Skip to Content

The 10 Best East Chicago Pizza Restaurants

Sharing is caring!

There is always fierce debate about the politics of pizza in Chicago. But, regardless of whether it’s for deep dish or thin crust, devoted supporters will never relent.

Fortunately, there are pizzaiolos in the city that specialize in different styles so that everyone can find something they like.

Some places have a long history, and others are relatively new, but they’re all stepping outside their comfort zones and making an impact on local food.

These ten pizza joints are just a few of the East Chicago pizza restaurants in the area.

The 10 Best East Chicago Restaurants

Toni’s Pizza

4724 Indianapolis Blvd., East Chicago // +12193979009

For years, East Chicago locals have enjoyed Toni’s Pizza. They offer Chicago-style pizza that’s a neighborhood favorite.

Here you will find delicious Chicago pizza, sausages, and sandwiches. Toni’s Pizza restaurant has been rated among the best for food delivery in this area.

Pizza and calzones made with homemade sauce and dough are impossible to resist due to their thin crusts and delicious sauce.

East Of Chicago Pizza: Chicago Pizza

The daily specials at Toni’s are also delicious and affordable. They are served from 11:00 AM to 2:30 PM Monday through Friday.

Genova Pizza

3820 Main St., East Chicago // +12193974008

This family pizzeria has a pleasant ambiance and is well worth a visit. Genova Pizza is a perfect choice if you love Italian cuisine. The cozy atmosphere is ideal for relaxing after a long day at work.

Pizza from Genova is known for its delicious taste. There hasn’t been much change at this restaurant since it opened. You can also order Italian sandwiches, burgers, and pasta. 

East Of Chicago Pizza: Pizza

There is nothing better than finishing off with a delicious cheesecake at this place!

Isabella’s Pizza

1932 Calumet Ave., Whiting // +12196596500

Due to its cozy atmosphere, the first thing that draws attention to this pizzeria is its appearance. However, this place is great because of the people who work hard here, stay positive, and make it great. 

There are a lot of places where you can eat in Chicago. But Isabella’s Pizza will give you good Italian pizza. It is also possible for you to order Hawaiian or Greek pizza. 

East Of Chicago Pizza: Hawaiian Pizza

For dessert, you can try fresh fruit. The location is easily accessible and the staff is friendly. 

There is an opportunity to order delivery in case you don’t want to go to the pizzeria. However, it’s hard to resist their delicious pies. They are the best in this area.

Dino’s Pizza

1601 121st St., Whiting // +12196590715

Dino’s Pizza has been in operation for over 50 years. What was once Baker Boys Pizza is now Dino’s Pizza. As a result, many changes have occurred in the menu. 

The pizza menu hasn’t changed much but has expanded to include a variety of sandwiches and homemade chili. Dino’s is still family-owned and open seven days a week!

East Of Chicago Pizza: Pizza

It’s a small, open dining room with rows of tables and booths to sit at. There is a small lunch counter with some seating available if you want to dine in, so this prevents Dino’s from being a carry-out-only pizzeria. 

They have amazing sandwiches and homemade chili and salads on the menu. Side items are a big hit, too, like garlic bread, cheese bread, and tomato bread.

Dino’s Pizza is a “no thrills” kind of place, and that is what I love about them!

Millo’s Pizzeria

521 W. Chicago Ave., East Chicago // +12193977600

Millo’s Pizzeria, a place that stands out for its delicious pizza and other dishes, is one of the favorites among the locals in East Chicago. The staff here is always friendly. Service at this place is something one can call professional.

Lunchtime will never be the same once you visit Millo’s Pizzeria. The food delivery is a pleasant bonus of this place.  

Stop by this restaurant to taste mouthwatering pizza, chicken, and beef during your spare time.  The coziness of this place makes you feel relaxed and a lovely time. 

East Of Chicago Pizza: Pizza

Pizza Mix

4912 Indianapolis Blvd. #1, East Chicago // +12193929000

To find the best-fried chicken, East Chicago pizza, and beef in this region, visit Pizza Mix. When you enter this pizzeria, you will see a friendly staff at the cashier.

Pizza Mix has all the qualities of a good restaurant, especially high-quality food. In addition, the cooking style is brilliant, enticing visitors to return for another meal in this pizzeria. 

I visited this place many times and was amazed by the service and welcoming hosts. The prices are average, but you can easily find special deals online. 

There are several great dishes to recommend at Pizza Mix, including their fried chicken pizza, the beef, meatballs, and deep-dish pizza. 

East Of Chicago Pizza: Deep-Dish Pizza

Frankie V’s Bar & Grill

1923 Calumet Ave., Whiting // +12196555454

Frankie V’s is a family-owned, neighborhood restaurant that is very popular with sports fans. It’s famous for its large menu of favorites, from Italian to American to seafood.

They serve pizza, jumbo chicken wings, half-pound burgers (including a half-pound Kobe beef burger), homemade Italian sausage, and Italian beef sandwiches.

East Of Chicago Pizza: Pizza

A variety of gnocchi, ravioli, and spaghetti dishes are also available, as well as baked haddock and perch, several steak dishes, and a variety of sandwiches like a ribeye steak sandwich and a fried chicken sandwich. It’s a definitive must-visit!

Aurelio’s Pizza

4226 Calumet Ave., Hammond // +12199321470

Among East Chicago pizza restaurants, Aurelio’s Pizza is a must-try. Joe Aurelio opened Aurelio’s in 1959 as a small pizzeria with four tables.

Aurelio’s has used premium ingredients since the early days to provide their customers with a premium pizza at a great value. They customize all orders to suit their customers’ tastes.

East Of Chicago Pizza: Pizza

You definitely need to try Aurelio’s pizza if you are in Chicago or plan to visit! They’re all delicious, whether it’s a small pizza or a large calzone. 

You can also order one of the many specialty pizzas if you are unsure what kind of pizza you should order. Trust me; you won’t be disappointed!

Paisano’s Pizza

6833 Calumet Ave., Hammond // +12199322233

Pizza from Paisano’s is recognized as the freshest and best tasting Chicago-style Italian pizza. It’s Chicago’s favorite Italian restaurant, pizzeria, and town square! 

The restaurant offers savory pasta, gourmet pizzas, sandwiches, and salads paired perfectly with pizza crusts made in-house.

East Of Chicago Pizza: Gourmet Pizza

You’ll find it all at Paisano’s, from the incomparable Tony D’s to the delicious stromboli stand to the savory lasagna!

Key Pizza

7003 Kennedy Ave., Hammond // +12198443668

East Chicago’s Key Pizza is a fast and friendly pizza joint where you can even customize your own pizza with a variety of fresh toppings.

No other East Chicago pizza will compare to Key Pizza’s savory and cheesy slices.

You need to try a slice of Key Pizza if you love pizza! Pizzas are made with the freshest, finest ingredients and come in Original Stuffed Crust, Thick Crust, and Thin Crust styles. 

There are four kinds of Original Stuffed Crust pizzas, nine specialty pizzas, six kinds of calzones, and many vegetarian options.

East Of Chicago Pizza: Calzone

Visiting Chicago? Don’t miss out on these delicious Chicago food guides! 

Visiting other destinations in Illinois? Check out our other delicious guides:

Summary About the Ten Best East Chicago Pizza Places

Pizza connoisseurs often lament the lack of decent pizza in Chicago. 

Even with all the options available, most people still say that New York is the place to get a good pizza pie. But newcomers aren’t even aware of the East Chicago pizza joints.

You’d be surprised at how many incredible and underrated pizza places there are in the East Chicago area! So make sure you visit it and enjoy some nice pizza!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.