The Best Pizza In St Petersburg FL

St. Petersburg, FL: where sunshine meets a rich tapestry of culture, art, and, yes, an absolutely irresistible food scene.

It might surprise you, but nestled between the renowned seafood restaurants and trendy vegan joints, the pizza parlors of this city are a world unto themselves.

Now, before you jump to conclusions, hear me out. In a place where the ocean’s bounty often steals the limelight, St. Pete’s pizza spots have carved out a niche that’s undeniably flavorful and innovative.

6 Spots For The Best Pizza In St Petersburg FL

Close your eyes and picture it. The rhythmic lull of waves nearby, the vibrant city ambiance, and right in the middle of it all, a slice of pizza that’s the stuff of dreams.

This isn’t just about gooey cheese or the perfect crust; it’s about an experience that fuses tradition with modern flair. Every bite tells a story of the city’s diverse culinary influences.

So, are you game? Let’s embark on this gastronomic adventure together and unearth the best pizza in St. Petersburg Fl.

Trust me, by the end of it; you’ll be echoing my sentiment: this city knows its pizza!

Table of Contents

Top Three Picks of the Best Pizza Spots In St Petersburg, FL

Restaurant	Top Pick	Our Rating
Gianni’s NY Pizza	South Philly Pizza	5/5
Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta	White Pizza	5/5
Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen	Pepperoni pizza	4.5/5

The 6 Spots For The Best Pizza In St Petersburg FL

Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen

210 1st Ave N, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, United States // +17278226757

In the heart of St. Petersburg, Florida, tucked away amidst the bustling streets and sunshine, is a gem of a pizzeria that I simply couldn’t resist exploring: Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen.

Now, when I say “famous,” I’m not throwing that term around lightly. This place is the real deal.

Joey Brooklyn’s isn’t just another pizza joint; it’s a slice of authentic New York right in St. Pete. Casual and cozy, with a laid-back vibe, you can spot people from all walks of life grabbing a late-night bite here.

One of the things that struck me, apart from their drool-worthy menu, was their genuine commitment to quality. They handcraft their pizzas with precision, letting the dough ferment just right before it becomes the base for a myriad of toppings.

And trust me; freshness is the name of the game here. From the crispiest veggies to the most succulent meats, everything screams quality.

Being a fan of options, I appreciate that Joey Brooklyn’s caters to all. Vegan or vegetarian? They’ve got you covered.

And their extensive menu doesn’t stop at pizzas. They offer hearty calzones, pasta that tastes straight out of an Italian grandmother’s kitchen, refreshing salads, and even a delectable range of beverages.

Now, let’s talk about my experience. I remember waiting in line, the buzz of anticipation palpable.

I went for the classic pepperoni pizza and couldn’t resist adding a slice of their strawberry/key lime cake. Let me tell you, every bite was worth the hype. The pizza? Divine. The cake? The cherry on top.

And the best part? No leftovers because every slice was devoured with gusto by me and my three friends.

Customer service? Top-notch, with a sprinkle of humor. The place, though buzzing, was spotless. Sure, it might be a tad pricier than your average pizzeria, but every bite validates that extra buck.

Joey Brooklyn’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience. And next time? I’m diving into their specials. St. Petersburg folks, if you haven’t been here yet, what are you waiting for?

Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta

6000 4th St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33703, United States // +17275212656

St. Petersburg has its fair share of eateries, but there’s something truly special about Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta.

Tucked away as a treasured spot since 1974, this Italian joint boasts more than just your typical pizza-pasta affair.

Strolling into Paisano’s is like stepping into a cozy neighborhood gathering. The ambiance shouts family-friendly, and if you’re a fan of buffets (who isn’t?), their lunch spread is not to be missed.

But what caught my eye during my visit was the salad bar. Now, I’ll admit, I didn’t opt for a salad that day, but the vibrant, fresh produce was truly a sight to behold, and I’ve mentally bookmarked it for my next visit.

But let’s talk about the real star of the show – the pizza. I took the plunge and ordered the Great White pizza. A single bite, and I was sold.

I’ve been to a lot of pizza places in St. Pete, but nothing quite compares to this. The harmonious blend of the tangy tomato sauce with that delightful cheese – it’s what pizza dreams are made of.

However, the standout for me? The Pizza Bones, also known as their iconic breadsticks. This isn’t just any breadstick; it’s a symphony of flavors.

Made from the same dough as their pizzas, they have this authentic crunch that only a traditional pizza oven can achieve.

And when slathered in their uber-garlicky butter sauce? Divine. Dip it into the meaty marinara sauce they generously serve on the side, and you’re in for a treat.

So, if you’re craving a slice of heaven (or a plate of delicious pasta or maybe some delightful happy hour specials), Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta is the place to be.

A bite here, and you’ll understand why it’s been a beloved spot for nearly half a century. Until next time, happy eating!

Paul’s Chicago Pizza St. Pete

11002 4th St N, St. Petersburg , FL 33716, United States // +17273465180

Nestled in a quaint strip-mall in St. Petersburg, Florida, lies an eatery that’s bound to change your pizza perceptions – Paul’s Chicago Pizza St. Pete.

