Skip to Content

Where to Find Best Pizza in Cary NC | 7 Must-Try Places

Sharing is caring!

Some smells are universal smells of happiness. The smell of rain on a hot day, the smell of a perfume that reminds you of something, the smell of fresh flowers, the smell of the sea, and, last but not least, the smell of pizza. 

I think no person in this world doesn’t like to eat pizza. If that person exists, they probably haven’t tried the right one. 

Pizza is pizza, the most popular Italian dish, with dough piled with tasty ingredients according to your wishes and your mood, resulting in an endless source of creativity. 

Suppose you are planning a trip to Cary, NC. In that case, it is fair to know the best places for eating pizza in Cary, being transported to lovely Italy, and enjoying traditional flavors with modern additions. 

You will love walking through the streets of Cary, NC, enjoying the hot weather, open green spaces, and all the adventures that the city is ready to surprise you with. 

There is a wide range of restaurants in Cary, NC, that offer spectacular pizza that will leave you speechless. 

So if you are planning a trip to Cary, or maybe you are going through life changes, and you are planning to move to the southeast, don’t worry, my friend.  You will be stacked every day with all the good places for pizza in Cary, NC. 

It is our pleasure to give you our suggestions to add these restaurants for pizza in Cary NC, to your list. Enjoy your meal!

My Top Three Picks of the Places with the Best Pizza in Cary, NC 

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
Veritas Pizza White Pizza5/5
Di Farra Pizza TavernWhite Pie4/5
Pizzeria FaulisiMargherita4.5/5

The Best Pizza in Cary, NC

Salvio’s Pizzeria

Salvio’s Pizzeria, 2428 SW Cary Pkwy., Cary, NC 27513, United States   +19194674600 

Memories are the best part of your thoughts; they make your soul rich and your face smile. We have a great memory of this friendly and family-owned place. 

We walked inside and felt that satisfying feeling that we would not be disappointed with the pizza. 

It was amazing, starting from the crust and sauce to the flavors and fresh ingredients. 

The pizza was really good, and we were delighted with our choice. 

We ordered a Large Meat Lovers Pizza, and we all agreed that the meat preparation was excellent.  It wasn’t overcooked; it was properly cooked and deliciously spiced.

Meat Lovers Pizza at Salvio's Pizzeria

This place has high standards when it comes to pizza, which was confirmed by my friend who lives in Cary, NC. He said that this restaurant always provided consistency in offering tasty pizza with incredibly tasty sauce. 

We visited this place on Sunday and again on Tuesday. We really liked the ambiance and the kind service. 

On the second visit, we ordered Sicilian with Crispy Pepperoni and Hot Honey, easily so large that you can split it. 

This restaurant has a basic decor but with cozy elements that will meet your needs for convenience while having tasty pizza. 

Other recommendations from my friend are New York White, Gourmet White, and Buffalo Chicken pizzas

The pizza is always delivered hot,  featuring excellent customer service. I highly recommend it for pizza in Cary. 

Pizzeria Faulisi

215 E. Chatham St., Cary, NC 27511, United States  +19193778244

Pizzeria Faulisi is a bright and comfortable place where we received a warm welcome as soon as we entered the pizzeria in Cary.

We really enjoyed this cozy place for strengthening our bond with the food and our desire to eat something unique, yet combined with tradition and dedication, 

This is a popular place featuring wood-fired pizzas with gourmet toppings, together with an extensive list of beers and wines. 

Many people prefer pizza with bacon or pepperoni. I personally love a lot of cheese. Therefore, I love the Margherita, and the Margherita that they have here is a benchmark pie. I ordered it, and it was great.

Margherita pizza at Pizzeria Faulisi

I  recommend this place to anyone who is looking for artisan pizza in Cary. I am a fanatic when it comes to pizza, and this place meets my obsession for a tasty classic and traditional pizza.  

The Prosciutto pizza was tasty, and the pineapple was nice and sweet. This is definitely my recommendation if you want to experience some other tastes and combinations of ingredients. 

The pizza here is really something that will inspire you to go to Italy and learn how to cook Italian pizza. Neapolitan wood-fired pizza is also something that you should try. The wood firing gives it a crispier crust, is perfectly salty, and has great cheese. 

I really liked everything about this place; the location, the staff, the taste of the pizza, the fact that pizza is baked in a wood oven, and that all ingredients are locally sourced. Our group also tried a burrata pizza, and it was utterly unique. 

This is the place to obtain excellent Neapolitan-style pizza in Cary.  Come and visit this Cary pizzeria. You will have one of the best experiences in your food career. 

Di Fara Pizza Tavern

111 E. Chatham St., Cary, NC 27511, United States +19196785300

From the moment we walked into this place, I knew this Cary pizzeria would be the first place that would cross my mind for a special occasion with a tasty pizza and lovely wine. 

I recommend this restaurant for dining, even though this place also provides takeout service, but you will miss the great ambiance both inside and outside. 

This place has authenticity, which is something that I really appreciate. 

We were sitting in this pleasant environment, enjoying the mutual company and having drinks with appetizers while waiting for the king of the show. 

The pizza is worth the wait. It is really something chewy and incredibly good that you would love to eat for the rest of your life. 

My breath was taken away when I tried the Difara Classic Pie with sausage, peppers, onion, and mushrooms.  It was so good. The other kind of pizza that made us believe in miracles was the White Pie. I liked the cheese; it was the ingredient that stole the show.

White pie New York style pizza

Here, you will find pizza with amazing dough, not flimsy at all. The sauce is sweet, and the ingredients are super fresh. 

If you want to order something else for later, you can order pizza by the slice. Our recommendation is Pepperoni and Square pizza with Pepperoni

But enough talking! It is time to see in person how delicious pizza is here. Come visit this restaurant for pizza in Cary.  Enjoy your pizza. After your pizza, you will recognize us as your best food advisers. 

