Skip to Content

Best Indian Restaurants In Rochester NY | 6 Must-Try Places

Sharing is caring!

Ever strolled through Rochester, NY, with a hankering for something spicy, aromatic, and utterly comforting? 

Well, buckle up, my fellow spice sojourners, because this city is a treasure trove of Indian culinary gems that are about to turn your cravings into a full-blown love affair with Indian cuisine.

Let’s embark on a flavorful journey through the streets of Rochester where the Indian food scene is as vibrant and diverse as the city itself. 

From the tucked-away enchantment of Taj Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine, offering steaming plates of malai kofta and bread baskets that could feed an army, to the inviting warmth of Haveli Indian Cuisine, where the Rogan Josh is as rich in flavor as the establishment is in elegance, there’s a story in every dish.

Then there’s the Royal of India, a place that’s not just about dining but about diving into a deep pool of spicy delights, where their thali is a palette of flavors and their chicken makhani, a buttery whisper of culinary excellence.

best Indian restaurants in rochester ny

Not to be outdone, India House Restaurant flaunts a buffet that promises a tour through the subcontinent, with each bite transporting you from the northern valleys to the southern coasts.

And for those who love a side of live tunes with their tikka, Tandoor of India Henrietta stands ready to serenade your senses, both auditory and gustatory. 

The mushroom balti there? Simply a must-try. Last but certainly not least, let’s not forget the unassuming yet unmistakable presence of Royal of India, where every dish is a vibrant celebration of traditional flavors.

Indian restaurants in Rochester NY are a testament to the city’s burgeoning food scene, a place where every meal is an adventure, and every bite tells the tale of a rich and ancient cuisine. 

So, are you ready to ditch the fork and grab a naan? Because Rochester’s Indian dining is calling, and it’s an invitation you don’t want to miss.

My Top Three Picks of the Best Indian Restaurants In Rochester NY

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
Amaya Indian CuisineSalmon tandoori5/5
Royal of IndiaPalak paneer 4.5/5
Taj Mahal Fine Indian CuisineBeef Vindaloo4.5/5

The 6 Best Indian Restaurants In Rochester NY

Amaya Indian Cuisine

1900 S Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States // +15852413223

Let’s start by talking about a culinary secret that’s too good to keep under wraps: Amaya Indian Cuisine, a spot in Rochester, NY, that’s dishing out traditional Indian flavors with a modern twist. 

It’s the kind of place that you stumble upon and can’t help but tell all your friends about.

From the moment you walk in, there’s a vibe that says ‘chill but sophisticated.’ With a full bar at your disposal, you can kick things off with a mango lassi with a kick or a smooth cocktail to set the tone for an unforgettable meal.

Now, let’s get to the good part – the food. The samosas? Think golden pockets of joy with the perfect crunch. And those momos are a masterclass in dumpling excellence. 

But hold on, because their baby lamb chops are a game-changer. They’re the kind of dish that has you closing your eyes with every bite, savoring the succulence that’s been perfected over time. 

The chicken Daab? It’s like a love letter to your taste buds, and the salmon tandoori? Let’s just say it dances on the edge of being scandalously good.

Even the curried goat, which is a bold choice for some, is a revelation at Amaya. It’s tender, it’s flavorful, and it’s got that home-cooked goodness you can’t replicate. 

And if you dive into their tandoori section, you’re in for a treat that’s nothing short of divine.

Salmon Tandoori at Amaya Indian Cusine

The service, you ask? Top-notch. The staff, led by a guy who could double as a stand-up comedian, ensures your water glass is never empty, your plate is always full, and your evening is sprinkled with laughter. 

It’s this blend of delightful dishes and warm service that makes Amaya not just the best Indian cuisine in Rochester but a family-owned gem where every detail matters.

Whether you’re a die-hard fan of Indian food or just dipping your toes in the aromatic waters of spices and flavors, Amaya Indian Cuisine is a place that’ll have you coming back for more.

Royal of India

300 Park Point Dr, Rochester, NY 14623, United States // +15853604418

You know that feeling when you’re craving something specific, and nothing else will do? That’s how I felt about Indian food in Rochester, where the hunt for that perfect spice and flavor often felt like a wild goose chase. 

Then, like a plot twist in a good novel, Royal of India came into the scene, and let me tell you, it was a plot twist I didn’t see coming.

Nestled in a corner that doesn’t scream ‘look at me’, this place is all about subtlety, including its approach to delivering some of the most authentic Indian dishes this side of the Atlantic. 

Walking in, you’re met with the kind of aromas that promise good things and—spoiler alert—they deliver.

First up, let’s talk about heat. Not all Indian restaurants get it right—some mistake ‘bland’ for ‘authentic.’ Not here. 

At Royal of India, when I asked for my dish to be hot, they brought the fire. And it wasn’t just hot, it was an orchestra of flavors where the heat played first violin.The Thali was a treasure trove with its palak paneer and chicken makhani stealing the show. Creamy, rich, and with just the right amount of tang, these dishes were the stars of their own show.