Now, before you roll your eyes and think, “Another Chicago-style joint?” hear me out, especially if you’re as deeply rooted in the New York/New Jersey pizza debate as I am.

You see, I was always a firm believer that New York-style pizza was the zenith of pie perfection. But oh, how the tables have turned after my culinary adventure at Paul’s!

When most of us hear “Chicago Style Pizza,” we’re quick to conjure up images of that dense deep dish.

But get this: Chicago boasts not one, not two, but three distinct pizza styles. And would you believe that the thin crust reigns supreme in the Windy City, leaving the deep dish often reserved for tourists?

During my visit to Paul’s, I naturally gravitated towards their thin crust, which, by the way, was perfection on a plate.

The meat, sauce, and cheese harmonized in a way that made every bite sing. What’s intriguing is how they serve it – be it round, square, or rectangular, they slice it into bite-sized squares. Perfect for sharing, though you might be reluctant to!

Diving deeper into Chicago’s pizza realm, I learned about the Deep Dish and Stuffed pizzas. Think pies, not flatbreads.

They’re layered in reverse, with the sauce generously ladled on top. While Paul’s in St. Pete has shelved their stuffed pizza offering, those craving it can find solace in their Clearwater location.

So, if you’re on the hunt for an authentic slice of Chicago without hopping on a plane, Paul’s Chicago Pizza St. Pete has got your back for the best pizza in St Petersburg FL.

Tony’s Pizza

533 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, United States // +17278964444

In the heart of St. Petersburg, amongst the bustling streets, there’s a hidden gem that any pizza lover shouldn’t miss: Tony’s Pizza.

Now, as someone who’s forever chasing that perfect slice, believe me when I say, Tony’s comes pretty darn close to that iconic NY style we all dream about.

And the secret? They import their water straight from New York State. If that isn’t dedication to authenticity, I don’t know what is.

On a serendipitous stroll through downtown St. Pete, my nose led me straight to Tony’s. Let me tell you, it wasn’t just luck, it was fate.

Every bite of their all Meat pizza was reminiscent of my countless excursions to the Big Apple. The crust? Oh, it struck that elusive balance between thin, chewy, and just the right hint of crisp. It’s no exaggeration to say it was the best pizza I’ve treated my taste buds to in quite some time.

And speaking of treats, we kicked off our meal with jalapeño poppers. But these weren’t your ordinary poppers; biting into one, I was met with a whole fresh pepper! A delightful departure from the usual diced fare you get elsewhere.

The service? Swift, with a side of warmth and friendliness. My only tiny gripe was the parking. Given its prime downtown location, spots were hard to come by.

We managed about two blocks away, which turned into a lovely short walk on a beautiful day.

So, St. Pete dwellers or visitors, if you’re craving a slice that’ll whisk you straight to the streets of New York, Tony’s Pizza is your spot for the best pizza in St Petersburg FL.

And while the parking might test your patience a tad, I promise, every bite will affirm that it’s all worth it. Until next time, keep those pizza dreams alive!

4th Street Pizza

3187 4th St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33704, United States // +17278958178

Nestled in the vibrant heart of St. Petersburg, Florida, is a gem of a place that has redefined my pizza experiences – say hello to 4th Street Pizza.

Now, I’ve had my fair share of pizza escapades in St. Pete, and while some eateries hit the mark, others? Not so much. But, my friends, 4th Street Pizza isn’t just a hit; it’s a home run. Here’s why it has one of the best pizza in St Petersburg FL.

At 4th Street, they understand the art of pizza personalization. Whether you’re team half-and-half or all-in, they’ve got you.

And the crust? It’s the culinary sweet spot between thick and thin, always baked to perfection, striking that balance I never knew I needed.

Let’s talk flavors. Ever heard of the Dali’s Dream? If not, you’re missing out on a four-cheese wonder. It’s my go-to base, and boy, is it dreamy. Now, here’s my pro-tip: top half of it with pepperoni and jalapeños.

But a heads-up for those who tread on the milder side of spice – these jalapeños pack a punch, seeds and all. Exactly the fiery kick I adore, but it might surprise the unassuming palate.

And while the Dali’s Dream does lean towards the pricier side, every bite reassures you it’s worth every cent.

Oh, and if you’re feeling a tad indulgent, upgrade to the garlic butter crust. Trust me on this one.

In the vast sea of pizza joints across St. Petersburg, 4th Street Pizza shines brightly. So, if you’ve been on the hunt for that perfect local pizza haven, look no further.

Dive in, savor the flavors, and thank me later. Here’s to more pizza adventures!

Gianni’s NY Pizza

936 58th St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33710, United States // +17273813209

St. Petersburg, Florida, is dotted with countless pizzerias, but if you’re hunting for a slice that’s authentically New York, I’ve got just the spot for you: Gianni’s NY Pizza.

Run by the passionate Johnny Colandrea, this place isn’t just serving pizzas – it’s dishing out slices of the Big Apple.

