Mequon, a quiet northern suburb of Milwaukee, has lately undergone an economic development plan that has resulted in a slew of new, independent, and delicious restaurants in this relatively tranquil Midwestern town.
What was formerly largely residential dwellings is now a hotspot for exciting places to eat pizza north of Milwaukee.
Fans of thin crust and deep-dish pizza will agree that there’s nothing like a fresh slice of pizza, and there’s no better spot to locate the ideal slice than Mequon, WI.
Continue reading to learn about the best pizza in Mequon, to fill your soul whenever you are yearning for that doughy, saucy, and cheesy bliss.
Table of Contents
The Best Pizza In Mequon
12020 N. River Rd., Mequon, WI 53092, United States // +12622425917
Mequon Pizza Company is a great family-owned business and has one of the best pizza in Mequon. One of the owners is usually working behind the bar. The service is friendly, and the cuisine is delicious comfort food.
There isn’t a lot of waitstaff because you order food and drinks at the bar. There are some gluten-free choices available. It’s always quite busy, but the kitchen moves quickly.
This is one of the best destinations in the area for pizza and beer lovers; hidden between the Thiensville and Mequon areas, this house-like restaurant boasts a wide horseshoe bar smack dab in one large room.
If you are a first-timer, you will notice there are no servers; instead, you’ll order at the bar. This can slow down service at peak times, but the staff is cheerful and accommodating.
The thin-crust pizzas at MPC are to die for, and while I enjoy a good Chicago deep-dish pizza, the deep dish at MPC is not up to par. However, the side salad is a great way to start if you’re not in the mood for their excellent wonton-wrapped mozzarella sticks.
Their thin crust pizza is delicious. They add sauce after the toppings, so there doesn’t appear to be much cheese. The handmade chips with cheese sauce and the beef lasagna are popular. They also offer to carry out if you don’t finish your meal!
It’s a well-known local pizza business for when you want a decent beer with supper; their other menu items will more than suffice; I’ve yet to have a sandwich that I didn’t appreciate.
Finally, there is no doubt that the beer selection is among the best in the area. If you can’t find a beer or a style you like, you probably don’t enjoy beer. However, it is an absolute must-try for pizza in Mequon. Do let me know in the comments if you think that this is the best pizza in Mequon!
11051 N. Port Washington Rd., Mequon, WI 53092, United States // +12622418557
This is the only and best NYC pizza on the Northshore. So fold it over and pack it in! Hidden off Mequon Road, Leonardo knows how to represent the 212. Their pies are hand-tossed and laid with a foundation of personal toppings that will make your mouth water.
This is my friend’s favorite, so he introduced me to it when we visited this weekend. This pizza is easily understandable as to why he raves about it.
The NY-style crust is thin but not soggy, with a pillowy edge that is the perfect spot of un-topped edge for holding and folding.There is ample cheese, and the toppings are generous but not so plentiful you are overwhelmed.
We opted for sausage + olive and a veggie option with olives, green peppers, mushrooms, and onions. As a veggie pizza lover, I have to say this was one of the favorites I’ve had. The veggies were thinly sliced, so the pizza didn’t get watery. The sausage had excellent seasoning as well. I recommend visiting here on your next tour! You’ll get a taste of Brooklyn-style pizza in Mequon.
1515 W. Mequon Rd., Mequon, WI 53092, United States // +12622415990
Everything about my experience at Zarletti’s was beautiful, from the courteous service to the delicious cuisine.
It’s a wonderful mix of formal and casual, allowing you to wear anything from jeans to a more formal dress. In addition, there are numerous seating options available to suit your mood.
Do not be afraid to ask where you would like to sit in the restaurant if you have a preference. All of the staff I encountered were quite accommodating.
First and foremost, all of the pasta, including the ravioli, is prepared in-house. I can vouch for the quality of the pappardelle and ravioli based on my own experience. Their pizza is authentic and delicious as well!
If you’re visiting Zarletti for the first time and enjoy pasta, I highly recommend the Pappardelle Bolognese, a slow-cooked stew of beef, pork, and veal ragu. No, not the Ragu brand sauce your mother used to cook. A ragu is a tomato-based meat sauce from Italy.
