, and they were a hit. Warm, doughy, and infused with a satisfying garlic and butter flavor, they were a great way to start the meal.

Pat’s Pizza of Bar Harbor is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and anyone looking for a casual and enjoyable dining experience.

With its wide array of menu options, inviting ambiance, and flavorful dishes, it’s a place where you can satisfy your pizza cravings and leave with a happy palate. 

My visit to Pat’s Pizza was a tasty escapade that left me with a newfound appreciation for the local dining scene in Bar Harbor.

Foodies Also Ask About The Best Italian Restaurants in Bar Harbor

What kind of Italian restaurants in Bar Harbor can we expect? 

In Bar Harbor, you can expect a variety of Italian restaurants that cater to different dining preferences and experiences. 

Pizzerias in Bar Harbor might specialize in crafting authentic Italian-style pizzas. Thin-crust, wood-fired, or brick-oven pizzas with a variety of toppings are common offerings. Some pizzerias may also serve pasta dishes and salads alongside their pizza menu.

Some Italian cafes or bistros might offer lighter fare, such as paninis, salads, and pastries, along with espresso-based beverages.

These spots could be ideal for a quick lunch or a coffee break. Casual Italian restaurants aim to provide a more relaxed and laid-back atmosphere.

They may emphasize comfort food and familiar Italian-American dishes like pasta, pizzas, and sandwiches. These restaurants are often family-friendly and welcoming to a wide range of diners.

Bar Harbor offers plenty of options if you are seeking tasty Italian food echoing the Italian philosophy that nourishment extends beyond the plate.

Are these Italian restaurants in Bar Harbor expensive?

The pricing of Italian restaurants in Bar Harbor can vary depending on several factors, including the specific restaurant, its location within the city, the cuisine offered, and the level of service and ambiance.


Even as the Italian influence weaves through Bar Harbor’s dining landscape, it’s important to acknowledge that the town’s unique character remains unaltered.

The Italian restaurants are not simply transplantations of Italy’s culinary treasures but reinterpretations that reflect the local culture and ethos.

They offer a glimpse into the global village we inhabit, where different cuisines harmoniously coexist, creating a tapestry of flavors that enrich our lives.

In conclusion, the Italian restaurants of Bar Harbor encapsulate the town’s ability to merge diverse elements into a harmonious whole.

Amidst the rugged coastal beauty and the allure of outdoor adventure, these restaurants stand as culinary ambassadors, offering a taste of Italy’s rich gastronomic legacy.

From the elegant sophistication of La Bella Vita to the comfort-driven embrace of Mamma DiMatteo’s and the casual charm of Rosalie’s, each restaurant brings its own unique flavor to the tapestry of Bar Harbor’s culinary scene.

These Italian havens enrich the town, enhancing its cultural and culinary diversity, and inviting visitors and locals alike to partake in an Italian culinary journey while immersed in the enchanting surroundings of coastal Maine.

While in Bar Harbor don’t miss out on activities that will help immerse yourself with the city (hurry while they’re hot!):

Visiting Bar Harbor? Check out our other delicious guides:


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.