Skip to Content

Best Bainbridge Island Pizza Restaurants | 5 Must-Try Places

Sharing is caring!

In this article, I will whisk you away to a slice of paradise (pun intended!) nestled in the stunning Puget Sound, a mere hop, skip, and a ferry ride from downtown Seattle. 

Welcome to Bainbridge Island, a quaint, picturesque escape with a food scene that’s as vibrant as its lush greenery.

You know, when I first set foot on this idyllic island, I had visions of devouring the freshest seafood. But then I caught a waft of something magical. It was the unmistakable aroma of freshly baked pizza.

And, boy, oh boy, it was love at first bite! Here on Bainbridge, the pizzas are like treasure maps, with each bite revealing a different secret.

Best Bainbridge Island Pizza Places

So, throw away those chain pizzeria coupons and come strolling down the cozy streets with me as I spill the cheese on the Best Bainbridge Island Pizza Places that will make your taste buds perform a standing ovation. 

These aren’t just your average pizzerias – these are gourmet havens that have turned dough, sauce, and cheese into an art form.

It’s not just the pizzas, though – the ambiance, the people, and the very air of Bainbridge Island that rolls in with the ferry seem to be sprinkled with a special seasoning. 

Be it the relaxed summer afternoons or the crisp fall evenings, there’s a pie for every palate and mood.

So buckle up, dear foodie friends! Bainbridge Island’s culinary adventure is calling, and I assure you, it’s peppered with all the delightful, cheesy goodness one can dream of. 

This is one saucy saga you don’t want to miss! Stay tuned as we dive into the toppings and tales of the best pizza places Bainbridge offers.

My Top Three Picks of the Best Bainbridge Island Pizza Places

Restaurant Top PickOur Rating
BruciatoDateri E Prosciutto Pizza5/5
That’s A Some PizzaGorgonzola pizza5/5
Bene PizzaFunghi Pizza4.5/5

The Five Best Best Bainbridge Island Pizza Places


236 Winslow Way E, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110, United States // +12062013462

Allow me to start by introducing you to Bruciato, the epitome of Neapolitan glory on Bainbridge Island.

Now, I’ve always fancied myself a fan of Neapolitan-style pizza, and let me tell you, Bruciato did not just meet my expectations – it soared above them! Nestled in a minimalist haven, this spot won me over with its cozy ambiance. 

The huge garage door at the front adds a dash of quirk, blending the indoors with the outdoors. The breeze whispers stories of distant Italian shores as you sip on your drink.

And, oh, the pizza! I can still taste the symphony of flavors that danced on my taste buds. The tomato sauce – such a simple thing, yet so divine. The ingredients? You bet they’re as fresh as the morning dew. 

I opted for the Dateri E Prosciutto Pizza, and let me just say; my life has been changed. The crust was like a journey through an Italian grandmother’s kitchen, and as the waiter gracefully shaved the prosciutto onto my pizza, I felt like the pizza gods were knighting me.

Prosciutto Pizza

But let’s take a moment to appreciate the glorious combination that is date and prosciutto. The sweet and salty flavors were locked in a harmonious embrace. It was like my taste buds were hosting the world’s most epic party.

Now, let’s talk location. Bruciato is perfectly situated. Before or after your meal, take a stroll through the charming shopping district of Bainbridge, or make your way to the Washington State Ferry terminal. It’s a triple threat – indulge, shop, and set sail for more adventures.

To sum it up, Bruciato is not just a pizza place; it’s an experience. Whether you’re here to embrace your inner foodie or simply looking for a delightful spot to unwind, this locally-owned Italian haven is a perfect slice of pizza on Bainbridge Island.

Via Rosa 11

10320 NE Valley Rd., Bainbridge Island, WA 98110, United States // +12064514640

Next on the list is Via Rosa 11, a counter-serve Bainbridge pizza haven tucked away like a hidden treasure.

Now, let me be upfront. Via Rosa 11 is not your ordinary Italian joint. This charming nook in a serene shopping plaza is a little slice of Italy right here in Bainbridge. 

