Skip to Content

6 Best Restaurants in Afton Wyoming | Must-Try Restaurants in Afton, Wyoming

Sharing is caring!

I’m so thrilled to share with you my culinary journey through the heart of Wyoming, specifically Afton. 

You might think, “Afton? What’s cooking over there?” Well, let me tell you – it’s not just the outdoor adventure hub that it’s famed for. 

Imagine a place where the grandeur of the Star Valley meets a rich, delightful, and unexpected tapestry of culinary offerings. That’s Afton for you. 

Tucked between scenic vistas and swift-flowing rivers, this town boasts a food scene as diverse and compelling as the landscapes that surround it.

Every corner in Afton holds a culinary gem – the comforting aroma of home-style cooking wafting from family-run diners, the vibrant and exotic notes of world cuisine, the sweet allure of locally baked treats, and let’s not forget, the sizzle of gourmet dishes being artfully crafted at upscale restaurants.

Best Restaurants in Afton

It’s like a secret garden of flavors, each restaurant a unique blossom adding to Afton’s vibrant gastronomic bouquet.

You see, Afton isn’t merely a scenic pit stop en route to Yellowstone. It’s a treasure trove of flavors, a culinary crossroads where traditional meets innovative. And trust me, it’s a delectable journey worth making. 

So, are you ready to join me on this delicious voyage? Ready to uncover the culinary delights of Afton’s best restaurants? 

Grab your forks, friends. We’re about to dive into this hidden gastronomic paradise. Let’s turn this simmer into a rolling boil, shall we?

My Top Three Picks of the Best Restaurants in Afton Wyoming

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
Fathom RestaurantChicken Tikka Masala5/5
Los Cabos Baja Family Mexican RestaurantQuesadilla5/5
Rocky Mountain SeafoodCalamari and fries4.5/5

The Six Best Restaurants in Afton, Wyoming

Stella’s 467 Dough Box & Roadhouse

467 Washington St., Afton, WY 83110, United States // +13078859215

To start, we have an unassuming yet mind-blowingly delicious spot in Afton – Stella’s 467 Dough Box & Roadhouse. 

Admittedly, on first impression, I was a little skeptical. But then, I remembered those raving reviews and thought, “Let’s give it a whirl.” Boy, am I glad I did!

Afton boasts a few great places to grab a bite and sip on a cool drink, but Stella’s? It’s in a league of its own. The food here doesn’t just compete with nearby spots; it triumphs with a victory lap of flavors.

When we talk about the best food in Star Valley, Stella’s proudly hoists its flag. Their secret weapon? The unbeatable quality. 

Oh, and the freshly baked bread. Imagine sinking your teeth into a burger or a sandwich layered with this heavenly stuff – it’s a game-changer. 

And the French dip? A carnival of meaty goodness, with each bite oozing flavor. It’s a symphony of taste that’ll leave you asking for an encore.

 Bacon Smashburger

The gastronomic orchestra isn’t over yet. Their batter-dipped fries are the perfect co-stars. Crispy golden shells give way to fluffy interiors, and the accompanying fry sauce takes the harmony of flavors to the next level. 

With portions as generous as their flavors and prices that won’t break the bank, it’s a complete win-win!

You’re thinking, “What about the service?” It was impeccable. From the moment I stepped in until I bid farewell, I was bathed in warmth and friendliness. It felt like I was dining among friends.

From the first mouthful to the last, Stella’s had me hooked. So, food lovers, if you’re ever looking for a restaurant in Afton, Wyoming, you know where to anchor your food voyage. You can thank me later!

Agave Family Mexican Restaurant

470 Washington St., Afton, WY 83110, United States // +13078852222

All right, food lovers, I’ve got another Afton restaurant gem to share with you. This one’s for all you Mexican food enthusiasts out there! 

We’re heading to a family-run oasis that serves up a speedy meal and does it with passion and authenticity. Yes, amigos, I’m talking about the Agave Family Mexican Restaurant in Afton.

Now, you may wonder, “A top-notch Mexican restaurant in Wyoming?” You bet! Agave shatters preconceived notions and offers a delightful surprise on Afton’s Main Street. And trust me, this is no tourist trap; it’s the real deal.

What catches your eye at Agave is not just the mouthwatering food but also the decor. It’s cozy, inviting, and a notch above what you’d typically associate with Mexican eateries. It’s the kind of comfort that whispers, “Sit back, relax, we’ll take care of the culinary magic.”

Speaking of culinary magic, let’s talk about the food! It’s like they’ve packaged the essence of Mexico and served it right on your plate. 

Good food? Check. Fair price? Check. Top-notch service? Check. Mind-blowing salsa? Double-check! What more could a foodie soul ask for, right?

Enchiladas and Sauce

Their enchiladas are worth writing home about, and the lunch combo plates make your mid-day break a flavorful fiesta. 

