Skip to Content

The Best Canandaigua Lake Restaurants | 5 Must-Try Places

Sharing is caring!

As the sun sets over the glistening waters of Canandaigua Lake, one’s thoughts naturally drift to the dinner table. Welcome to New York’s Finger Lakes region – an unassuming gastronomic gold mine!

Canandaigua, a gem among the lakes, is renowned for its breathtaking vistas and burgeoning culinary scene. Here, nestled in a peaceful pocket of Upstate New York, you’ll find some of the finest eateries that the Empire State has to offer. 

Best Canandaigua Lake Restaurants

Canandaigua isn’t just a gorgeous, serene refuge from the hustle and bustle of city life; it’s a place where food, nature, and hospitality converge in a flavorful symphony.

The Canandaigua food scene boasts an eclectic mix of restaurants, from cozy, family-owned bistros that have been serving comfort food for generations to modern gourmet establishments that are pushing the boundaries of Finger Lakes’ cuisine.

In this neck of the woods, you don’t just dine; you embark on a culinary adventure. Each restaurant has a unique tale to tell, each plate a testament to the rich tapestry of local flavors and ingredients. 

Buckle up, as we’re about to embark on a delicious journey to discover the best Canandaigua Lake restaurants!

My Top Three Picks of the Best Canandaigua Lake Restaurants

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
Peppers Family RestaurantThe Lobster Bisque & Homemade Pie 5/5
Sand Bar at The Lake House on CanandaiguaAlmond Cake Dessert5/5
Finger Lakes Public HouseSmokehouse Pulled Pork Burger5/5

The Five Best Canandaigua Lake Restaurants

Sand Bar at The Lake House on Canandaigua

770 S. Main St., Canandaigua, NY 14424 // +15853947800

As a self-proclaimed gastronome, my visit to the Sand Bar at The Lake House on Canandaigua left me swooning. Nestled on the shores of Canandaigua Lake, this picturesque spot effortlessly meshes great food, superb service, and an unbeatable ambiance!

My eyes were first captivated by the restaurant’s design, seamlessly reflecting the lake’s pure beauty. There was an air of sophistication blended with an easygoing lakeside vibe, and every detail echoed an obvious attention to aesthetics.

The food was nothing short of superb. Each dish was cooked to perfection, marrying splendid taste with just the right consistency, and served at the perfect temperature. 

The grilled chicken sandwich was robust and succulent, while the crab cake hush puppies – oh, those hush puppies! – were an absolute delight. With every bite, I could taste the crab, complemented beautifully by the cornmeal exterior.

Chicken sandwich

But let’s not forget the standout – the almond cake dessert. It was the showstopper, a sweet grand finale that had me wishing I could slow down time to savor each mouthful.

Complementing the delightful meal was a selection of robust drinks from the bar, served swiftly, potent, and mixed with finesse. The wine list, boasting some exquisite picks, was the perfect pairing for our upscale lakeside dinner.

All this was enjoyed from a relaxed outdoor dining spot with a magnificent view of the lake. But be warned, friends – such an unforgettable experience does come with a price tag to match. 

Nevertheless, I believe it was worth every penny, and I’d recommend calling ahead for reservations. After all, a dining experience at The Sand Bar is one that should not be missed. A trip to Canandaigua restaurants isn’t complete without it!

Nolan’s on Canandaigua Lake

726 S. Main St., Canandaigua, NY 14424 // +15859050201

In the heart of Canandaigua lies a culinary haven, Nolan’s on Canandaigua Lake, that’s worth every morsel of its reputation. As an ardent food lover, my dining experience here was an absolute pleasure.

From the first welcoming smile of the charming hostess to the last satisfying bite, the service at Nolan’s left an indelible mark. 

Now, let’s talk about their cocktail, beer, and wine selections – they are grand! But what took my breath away was their food. It was the stuffed mushrooms appetizer that first teased my taste buds. 

Topped with a silky, rich bearnaise sauce, it was the culinary equivalent of a standing ovation. As someone who appreciates a well-crafted bearnaise, I can confidently say Nolan’s version was one of the best I’ve ever tasted.

My main course, a steak cooked to sheer perfection, was a testament to the skill and dedication of the real chef working the kitchen. 


Every dish on their menu, from seafood to pasta to meat dishes, evoked a sense of refined dining. The daily specials, generously portioned, offered a welcome surprise element.

While enjoying the cuisine, I couldn’t help but admire the spacious seating and the seasonal decor. Each of Nolan’s various rooms holds a distinct charm, setting the stage for different dining experiences, all under one roof. 

It’s the kind of place that personifies what one envisions when you say you want to go to a ‘nice restaurant.’ And the best part? The experience at Nolan’s comes at surprisingly reasonable prices. Higher-end, clean, and brimming with excellent quality ingredients and dishes – Nolan’s has become a personal favorite and a must-visit when looking for a restau

Peppers Family Restaurant

101 E. Lake Rd., Canandaigua, NY 14424 // +15854129005

Some culinary experiences happen serendipitously. That’s precisely how I discovered Peppers Family Restaurant on a simple, laid-back ride around Canandaigua Lake. What a delight it was to stumble upon this local gem!

At Peppers, you’re immediately wrapped in a fun, casual, and welcoming atmosphere. It’s the kind of place that instantly feels like home, thanks to the warm smiles of the staff. The menu is bursting with variety – traditional, yet far from mundane.

Let me give you a sneak peek into my dining experience. The Lobster Bisque? Phenomenal. I’ve had my fair share of bisques, but this one took the cake. It was pure maritime magic in a bowl. 

