Skip to Content

Where to Find The Best Pizza In Orange Beach, Alabama

Sharing is caring!

Renowned for its spectacular sunsets, fabulous beaches, and incredibly fresh seafood, Orange Beach is one of Alabama’s most beautiful holiday spots. However, you might start to yearn for some excellent pizza after all that tanning and strolling along the seaside.

Orange Beach

And, If you are a resident or a tourist of Orange Beach and come to enjoy its sunny beaches often, you’ve definitely found yourself in the familiar scenario of not knowing the best pizza in Orange Beach.

This can be a real challenge when it comes to finding the best local pizza restaurants. But don’t worry! You’re in good hands – here are my top five recommendations for Orange Beach pizza restaurants!

The Best Pizza In Orange Beach

Rotolo’s Pizzeria

25755 Perdido Beach Blvd., Orange Beach, AL 36561, United States // +12519818895

This pizzeria is a must-visit! Despite the fact that I have gone to several pizzerias, this one has a unique and delectable menu. We went on a Monday night for dinner and were seated right away. Our server was polite and attentive. The bread bits we had to start were the nicest I’ve ever had. Very soft!

During my meal, I had a calzone with the softest bread ever. It was fantastic; it really brightened my night! My friend was delighted with a delicious small pizza. Drinks were served in take-home cups, which was a great touch!

Best Pizza In Orange Beach: Rotolo's Pizzeria Calzone

They also provide gluten-free choices. So don’t doubt this small nugget if you’ve made it this far. With the best food and staff, it is a beautiful jewel.

They undoubtedly offer some of the best pizza in Orange Beach. Without a doubt, I would return there.


Get my free checklist with 15 tips on how to eat like a real foodie and enjoy an authentic culinary experience!


We respect your email privacy

Vinny’s Pizzeria

4651 Main St. K-1, Orange Beach, AL 36561, United States // +18667437669

We are all aware of how crucial it is to have a great pizza restaurant nearby for lunch and dinner. Pizza is a universal favorite, primarily when it can be delivered right to our door. And Vinny’s is the best location in Orange Beach to get freshly made or handcrafted New York-style pizza.

If you love pizza, Vinny’s is the spot you must visit.

This southern staple truly deserves some notice because of the actual New York-style pizza dough and toppings. The restaurant keeps things basic and doesn’t make a great effort with the decorations, but it’s not a significant concern. You’ll like their exceptional ambiance and fantastic service!

Vinny's Pizzeria Pizza

The ambiance was fantastic, and the pizza was excellent! We were happy we had stopped by. The pizza with pineapple and Canadian bacon was delicious. Definitely would come back!

Perdido Beach Pizza Company

27200 Perdido Beach Blvd., Orange Beach, AL 36561, United States // +12519819811

There’s a decent chance you know what Perdido Beach Pizza Company is all about if you’ve ever visited New York or seen “Cheers.”

Perdido Beach Pizza Company was the place to go when the big cities were the only places to find truly authentic New York-style pizza. They don’t make deep dish pizzas or anything flashy; instead, they make pizza properly, using essential ingredients and meticulous attention to detail.

The meat lovers’ pizza was fantastic, with a thin crispy crust and an excellent marinara sauce. It was great! 

Perdido Beach Pizza Company Meat Lover Pizza

Additionally, because the ice cream is Hershey’s brand, it has a soft-serve texture but tastes the same as other ice cream and, in some ways, even better, in my view.

Although it takes some time, the wait is well worth it for pizza. I was surprised to learn that neither ranch nor jalapenos were extra. For what you receive, the price is fair. The advantage is that you may consume it there or take it outside to the pool. It is quite practical if you are staying at the resort.

Pizza At The Pass

27267 Perdido Beach Blvd. C2, Orange Beach, AL 36561, United States // +12512400500

Anyone who has ever had pizza in Orange Beach, Alabama, understands how difficult it can be to locate delicious pizza.

Therefore, I was delighted to learn about Pizza at the Pass. How could this establishment stand out when so many places give identical meals and options?

They have more than just homemade breadsticks and inexpensive pepperoni, that’s why. But, in my opinion, you can’t go wrong with the price of the pepperoni pizza with sausage and onions.

Pizza At The Pass Pepperoni Pizza

I started off with a tasty Greek salad topped with a lovely Greek dressing and packed with chunky tomatoes and cucumbers. Then, I ordered pretzel sticks to go with my healthy salad.

It’s incredibly cool because the restaurant is so small that you can watch the employees make your pie. This is the place to be if you’re in Orange Beach, Alabama, and need a decent pizza fix! In addition to being complete and delicious, their pizza is one of the best pizza in Orange Beach.

Villaggio Grille

4790 Main St. F108, Orange Beach, AL 36561, United States // +12512246510

One of the most excellent meals I’ve had in a long was this one! The meat and vegetable soup of the day was fantastic! The most pleasing soup ever, hands down! I drank the Octavia loose tea with lime blossom, goat cheese, and walnut salad.

The cheese and meat board starter was excellent. I also got a very fresh Caesar salad, which I also ordered. I chose their wood-fired Villaggio Pizza with Marinara, Sausage, Pepperoni, Bell Peppers, Mushrooms, and Kalamata Olives as my entrée. It was well done. Bell peppers were delicious.

Villaggio Grille Pizza

The strawberry cream cheesecake was a tasty addition to the meal, which we shared. Our server was pleasant and helpful but not intrusive. The ambiance in the restaurant is pleasant. Whenever I’m in the region, I’ll always return.

Final Thoughts About the Best Pizza In Orange Beach

Orange Beach has some of the best options, whether you’re looking for a family-friendly pizza place or a unique, one-of-a-kind location. 

From tasty pies with toppings you can’t find anywhere else to an amazing atmosphere and ambiance, it’s no wonder these pizza restaurants have become so popular.

Visiting other destinations in Alabama? Check out our other guides:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.