Palak Paneer at Royal of India

The channay and tikka could’ve used a little more of the spotlight, with the tikka getting a bit more of a char than one might sign up for, but it was a minor hiccup in an otherwise flavor-packed meal.

Now, for the Tandoori platter—oh, what a marvel! The malai boti was so tender, it practically melted in the mouth, while the kabab was a symphony of spices. 

And the shrimps, paired with sautéed vegetables, were the kind of dish that makes you want to abandon all pretense of sophistication and just dig in with both hands.

The portion sizes? Generous doesn’t begin to cover it. You’ll need to bring your appetite and maybe even some backup in the form of a friend or two. 

And throughout the meal, the service was nothing short of stellar. Prompt, attentive, and with a commendable knack for timing, the staff at Royal of India ensures that the only thing you need to focus on is the culinary journey they’re taking you on.

India House Restaurant

7343 NY-96, Victor, NY 14564, United States // +15857422030

Next, let’s cut to the chase: when your stomach is growling for Indian cuisine in Rochester, you don’t want to wade through a sea of mediocrity. 

You want the good stuff, the real deal. Enter India House Restaurant, a cozy spot that might not win any design awards but will absolutely take your taste buds on a first-class journey.

The first thing you’ll notice when you walk in isn’t what you’ll notice—it’s what you won’t. No overwhelming cooking smells that you’re trying to air out of your clothes for days. 

Instead, you’re greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere that says, “Relax, we’ve got this.”

Now, let’s talk about the buffet because if there’s one thing that gets me more excited than fresh bread, it’s a buffet that delivers. India House doesn’t just deliver; it’s like the culinary Santa Claus of lunchtime. 

A smorgasbord of North and South Indian dishes awaits, each tasting like it’s been made with the kind of love Grandma used to pour into her cooking.

From paneer that’ll make you ponder to chutneys that charm, it’s all there, fresh and beckoning.And the lamb biryani? Let’s just say it’s the dish that dreams are made of. It’s the headliner of a menu that knows its audience.

Lamb Biryani at India House Restaurant

Spicy food enthusiasts fear not—though the default setting is ‘friendly for all’, the chefs here are like DJs taking requests. Want it hot? They’ll turn it up to eleven.

Sure, the decor might be a bit ’90s sitcom living room’, but that’s not why we’re here. We’re here because the food does the talking, and it’s positively eloquent.

Service that’s as quick as it is friendly, prices that keep your wallet happy, and easy parking to boot? It’s all part of the package.

India House Restaurant is the kind of place you’ll go for the buffet but stay for the biryani. It’s where the ambiance is measured not in décor, but in deliciousness. 

Hats off to the proprietor for creating a place where the food shines brighter than any chandelier ever could.

Taj Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine

1742 Long Pond Rd STE 1, Rochester, NY 14606, United States // +15854340123

Ever stumble upon a place that makes you want to tell everyone you know, and yet, selfishly, you want to keep it all to yourself? That’s exactly how I felt about Taj Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine. 

Nestled in a corner of Rochester that might not scream ‘culinary hotspot’, this restaurant is a treasure trove of flavors waiting to be discovered.

From the moment the steaming hot dishes hit the table, you know you’re in for a treat. Let’s chat about that garlic naan for a second—fluffy, fragrant, and with just the right amount of garlic to make your taste buds sing without overwhelming them. 

It’s the perfect companion to every dish, especially when you’ve got malai kofta that melts in your mouth, and chana that’s so authentically spiced it transports you straight to the streets of Delhi.

But the beef vindaloo is where things get serious. It’s a fiery dance of flavors that’s not for the faint of heart but oh-so-rewarding for those who dare. And the paneer pakora? It’s like a love letter to cheese, wrapped in a crispy, golden-brown hug. Now, if you’re feeling bold, dive into the kasturi kebabs. They’re the kind of good that has you plotting your next visit before you’ve even finished your meal.

Beef Vindaloo at Taj Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine

{image} beef vindaloo {image}

Oh, and a word to the wise: when they say ‘bread basket’, they mean it. It’s a bountiful assortment of naan and kulcha that could probably double as a flotation device if you ever found yourself stranded at sea.

Taj Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine is more than just a meal; it’s an experience. It’s clean, the folks are friendlier than your neighbor with the toolshed, and every dish is a hit parade of taste and texture. 

Sure, the neighborhood has more grit than gloss, but trust me, one bite and you’ll see why it’s worth the adventure.

Tandoor of India Henrietta NY

376 Jefferson Rd, Rochester, NY 14623, United States // +15854277080

Stepping into Tandoor of India in Henrietta, NY, feels like walking into a story where every chapter serves up a new flavor. 

For someone dipping their toes into the rich waters of Indian cuisine for the first time, or the seasoned spice aficionado, this place is like finding the culinary pot of gold at the end of a rainbow.

