Skip to Content

The Best Pizza In Philadelphia | 13 Must-Try Restaurants for Pizza In Philly, Updated May 2024

Sharing is caring!

Looking for where to find the best pizza in Philadelphia? You’ve come to the right place!

There’s nothing like a carefully crafted slice of pizza. Philadelphia is home to hundreds of pizza joints, each filled with hungry locals and tourists looking for a delicious slice. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia : Philadelphia

Philadelphia’s pizza scene, locally and nationally regarded, has splintered into so many creative factions that it took a lot of debate and some heavy-lifting to come up with this article. 

I went in with a certain mindset and was quickly challenged by crust thicknesses, sauce recipes, inventive toppings — pretty much anything you can think of that goes on pizza. 

My criteria were that each pie has to be available for delivery and has had a great reputation all around the city.

So, If you’re looking for the best pizza Philadelphia has to offer, here are 10 of the best places for that. I focused mainly on the best places for sauce-and-cheese combos, but there are also Italian regional pies, Roman pizzas and even ones with a dash of South Philly edge.

Hey, we’re the Foodie Flashpackers, experts at reviewing restaurants in the USA, and committed to trying out the best foods available to us! In this article, we’ll review the pizza scene in Philadelphia, PA.

The Best Pizza In Philadelphia: 13 Must-Try Philly pizza Restaurants

Pizzeria Beddia

1313 N Lee St, Philadelphia, PA 19125, United States // +12679282256

Pizzeria Beddia in Philadelphia, PA, is a sought-after destination that offers daily specialty pizzas either to-go or in its small but inviting dining area. 

This is the pizza experience I had been searching for, where high-quality ingredients are thoughtfully combined to create something truly special.

The appetizers and drinks set a strong foundation for the meal, while the staff’s attentiveness made every interaction pleasant and welcoming.

The outdoor seating is ideal for warm-weather dining, and the interior is both clean and polished, providing a sophisticated yet comfortable ambiance. 

I was seated close to the kitchen, which allowed me to watch the team in action, expertly shaping dough balls into perfectly round bases ready for their toppings. 

pepperoni pizza

The pizzas came out hot and crispy, with a crust that strikes the perfect balance between structure and pliability, making it easy to fold each slice for that classic pizza-eating experience.

We ordered a pepperoni pizza generously covered with slices of spicy meat and a daily special that showcased thinly sliced fried potatoes. 

Both were prepared with care, delivering exceptional flavors and textures. The attention to detail is evident in every aspect of the preparation, from the ratio of toppings to the crispness of the crust.

Pizzeria Beddia is a must-visit for anyone looking for a memorable pizza outing in Philadelphia. 

Its thoughtful preparation, friendly service, and atmosphere that balances sophistication with casual comfort make it an excellent choice for anyone who appreciates quality pizza.

PIZZA Shackamaxon

115 E Girard Ave #3907, Philadelphia

Pizzeria Beddia moved into the Pizza Shackamaxon location when it was just a counter shop, without anyone noticing. 

Although there are no lines out the door anymore, these thin-crust pies are still really good. If you want to eat on the couch, you don’t have to buy an entire pizza from Shackamaxon. They sell their pizza by the slice. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Pizza Slice

Despite how big the slices are, they still have a lot of toppings on them, so you won’t lose all of your perfect little grease pools the moment you pick one up. 

Even though you can get some of the best slices in the city at this neighborhood spot, you will be out in no time.

The Famous & Original King of Pizza

2300 NJ-70, Cherry Hill, NJ 08002, United States // +18566654824

The Famous & Original King of Pizza is an institution known for serving pizzas, cheesesteaks, hoagies, and other casual bites in an old-school atmosphere. 

The restaurant’s reputation spans decades, and its enduring presence is a testament to the consistently satisfying experience it offers. 

The friendly staff and spotless dining area only add to the welcoming environment.

As someone who enjoys sampling different pizza joints, King of Pizza exceeded my expectations. 

The crust is impressively thin but strikes the perfect balance between crispy and sturdy without crossing into cracker-like territory. 

sausage pizza

Their sausage pizza, featuring shredded sausage generously layered on top, is a crowd-pleaser. 