 Lobster Bisque

And the Black and Blue salad? It was, quite simply, the best I’ve ever had. Every ingredient harmonized to create a melody of flavors that had my taste buds singing!

But the real showstopper was the pie. If you find yourself at Peppers, do your senses a favor and indulge in their pies. You can thank me later. 

Did I mention their homemade chips? Because they deserve a mention. Delicious would be an understatement. Crispy, flavorful, and downright addictive, they were the perfect sidekick to the memorable meal.

What’s more, you’re not going to feel the pinch on your wallet at Peppers. The quality, size, and flavor of the meals far surpass what you’d expect from the modest prices. It’s indeed the best bargain in town!

Peppers is a must-visit restaurant in Canandaigua. It’s an experience that will leave you with a belly full of joy and a heart full of gratitude for good food and great times!

Finger Lakes Public House

401 Lakeshore Dr., Canandaigua, NY 14424 // +15853960001

If you’re looking for stellar dining in Canandaigua, let me direct you to a hidden treasure, Finger Lakes Public House. This place packs a punch with pub-grub-style offerings that leave an indelible mark on your palate.

I remember stepping into the restaurant and being instantly enveloped in its warm and friendly aura. The moment I entered, I was greeted with the kind of genuine hospitality that makes you feel like a valued guest, not just another diner.

The allure of the Finger Lakes Public House is in its homemade food. The Smokehouse Pulled Pork Burger? Absolute heaven! The taste of that tender, smoky pulled pork still lingers in my memory. 

 Pulled Pork Burger

And as a side, the fried cauliflower was an unexpected star, delivering a delicious crunch in every bite. I’d be remiss if I didn’t recommend the pulled pork sliders – they’re a must-try, trust me!

Pairing this delicious food was a selection of splendid beers, a nod to the laid-back, pub-like ambiance. The servers, friendly and attentive, created a seamlessly pleasant dining experience. 

And on a nice day, the patio is the perfect spot for a relaxing meal under the blue Canandaigua sky.

Despite having a full house, the efficient staff ensured quick table turnovers, making sure the wait time was minimal, even during peak dinner hours. It’s clear that customer satisfaction is their top priority.

Finger Lakes Public House is more than just a restaurant. It’s a warm, welcoming space that combines a family atmosphere with mouth-watering food and top-tier service. If you’re looking for a restaurant in Canandaigua, do yourself a favor and treat yourself to a meal here!

Laguna Grande Restaurante Mexicano & Bar

407 Lakeshore Dr., Canandaigua, NY 14424 // +15859053097

Stepping into Laguna Grande Restaurante Mexicano & Bar in Canandaigua feels like a mini-vacation to Mexico! This place has mastered the art of creating a rich, authentic dining experience that wows you in every possible way.

Right from the moment you enter, Laguna Grande rolls out the red carpet of hospitality. I was instantly seated and offered a refreshment, setting the tone for the delightful experience to follow. 

The complimentary chips and salsa arrived swiftly – and talk about freshness! They were the perfect opening act, tantalizing my taste buds and setting the stage for the main event.

The menu at Laguna Grande is a beautiful symphony of Tex-Mex flavors. My favorites? The chicken and steak fajitas served with your choice of corn or flour tortillas, refried beans in a corn shell, guacamole salad, and Spanish rice.

chicken and steak fajitas

Each bite was a flavor explosion, a testament to the mastery of the kitchen. Oh, and let’s not forget the enchiladas and bean dip, which were so flavorful, they had me scraping the plate clean. 

These delicious dishes, beautifully presented, came at surprisingly affordable prices. But a visit to Laguna Grande is incomplete without trying their drinks. The Margaritas are colossal and so very refreshing, the perfect accompaniment to the meal.

I highly recommend you give this cozy establishment a visit. Dive headfirst into the vibrant, affordable Tex-Mex cuisine in Canandaigua – it’s an experience that will keep you coming back for more!


What is the food scene like in Canandaigua Lake?

Canandaigua Lake offers a diverse and exciting food scene! It’s a melting pot of flavors where you can find everything from classic pub grub and delicious Tex-Mex to fine dining options and family-friendly eateries.

Are there vegetarian and vegan options in Canandaigua Lake restaurants?

Absolutely! Many restaurants around Canandaigua Lake offer vegetarian and vegan-friendly dishes. Some places have separate vegetarian and vegan menus, while others can customize their offerings to suit dietary preferences. It’s always a good idea to check in advance or ask your server.

Is outdoor dining available in Canandaigua Lake restaurants?

Yes, many restaurants around the lake offer beautiful outdoor dining spaces. Whether it’s a sunny patio, a cozy deck, or seating right by the lake, you can enjoy your meal in the open air with a stunning view.

Conclusion about the Best Canandaigua Lake Restaurants

And there you have it! An insider’s glimpse into the savory delights that dot the beautiful shores of Canandaigua Lake. 

Each culinary corner of our beloved lakeside haven boasts its own unique charm, beckoning foodies from all walks of life.

The gastronomic scene here is as diverse and dynamic as the lake’s shimmering waters. From hearty breakfast spots that rouse your senses with the aroma of fresh coffee to sun-drenched patios where you can while away the afternoon over a late lunch, every meal in Canandaigua Lake is a memorable one. 

The dinner scene is an enticing blend of homestyle comforts and high-end finery, featuring locally sourced ingredients that sing praises of the fertile Finger Lakes region.

The beauty of dining around Canandaigua Lake lies in its variety. Whether you’re a food connoisseur, a casual diner, or somewhere in between, there’s a table here waiting just for you. 

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.