Brothers Of New York Pizza

3450 Kildaire Farm Rd., Cary, NC 27518, United States  +19196296000

In this place, we experienced an authentic New York dining experience eating delicious pizza in Cary, NC. 

This experience starts from the very beginning when you enter the restaurant and feel the stylistic magic that this Cary pizzeria has. It is typical New York style, and I really loved the ambiance in combination with some of the best pizzas in Cary. My favorite decor element is the subway door against the wall.  

We sat at the nice little bar surrounded by amazing staff. They were always attentive and very helpful. Special thanks to the cooks for the NY Supreme pizza.  It had plenty of toppings, and I liked the crust too. 

The Sicilian pizza was good, also.  Of course, Margherita is always my choice because I love when the emphasis is put on the cheese and tomato sauce. Other types of pizzas suggested by our native friend are Barbecue Chicken with crispy chicken, BBQ Sauce, and Mozzarella, and the Prosciutto Pizza, where you will love the mozzarella together with ricotta, garlic, sliced prosciutto, oregano, and Parmigiana.  

Sicilian pizza

I love Brothers of New York Pizza! I highly recommend this place, especially for all of you who want to be transported to New York. Experience the delicious NY Style pizza, a great beer and wine selection, and a nice outdoor sitting. What more can you wish for? The pizza was really good, deserving of a five-star ranking in this pizza restaurant in Cary. 

Pizzeria Veritas

1260 NW Maynard Rd., Cary, NC 27513, United States  +19193193232

Pizzeria Veritas is a place that will surprise you with a welcoming energy and chill atmosphere.

You are going to love this place and everything about its offerings. 

People here were very helpful and willing to offer the best pizza, something appreciated from our side. 

I loved the Veritas Cheese featuring a perfectly baked crust and thin, light sauce. I personally assess a pizza by taking into account the crust, and here it was really amazing. You will not throw the crust away here; you will eat the entire pizza.  The flavors were very robust and authentic. 

The secret of the success of this magnificent pizza is the dedication of the staff and the fact that all ingredients are locally sourced. The restaurant’s basil garden is a source of pride. 

I love when honey is added to the pizza as a special taste to seduce you. Because of that, I really loved the Spicy Honey with fresh mozzarella cheese, cupped pepperoni, sausage, oven-roasted peppers, jalapeno peppers, and a drizzle of honey.

If you enjoy Mediterranean-style food, they offer Mediterranean pizza with olive oil and mozzarella base, lamb/beef gyro meat, green peppers, red onions, garlic, and tomatoes. It even comes with tzatziki sauce for dipping.

Mediterranean pizza with gyro meat and vegetables

For vegetarians, The Veggie, is a perfect fusion of fresh and healthy ingredients such as green peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.

The pizza here is top-notch. Everything it’s just the BEST!!  I can’t wait to come back and try the Supreme Veritas that my friend had. We had really outstanding experience in one of those Cary pizzerias that instantly made you a repeat customer. 

That is me for sure!!

Cappolla’s Pizza & Grill Cary

 2462 Walnut St., Cary, NC 27518, United States +19198547777

This is a family-owned Italian restaurant, and we were really happy that we managed to visit this place and eat delicious Cary pizza with fresh ingredients.

Coppola’s is a perfect place to stop for a pizza and has quick, amazing customer service and beyond-amazing pizzas. 

We got their Buffalo chicken pizza and a Veggie Pizza. They were both so delicious! You will have a chance to sit in a pleasant ambiance at a comfortable table and talk with the owner. He is very friendly and kind.

veggie pizza at one of the best restaurants for pizza in Cary NC

Our group also enjoyed Eggplant Pizza in this Cary pizzeria. My local friend visits Cappolla’s regularly and recommends the classic Cheese pizza and White Spinach Pizza, with a base of olive oil, fresh garlic, spinach, tomatoes, black olives, and feta cheese.  

Cappolla’s Pizza & Grill is a great Cary pizza restaurant with great food and customer service. Come and enjoy this place. You are going to love it!


Do these restaurants offer dishes other than pizza? 

Of course. Many of these restaurants are offering other dishes that will bring your appetite to the highest level. You can order pasta, spaghetti, mozzarella sticks, garlic knots, and other dishes that will show the quality of these pizza restaurants in Cary and give you satisfaction for your food needs. 

Are these restaurants expensive? 

It depends on what you are searching for. Some of them are a little pricey, but not at such high prices that would cause a headache. 

Do these restaurants offer takeout or delivery options?

Of course! Each of these restaurants offers takeout options. It is pizza; you can’t be restricted to only one place. You deserve to have a chance to eat extra good pizza in the comfort of your home, and these restaurants offer that. 

Do these restaurants offer vegan options?

Yes, sure! If you are a vegetarian, you will have plenty of veggie options when it comes to pizza. 

Wrapping Up And Heading To The Next Pizza Place In Cary NC

As a pizza purist, I was happy to see many pizza options in Cary, NC. Interesting places with different tastes of pizza, respecting the traditional flavors, but too brave to offer a different pizza experience to the visitors. 

You will find many places that offer pizza by the slice. Places with extraordinary cheese pizza, pizza with a Mediterranean taste, and veggie pizza. 

The best thing to know is that pizza here is not going to be something that you will miss, especially when you can add these amazing restaurants to your list. 

From deep dish to thin crust, there are multiple options available. 

So, you can easily travel for pizza in Cary, NC. Relish the succulent flavor of sizzling pizza at Pizza places at Carry, NC.

If you liked this article and you are interested in exploring some more amazing restaurants in North Carolina, make sure to check out our articles:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.