Every bite is full of flavor, and the cheese fries are another highlight, complementing the pizza perfectly.

After a busy day, King of Pizza is the ideal spot to unwind and refuel. If you’re a fan of thin-crust New York-style pizza with an authentic, slightly greasy touch, this place won’t disappoint. 

With its extensive menu and inviting vibe, I’d gladly return to explore their other options, like the hoagies and cheesesteaks. 

The long-standing reputation isn’t just nostalgia; it’s a sign of a restaurant that knows how to deliver quality, comfort food consistently.

Wm. Mulherin’s Sons

1355 N Front St, Philadelphia // +12152911355

Wm. Mulherin’s Sons – an upscale hotel and restaurant in Fishtown – won’t serve up a big, greasy slice of cheese pizza. 

What you will get, though, is a 10-inch pie with a chewy, soft crust, topped with things like duck and pears, or – our personal favorite – a spicy jawn with long hot peppers and pepperoni. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Pizza

Several of their pizzas are available for brunch, such as one with speck and egg, when a cold slice from the fridge won’t do on a Saturday morning. Definitely my fav when it comes to the best pizza Philadelphia has to offer

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza

655 N Broad St, Philadelphia, PA 19123, United States // +12676396014

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza, is a family-owned pizzeria that brings traditional square pies, pasta dishes, and other comforting bites to the table in a casual yet thoughtfully styled space. 

I found this location on a whim and was pleasantly surprised by the friendly staff and quick service, despite the made-to-order nature of their pizzas. The pies arrived at the table piping hot and bursting with flavor.

The decor, though simple, adds to the inviting vibe, making it a perfect spot for a relaxed night out with friends or family. 

Their signature square pizza stood out as a must-try. I ordered a personal pizza with extra cheese, which boasted a thick crust that was satisfyingly crisp yet airy, generously topped with a flavorful tomato sauce. 

BBQ chicken pizza

The BBQ chicken pizza, paired with a couple of ice-cold beers, was another winner. The crust was well-baked, not greasy, and carried the toppings nicely.

For dessert, we opted for the cannoli and a cannoli cake. Both offered a delightful finish to the meal, with just the right balance of sweetness. 

The server was quick and accommodating, guiding us through the menu with helpful recommendations. It’s worth noting that Santucci’s is cash-only, but an ATM is conveniently available on-site.

Santucci’s is a wonderful find in Philadelphia, offering a blend of quality food, friendly service, and a laid-back atmosphere that makes it easy to return. 

Whether it’s their signature square pizza or any of the other items on the menu, each visit promises a satisfying meal that leaves you looking forward to your next trip back.

Pizza Brain

2313 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia // +12152912965

In Philly, you’ll find decent plain cheese pizza almost anywhere, but Pizza Brain tops the pies with brisket, brown sugar and cheese whiz and gives them ridiculous names, like Bob Sheldsmoose and Wendy Wedgeworth. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Pizza

Pies are served at this slice shop with thick, thin crusts and bizarre combinations that somehow work. 

There’s probably only one pie you’ll need to fill you up, and while you eat, you’ll be able to see all the weird pizza paraphernalia hanging on the wall.

Tacconelli’s Pizza

2604 E Somerset St, Philadelphia, PA 19134, United States // +12154254983

Tacconelli’s Pizza is a longstanding institution where the signature thin-crust tomato pie has drawn crowds for decades. 

This brick-oven pizzeria, known for its distinctive, ultra-thin pizzas, takes an old-school approach, requiring customers to reserve their dough days in advance. 

It’s a cash-only spot, but guests can bring their own beer and wine to enjoy with their meal, adding to the relaxed, communal atmosphere.

During our visit, we went all out, ordering four pies: a tomato pie, a white pie with a tomato topping, a plain regular pie, and one that was half-sausage, half-pepperoni

The thin-crust tomato pie was the standout. It delivered a satisfying balance of rich sauce, a light layer of cheese, and a crispy yet chewy base that only a brick oven can produce. 