As for portion sizes, they hit the perfect sweet spot. And, oh, the Chile Verde and Chile Colorado

They had me swooning with their rich, tantalizing flavors. Just a small heads-up, though; the plates can be hot, thanks to their broiler or oven melting the cheese to perfection.

If it’s warm service that adds that extra spice to your meal, you’re in luck. Every visit feels like coming home, thanks to the amiable owners. 

Remember, this isn’t some franchise – it’s a family pouring their love for food into every dish.

So, whether you’re an Afton local or just passing through Star Valley, be sure to make a pit stop at Agave Restaurant in Afton. 

It’s an experience that goes beyond just dining – it’s a flavorful journey you wouldn’t want to miss!

Fathom Restaurant

461 Washington St., Afton, WY 83110, United States // +13078851919

Here’s a little secret from my gastronomic treasure chest, Fathom Restaurant in Afton, Wyoming. 

Nestled just a stone’s throw away from the iconic Elkhorn Arch, Fathom has found a sweet spot in the hearts of both locals and visitors, becoming a culinary symbol on Main Street.

Now, if you’re a tourist wondering where to dine in Afton, let me spare you the trouble – it’s got to be Fathom. And let me tell you why. 

The owner was once the head chef on a ship, which I think is pretty cool, don’t you? He’s brought his culinary artistry ashore, and boy, can you taste it in every bite!

The restaurant is as fresh and welcoming as a sea breeze, with a fun and sociable vibe. Not to mention, it’s spotless. 

Now onto the best part, the food – it’s simply irresistible! The taste, texture, and cooking all come together to create a culinary masterpiece.

Chicken tikka masala

Two dishes for you – chicken tikka masala and saffron chicken. The flavors are out of this world! Each dish is an art form, with the curry worth a standing ovation. 

Fathom won’t let you down if you’re a curry enthusiast like me. And for dessert? Seradura. It was the perfect endnote to a symphony of flavors.

Another factor that caught my eye? The prices. They’re as friendly as the staff, who are always ready to lend their expertise and ensure a memorable dining experience.

So, folks, if you ever find yourself wandering around Afton, Wyoming, look for the Elkhorn Arch; right next to it, you’ll find Fathom, a true delight for all food lovers.

Take my word for it, and you won’t be disappointed. Enjoy the voyage!

Los Cabos Baja Family Mexican Restaurant

453 Washington St., Afton, WY 83110, United States // +13078850010

Next stop, Los Cabos Baja Family Mexican Restaurant in Afton. I kid you not; this place tops some of the Mexican eateries I’ve visited down South. 

From the moment I walked in, it was clear that this wasn’t your run-of-the-mill Mexican restaurant.

The first thing you notice about Los Cabos? The elderly owner is a seemingly gruff gentleman who single-handedly runs the show. 

Yet there’s an endearing quality about him, an embodiment of authenticity. It’s his spirit that infuses every inch of Los Cabos, making it more than just an Afton restaurant.

Now, let’s talk about the real star – the food. Friends, it’s a culinary spectacle! Each dish I tasted was an explosion of flavors. Authentic? Yes. Delicious? Absolutely. And the prices are as appetizing as the food itself.

Chicken quesadillas

Ever had a quesadilla that makes you close your eyes in bliss with the first bite? That’s what I experienced at Los Cabos. 

Fresh, flawlessly cooked, and downright delectable. But the flavor train doesn’t stop there.

Their sides of beans and rice, served in cute little taco shells, were the perfect accompaniments, with super guacamole and sour cream adding an extra kick.

And as far as presentation goes, Los Cabos gets a standing ovation. It’s not just about the taste here; it’s a full sensory experience.

So,be sure to venture to Los Cabos Baja Family Mexican Restaurant in Afton, Wyoming. Consider it my personal recommendation. 

It’s a hidden gem that deserves to shine, and I promise you, it’s an experience you won’t soon forget. Don’t just take my word for it, though. Try it yourself, and let the flavors speak!

The Rolling Omelet

595 Washington St., Afton, WY 83110, United States // +13072206465

Next up, we’re steering away from conventional dining and stepping aboard an incredible food adventure – The Rolling Omelet!

Here’s the deal: The Rolling Omelet is a food truck housed inside a school bus no less. Quirky? Absolutely! Intriguing? You bet! And if you’re worried about first impressions, cast them aside. 

Once you step in, it’s a different world – clean, well-kept, with an atmosphere that’s delightful.

What won my heart at The Rolling Omelet, apart from its adorable name, was the breakfast. Fresh, flavorful, and straight from the heart, it’s the kind of meal that kick-starts your day on a high note. And did I mention it’s a pleasant surprise, especially when it comes from a food truck?

breakfast burrito

The breakfast burrito and the English muffin sandwich were my picks, and they were nothing short of delicious. It’s not just about the food here, though; it’s the warmth with which it’s served. 