My favorite on the menu is the Apple Gorgonzola Pizza. It has blue cheese crumbles, nuts, and the perfect tart taste from when you bite into the hot, green, sliced apples. Delicious! The best part is that it will fill you up but won’t make you feel like a million pounds afterward.
A great place to go with a very close friend or if you’re looking for something romantic but still not overdoing it for a second date!
One thing I like about Zarletti is that you can share salads. They served the salad family-style with a large serving utensil for a party of three. They served two smaller salads. Very good! Give it a go. You’ll get some of the best pizza in Mequon.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting. Our waiter was quite friendly, and the service was quick. There were so many menu options, and everyone at our table agreed the food was delicious. In addition to vegetarian and vegan options, meaty options are available. Excellent for all diets and lifestyles.
This restaurant has a great ambiance and delivers lovely food. Authentic wood-fired pizza, salads, burgers, and sandwiches. I could smell the hardwood smoke as we got out of the car.
I ordered the $5 personal pizza from the football specials, figuring it wouldn’t be anything exceptional. My toppings were Italian sausage and red onion. The pizza was rather tasty!
The sausage was tasty, the cheese was of good quality, and the crust appeared handcrafted (hand-tossed) and coated with cornmeal before being baked in their wood oven.
It’s a great spot for a casual work lunch or a get-together with pals. Also, check the signs for live music on certain nights. I can’t wait to come back! And as always, let me know in the comments if you think this is the best pizza in Mequon!
227 S. Main St., Thiensville, WI 53092, the United States // +12623874992
We came here for the first time and were blown away. It has a tiny, vintage pizza place feel to it, with an ice cream counter stocked with numerous Cedar Crest ice flavors.
We got the garlic bread, a deep-dish pizza with most of the toppings of a supreme, and a tiny ten-inch spinach, artichoke, and chicken pizza with a cauliflower crust from their specialty menu.
I’d never eaten a pizza with a cauliflower crust, which was delicious! It has a little strong flavor that comes out in waves and beautifully complements the artichoke, chicken, and spinach, and the sauce provides harmony to the rest of the pizza’s melody.
The garlic bread came in two enormous slices with a deliciously browned cheese and garlic topping, and the butter just soaked into the bread so perfectly that it tasted like the entire piece was infused with garlic and cheese!
And now for the main attraction; deep-dish pizza. The dough was obviously deep-dish but not too bready that it obscured the toppings, and it had some chewiness that provided an excellent introduction to the pizza.
The toppings and sauce were all the way to the edges, and the actual pizza appearance hinted at a fantastic experience! There were no bare patches, thin spots, or flat spots to be found. Every single topping on the pizza could be tasted with each bite.
This is how pizza should be created. I’m looking forward to returning to taste every variety of pizza they have, and I recommend you do the same! This is your go-to spot for Chicago-style deep-dish pizza in Mequon. What do you think? Is this the best pizza in Mequon? Let me know in the comments!
Summary Of The Best Pizza Restaurants In Mequon
Everyone has a soft spot in their heart for pizza. Both young and older people can enjoy it. It’s something that brings families together with a grin for decades.
And, if you’re anything like me, there’s something seductive about a thin crust against a thick crust. There’s a Mequon pizza restaurant that gets it done properly no matter what kind of pizza you like: thin crust or deep-dish pie. Veggie fans can taste the most fantastic vegan cheeses in town, and the wide array of classic dishes makes eating out at a local pizzeria everyone’s favorite pick!
Visiting other destinations in Wisconsin? Check out our other delicious guides:
- 8 Best Mequon Restaurants | Where to Eat in Mequon, Wisconsin
- The 10 Best Restaurants In Superior Wisconsin
- The 8 Best Restaurants In Sturgeon Bay WI
Igor Jovanovski is an aspiring digital nomad, travel blogger and graphic designer who really loves food. He also has a creative side, and he works as a freelance graphic designer in his spare time. He has traveled across Europe quite a few times since he was young and recently started his mission to visit every country in the world! Igor’s favorite thing about traveling is the way he gets to know new people, food, places and cultures.
This exciting experience helps him create his own stories and make memories that will last forever