The white pie, with its flavorful crust and vibrant toppings, showcased how the team here elevates each pizza to a work of art through simplicity and expert execution.

white pie

Despite the casual setup, where there is no formal hostess station, the servers are quick to ensure that drinks stay filled and that every table is well taken care of. 

Due to their handmade nature, the pizzas take time to prepare, so those without reservations should be prepared for a bit of a wait. 

However, the quality and taste of the pizza are worth it, offering an experience that lingers well beyond the final slice.

With its communal seating, BYOB option, and a nostalgic vibe that transports you to simpler times, Tacconelli’s is an ideal spot for unwinding with friends and family. 

Free street parking around the neighborhood makes the visit easy, and the dedication to maintaining quality ensures each visit is just as memorable as the last. 

Tacconelli’s is a shining example of how a traditional approach can still deliver exceptional results in a world of ever-changing culinary trends.

Rione

100.5 S 21st St, Philadelphia // +12155759075

Rione Pizza is the only place on this list that delivers, which means you won’t have to wait in line or travel across for the best pizza Philadelphia has to offer. 

Rione’s Roman-style squares are chewy, soft and topped with a sweet tomato sauce that tastes great both with and without the cheese. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Roman-Style Square Pizza

Moreover, you can order by the slice, so you can try lots of different topping combinations without having to buy a bunch of full pies.

Enjay’s Pizza

210 S 40th St, Philadelphia // +12152220770

There is a bar called Smokey Joe’s near Penn in West Philadelphia. There is live music every week and also a weekly game of quizzo at this divey sports bar. Sticky barstools, $2 beers, and a makeshift stage complete the picture. 

It is also home to Enjay’s Pizza, so it is one of the best dives in town. They make their wood-fired pizza from a kitchen in Smokey Joe’s, and their pies are perfectly charred with bubbly crusts. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Wood-Fired Pizza

Whether you choose the 12-inch or 18-inch size, they are all topped with parmesan and oregano, regardless of the toppings. It’ll feel like you found a hidden gem when you get one of these pies.

Barbuzzo

110 S 13th St, Philadelphia // +12155469300

West Philly’s Barbuzzo has been serving upscale Mediterranean dishes since 2003, focusing on local ingredients. In addition to their high-quality menu, they excel at pizzas – baked in their wood-burning oven. 

There are some exceptional rotating specials on the Buzzo menu. 

In addition to the roasted corn pie with pickled shallots, guanciale and truffle egg, there are classics like the Margherita and eggplant pizzas with San Marzano tomatoes. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Margherita Pizza

Pizzata Pizzeria

240 S 22nd St, Philadelphia // +12155467200

Pizzata, an Italian-American pizza restaurant located in Philadelphia, is one of the best places to get a pie in the city. Pizzata’s menu includes a variety of signature pizzas and bruschetta. 

The pizza dough is typically made with high-quality all-purpose flour, there are no preservatives, and it is naturally leavened. The toppings are fresh. 

The pizzeria’s location allows customers to have a glimpse of Italy through their menu items, decor and architecture.

Gallagher and Labruno, who worked for his family’s pizza place in Naples, make Pizzata’s dough, which is naturally leavened and topped with spicy salami and burrata. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Burrata Pizza

Angelo’s Pizzeria

736 S 9th St, Philadelphia // +12159220000

At Angelo’s Pizzeria on South 9th Street, cash is the only payment method, takeout is the only option, and preorders have to be made by phone. 

Lines are often long, and it’s open Tuesday through Sunday at 11 a.m. until it’s sold out. 

The crust is chewy and sour, featuring cheesy layers, vibrant tomato sauce, and fresh basil. Tempted? Hoagies and cheesesteaks are just as popular at Angelo’s as the pizza.

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Pizza

Square Pie

801 E Passyunk Ave, Philadelphia // +12152380615

There are few places inside the city where it’s as easy to spend an entire evening as it is at Square Pie. Of course, there’s a draft beer on the menu. And there are always good movies playing. 