The friendly folks at The Rolling Omelet ensure you feel right at home, adding to the appeal of this unique eatery.

Another feather in their cap? The portion sizes and prices. They’ve nailed the balance perfectly – hearty meals that don’t burn a hole in your pocket.

So, if you find yourself hungry for a breakfast in Afton, keep an eye out for The Rolling Omelet. 

Hop aboard this school bus-turned-food truck, order your meal, and get ready to roll on a flavor-filled journey. And remember, it’s not just a meal; it’s an experience. Enjoy every bit of it!

Rocky Mountain Seafood

492 Washington St., Afton, WY 83110, United States // +13078852722

Time for our final culinary stop in the picturesque town of Afton, Wyoming, nestled in the majestic Star Valley mountains. 

Enter Rocky Mountain Seafood, a place where the beauty of nature meets delectable sea flavors.

Now, picture the setting – a pristine restaurant, with expansive windows that frame the breathtaking mountain views. Trust me when I say, the ambiance here is just the appetizer.

What truly amazes me about Rocky Mountain Seafood is its commitment to quality and diversity. For a mountain town, their array of fresh seafood would give coastal eateries a run for their money. 

From halibut to salmon, tuna, shrimp, calamari, and more, the selection is simply splendid. Dine-in or cook at home, they’ve got you covered.

As for my personal experience, the food was exceptional. The tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, and a uniquely delicious mint jalapeno jelly, all seemed to be freshly prepared in-house. 

The calamari I ordered was perfectly crispy and not a bit chewy. Paired with fries, this meal left my palate singing.


What about service, you ask? Just as delightful as the food! The friendly and helpful staff at Rocky Mountain Seafood in Afton ensure a dining experience that’s hard to forget.

My friend, on the other hand, was all praise for the coconut shrimp basket. And we both gave a unanimous thumbs-up to the pickle fries – a must-try!

So, fellow food explorers, if your adventures take you to Afton, make sure Rocky Mountain Seafood is on your itinerary.

It’s more than just a restaurant; it’s a seafood celebration set against an awe-inspiring mountain backdrop. 

As they say, the proof of the pudding (or, in this case, seafood) is in the eating. So, go on, give it a try, and let the flavors do the talking.


What is unique about Afton’s food scene?

Afton, Wyoming, stands out for its blend of flavors, from traditional American to Mexican and seafood. 

Despite its small-town charm, it offers a surprisingly varied dining scene, including family-owned establishments and innovative food trucks.

Is there any signature dish I should try in Afton?

While Afton doesn’t have a singular signature dish, it’s known for quality meals across various cuisines.

From the fresh seafood at Rocky Mountain Seafood to the authentic Mexican delicacies at Los Cabos Baja Family Mexican, there’s something for every palate.

Is dining in Afton budget-friendly?

Dining in Afton caters to a range of budgets. From upscale dining to wallet-friendly options, you’ll find something that suits your budget without compromising on taste.

Wrapping Up: The Six Best Restaurants in Afton, Wyoming

And there you have it, our culinary exploration of Afton, Wyoming – a food lover’s hidden treasure! 

This small town, nestled amidst the scenic landscapes of the Star Valley, proves that size isn’t everything when it comes to serving a varied and vibrant food scene.

With every dining establishment we visited, Afton has proven that it’s not just about the meals but also the rich tapestry of experiences that come with them. 

From the warmth of family-run restaurants in Afton to the novelty of dining in a converted school bus, Afton’s dining scene is a testament to the creative spirit of its locals.

But it’s not all about the unique dining experiences. An unwavering commitment to quality is at the heart of Afton’s culinary scene. 

Regardless of the cuisine, the common thread that runs through these establishments is the dedication to serving fresh, flavorful, and well-prepared food.

And let’s not forget the people who make these meals come alive. The chefs who pour their heart into every dish, the servers who serve with a smile, and the owners who warmly welcome every patron as though they were family. 

These people are the true backbone of Afton’s dining scene, and their passion is palpable in every bite.

So, whether you’re a seasoned foodie on the hunt for your next gastronomic adventure or a traveler looking for a comforting meal to warm your heart, Afton, Wyoming, is a destination worth adding to your foodie bucket list.

In this town, you’ll find that food isn’t just sustenance; it’s a conversation starter, a bond builder, and an expression of the community’s spirit. 

From the first delicious aroma to the last satisfying bite, Afton is sure to leave a delightful and lasting impression on your culinary senses. 

So, pack your appetite and sense of adventure, and discover the flavorful surprises Afton restaurants offer. Here’s to good food, great memories, and the joy of discovering the undiscovered. 

Visiting other destinations in Wyoming? Check out our other delicious guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.