From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm shawl. The lighting wasn’t just illumination—it was mood-setting, and the décor? It’s like stepping into a piece of India, with vibrant colors and intricate patterns that are a feast for the eyes.

Every corner of the room promised comfort, and the place hummed with the kind of energy that makes you want to stay a while, maybe forever.

Mushroom Balti at Tandoor of India Henrietta NY

Let’s talk about the Balti trio that stole the show: lamb, chicken, and mushroom Balti. Each dish was a masterpiece of taste, perfectly spiced and balanced, leaving your taste buds dancing long after the meal is over. 

The lamb was tender enough to pledge your loyalty to, the chicken was a dive into tradition with a twist of innovation, and the mushroom Balti was a revelation that would make even the staunchest meat-lover pause for thought.

But it wasn’t just the food that had me planning my next visit before the first was over; it was the service. 

The kind of attentive, personalized service that makes you feel like royalty. The staff moved with the kind of efficiency and grace that made the meal seamless.

Haveli Indian Cuisine

1635 E Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623, United States // +15854270430

As I crossed the threshold of Haveli Indian Cuisine in Rochester, NY, it was clear that this wouldn’t be just any dining experience. 

What met me was an elegant oasis, a stark contrast to the humble storefront that whispered promises of culinary delights to those who ventured inside.

The aroma of spices greeted me like an old friend, and the warm welcome from the owner, Arjun, made it feel like I was a guest in his home rather than a customer in his restaurant. 

His pride in Haveli shone through as brightly as the lights that bathed the elegant setting in a warm glow.

On to the feast—starting with the Chana Bhature, a dish where the puffed bread and chickpeas play a duet of soft and spicy, each bite better than the last. 

The Chicken Chow mein was a testament to the kitchen’s ability to fuse flavors in a symphony of savory satisfaction. It wasn’t just food; it was storytelling on a plate.As I looked around, my dining companions’ nods of approval over their Rogan Josh and Lamb Tikka Masala told me all I needed to know.

Chana Bhature at Haveli Indian Cuisine

The dishes were not just ‘good’—they were a culinary ballet, where flavors pirouetted around palates and left us all in applause. 

And let’s not forget the service; it was as if the staff had anticipated our every need, ensuring our water glasses were never empty and our plates always full.

With portions generous enough to satiate the heartiest of appetites and prices that didn’t leave your wallet feeling too light, Haveli stood out as a beacon of gastronomic excellence. It’s a place where every dish boasts a backstory of tradition, each spice has a tale to tell.

For anyone in search of an Indian dining experience in Rochester that is as authentic as it is memorable, Haveli Indian Cuisine is the place where your search ends and the journey to flavor begins.

Foodies Also Ask About The Indian Restaurants in Rochester

What makes Rochester’s Indian food scene unique?

Rochester’s Indian food landscape is as eclectic as it is delicious, boasting a blend of North and South Indian cuisines. 

Each restaurant, from the cozy Taj Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine to the spirited Tandoor of India Henrietta, brings its own blend of spices, atmosphere, and culinary traditions to the table. 

It’s a small but vibrant scene where the love for rich flavors and hearty meals is evident in every dish served.

Are there any Indian restaurants in Rochester that offer live music?

Yes, for those looking to spice up their dining experience with some melodies, Tandoor of India Henrietta occasionally features live music. It’s a delightful way to enjoy the robust flavors of your meal with an auditory backdrop that enhances the ambiance.

Is there a dress code for Indian restaurants in Rochester?

Rochester’s Indian dining scene is generally casual and welcoming. You don’t need to dress up unless you’re heading to a more upscale place like Haveli Indian Cuisine for a special occasion. 

Comfort is key, so wear whatever makes you ready to dive into a generous platter of biryani or a savory curry.

Wrapping Up: The 6 Best Indian Restaurants In Rochester NY

Wrapping up our culinary voyage through the vibrant Indian food scene of Rochester, NY, it’s clear that the city is a hidden gem for those who treasure the rich tapestry of flavors that Indian cuisine has to offer.

Each restaurant we’ve visited in spirit adds its own signature to the collective menu of the city, from the steamy, spice-infused curries that warm you from the inside out to the fresh breads that are a testament to the art of baking.

What sets Rochester apart is not just the authenticity of its Indian fare but the passion behind it. The chefs and restaurateurs here aren’t just cooking; they’re curating experiences, inviting diners to partake in a cultural journey that’s both exotic and familiar. 

It’s about community, a shared table where stories and samosas are passed with equal enthusiasm.

As you leave the table, full not just with food but with stories, you carry with you a sense of having traveled miles away without leaving the comfort of this upstate New York haven. 

Rochester’s best Indian restaurants aren’t just eateries; they’re gateways to an ancient culture served up one delicious meal at a time. 

So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, let the city’s Indian cuisine be a must-visit on your gastronomic bucket list.

Visiting other destinations in New York? Check out our other delicious guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.