“We’re never going back to round pizzas.” That’s what John Longacre, co-owner of Square Pie pizzeria in South Philly, keeps telling his customers as he prepares their massive square pies in the restaurant’s Scudé oven. Unlike traditional round pizza pies, these bad boys are made on a 10-by-14-inch tray. 

Best Pizza Philadelphia: Square Pie

Square Pie combines true blue Italian ingredients with Brooklyn-style aesthetics. Bring all your friends to this South Philly pizza place and order the porchetta pie, which riffs off the roast pork sandwiches that Italian immigrants brought to the Northeast when they first arrived in America.

Top 10 Best Restaurants For Pizza In Philadelphia, PA: To Visit List

1. Stella’s Pizza

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 3209 Willits Rd, Philadelphia, PA 19114, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.0 out of 520 reviews.

2. Pizza Plus West

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 4814 Spruce St, Philadelphia, PA 19139, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.0 out of 82 reviews.

3. Paulie Gee’s Soul City Slice Shop

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 412 S 13th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.7 out of 330 reviews.

4. Fairmount Pizza and Grill

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 2000 Fairmount Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19130, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Rating: 4.0 out of 1033 reviews.

5. Spring Garden Pizza and Restaurant

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 1139 Spring Garden St, Philadelphia, PA 19123, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.6 out of 335 reviews.

6. Pizza Jawn

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 4330 Main St, Philadelphia, PA 19127, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.7 out of 562 reviews.

7. Aldo & Manny Pizza and Pasta

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 1431 Arch St, Philadelphia, PA 19102, United States
  3. Price: $$
  4. Rating: 4.4 out of 417 reviews.

8. Savas Brick Oven Pizza

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 3505 Lancaster Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19104, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.1 out of 1042 reviews.

9. OG Pizza

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 2500 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19125, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.5 out of 920 reviews.

10. Rosario’s Pizzeria

  1. Cuisine: Pizza
  2. Location: 1256 S 15th St, Philadelphia, PA 19146, United States
  3. Price: $
  4. Rating: 4.2 out of 475 reviews.

Foodies Also Ask: Frequently Asked Questions

Why is Philadelphia’s tomato pie different from traditional pizza?

Philadelphia’s tomato pie stands out because it’s not your standard pizza. This local specialty features a thick, focaccia-like crust that’s baked with a robust layer of tomato sauce on top, often without cheese or with just a sprinkle of Parmesan. 

Unlike other pizzas that prioritize toppings or gooey cheese, the tomato pie focuses on the sauce’s flavor and is typically served at room temperature, making it unique among the various pizza styles.

What makes Tacconelli’s pizza reservation system unique?

Tacconelli’s Pizza operates a one-of-a-kind reservation system where customers must call in advance to reserve their dough before visiting the restaurant. 

This practice dates back to the 1940s when the pizzeria started baking with limited oven capacity. 

To ensure that each pizza is made fresh and maintains its renowned thin-crust quality, patrons still follow this decades-old tradition today.

How did pizza-by-the-slice shops become so popular in Philadelphia?

Philadelphia’s love for pizza-by-the-slice can be attributed to its strong Italian-American community and the influence of nearby New York City’s slice culture. 

During the mid-20th century, as Italian immigrants settled in the city, pizza became a staple for locals. 

The convenience of enjoying a quick, affordable slice while walking or on the go resonated with the urban lifestyle, leading to the proliferation of pizza-by-the-slice shops that are still popular today.

Final Thoughts On The 13 Restaurants For Best Pizza Philadelphia Has To Offer

If you love pizza as much as I do, then you’re going to love this list of the best in the city. From thin crust to deep dish, and everything in between, there is no shortage of places in Philly to try some of the best pizza around. 

Once you’ve read this list, I am sure that you’ll discover a new favorite place to indulge in some of the best pizza in the City of Brotherly Love. 

I must admit my friends and I had some differences on which pie is the best, however, I should underline that of the group, I am the most objective by far.

Having said that, I have no desire to impose my own opinion – it’s on you to figure out which one is really your favorite.

Visiting other destinations in Pennsylvania? Check out our other delicious guide:


Next time you’re craving pizza in Philly which place will you try first? Let us know in the comments section below!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.