Now, I’ve been on a relentless quest to find the perfect NY-style pizza in St Pete, and let me tell you, the journey led me right to the doorstep of Gianni’s. One bite in, and I was transported straight to the bustling streets of New York.

The pizzas here? They’re in a league of their own. In fact, they’re so spot on that reaching for any condiments feels almost like a crime.

The ambiance? Pure New York! It’s relaxed, it’s casual, and you feel instantly at home. And just to sprinkle a bit more of that NYC magic, there’s the Vitale Brothers’ mural – a masterpiece that lends the space an air of authenticity.

St. Petersburg, Florida, is dotted with countless pizzerias, but if you’re hunting for a slice that’s authentically New York, I’ve got just the spot for you: Gianni’s NY Pizza.

Run by the passionate Johnny Colandrea, this place isn’t just serving pizzas – it’s dishing out slices of the Big Apple.

The pizzas here? They’re in a league of their own. In fact, they’re so spot on that reaching for any condiments feels almost like a crime.

Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza

3523 49th St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33710, United States // +17275222717

If you haven’t been to Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza in St. Pete, you’re missing out!

This place is a classic. It’s all about no-frills, great pizza, and a chill atmosphere. Think old-school pizzeria vibes where everyone’s welcome and the focus is squarely on the food.

Their New York-style pizza is legit. It’s got that thin, crispy crust that’s hard to find outside of New York. The toppings? Generous and tasty. You can tell they don’t cut corners. And the size of the pizzas, especially the large? Huge. Easily feeds a group.

Their Little Italy Special and White Pizza are must-tries. Each slice is a harmonious blend of flavors that’ll have you nodding in appreciation at the first bite.

Let’s not forget the garlic knots. If you’re a garlic fan, these are a must. Perfectly seasoned, buttery, just awesome.

The best part? The laid-back feel of the place. It’s counter service, so you order, grab a seat, and relax. No rush, no fuss. They’ve got draft beer too, which is a nice touch.

It’s been around since the ’70s for a reason. Great pizza, good times, no-nonsense!

Questions Foodies Ask About The best pizza in St Petersburg FL

Is St. Petersburg known for any specific style of pizza?

While St. Pete might not have its own signature pizza style like Chicago or New York, the city embraces a medley of pizza traditions. From thin crust to deep dish, and NY-style to Neapolitan, there’s something for every pizza lover here.

Is the pizza food scene here more traditional or experimental?

A bit of both, actually. While there are places that stick to the classics, there’s no shortage of pizzerias experimenting with innovative toppings and crusts. From gourmet toppings to unique fusion styles, the pizza scene in St. Pete is wonderfully diverse.

What’s the deal with garlic knots? Are they a big thing in St. Pete’s pizza places?

Oh, they certainly are! While pizza might be the star, garlic knots have carved out their own fan base in St. Petersburg. Soft, garlicky, and utterly delicious, many locals swear by them as the perfect side.

Wrapping Up: The 6 Spots For The Best Pizza In St Petersburg FL

As the sun sets over the shimmering waters of the Gulf, casting a golden hue over St. Petersburg, there’s an undeniable aroma wafting through the balmy Florida air – the scent of fresh pizza.

Yes, St. Pete, with its rich cultural tapestry and artsy vibes, is also a sanctuary for pizza enthusiasts.

And as we wrap up our gastronomic journey through its lanes, one thing’s for sure: this city truly celebrates the art of pizza-making.

Each bite of a St. Pete slice is a revelation. From the crispy crust that crackles just right, to the symphony of flavors from toppings sourced with love and care, pizza here isn’t just food; it’s an experience.

But what truly sets St. Petersburg’s pizza culture apart is its embrace of diversity. Whether you’re a purist who swears by the classics or an adventurous soul yearning for a gourmet twist, this city has got you covered.

Interestingly, it’s not just the variety that stands out. It’s the community’s fervor for pizza that turns an ordinary meal into an extraordinary event.

Friends gather, families bond, and stories are exchanged over shared pies, making memories that last far beyond that last slice.

The pizza scene here is also reflective of St. Pete’s larger ethos: a blend of tradition and innovation.

The city respects the age-old techniques that have made pizza a global favorite while also daring to experiment, ushering in fresh flavors and bold combinations.

In the end, as we savor the lingering tastes of the best pizza in St Petersburg FL, we realize that it’s not just about finding the “best” slice.

It’s about the love, the passion, and the community that comes together around it. St. Pete doesn’t just serve pizza; it celebrates it. And that, dear readers, is the true essence of a pizza paradise.

Check out some of my other guides for this foodie haven:

Igor Jovanovsky

Igor Jovanovski is an aspiring digital nomad, travel blogger and graphic designer who really loves food. He also has a creative side, and he works as a freelance graphic designer in his spare time. He has traveled across Europe quite a few times since he was young and recently started his mission to visit every country in the world! Igor’s favorite thing about traveling is the way he gets to know new people, food, places and cultures.
This exciting experience helps him create his own stories and make memories that will last forever