And when I say charming, I mean cobblestone-patio-with-hanging-plants charming. You order at the counter and sit, anticipation building as you take in the rustic, authentic vibes around you.

But let’s talk about the highlight – the food! I went classic and ordered the Margherita Pizza. Oh, you beautiful Margherita, let me count the ways I adore thee. 

The fresh and simple ingredients seemed to sing an Italian ballad with every bite. The crust, the sauce, the cheese – it was as if they were all in perfect harmony.

Pizza Margherita

And just when I thought I couldn’t be more enamored, the tiramisu waltzed into my life. If I could write poetry, odes would be penned to this tiramisu. It was ethereal, cloud-like, and made me question every tiramisu I’d had before.

Now, what’s fascinating is that Via Rosa 11 is not just about the here and now. They have a selection of take-home dishes and sauces that practically scream, “Take me home tonight!” How could I say no?

So here’s my heartfelt recommendation: if you find yourself looking for pizza on Bainbridge Island, make the trip to Via Rosa 11. 

Whether you’re seeking an authentic Italian meal or a serene spot to relax with a coffee, this place has got you covered. It’s not just a meal; it’s a journey through the Italian countryside sans the airfare.

That’s A Some Pizza

9720 Coppertop Loop NE Suite 101, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110, United States // +12068422292

Have you ever had a slice that made you want to shout from the rooftops? Well, I found my rooftop-worthy pizza at a humble gem on Bainbridge Island called That’s A Some Pizza. The name is quite the statement, and trust me; it lives up to every letter.

This unassuming counter-serve joint is like the unsung hero of sourdough pizza. “Small but mighty” should be their motto because while the space may be basic, the pizzas that emerge from their ovens are anything but. 

And did I mention they have gluten-free crusts? A chorus of cheers for our gluten-averse comrades!

Now, seating is a no-go indoors, but that’s just part of the charm. This is the ultimate grab-n-go pizza experience. 

I took my bounty and claimed a patch of grass in the park across the street, and let me tell you, the combo of fresh air and fresh pizza was sheer bliss.

But let’s get down to business; the Gorgonzola pizza. I mean, if I could send this pizza a thank-you note for existing, I would. It’s like they bottled up joy and sprinkled it as a topping.

Gorgonzola pizza

And can we talk about the crust? I’ve always said that a pizza’s soul is in its crust, and this soul is harmonious. 

It’s like the crust had a secret handshake with the oven – crispy here, chewy there. The perfect foundation for the pizza symphony on top.

What really warmed my heart, though, was the crew. They are the wizards behind the curtain, and their passion for pizza is evident in every slice.

So if you’re ever meandering through Bainbridge Island, do yourself a favor and grab a pie (or two) from That’s A Some Pizza. 

It’s a simple, soulful, and satisfying experience that will complete your Bainbridge pizza escapade.

Joe’s Restaurant

4633 Woodson Ln. NE, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110, United States // +12068427807

Next up is the fantastic Joe’s Restaurant. The welcoming air was palpable. The friendly service paired with an ambiance that just urges you to kick back and relax, Joe’s felt like an old friend. 

And when an establishment feels this much like home, you just know the food is going to be heartwarming.

Now, folks, let me rave about the showstopper – the Roasted Butternut Squash Pizza. Yes, you read that right! Squash on pizza – sounds avant-garde, but oh, what a masterpiece it is! 

The butternut squash is like the golden nectar of the earth; when it meets the velvety béchamel sauce, it’s pure magic. 

The sage makes a grand entrance, taking the flavor profile to a whole new level. This pizza is like an opera in your mouth.

Roasted Butternut Squash Pizza

But wait, there’s more. The polenta fries at Joe’s are like a carnival for your taste buds. Crispy, golden, and perfect for dipping into their marinara sauce (though, rumor has it ranch is also an option).

And let’s not forget their huge kale salad. This, my friends, is not your average salad. This is a colossus among greens. 

The olive oil sings, the golden raisins bring a touch of sweetness, and the grated cheese ties it all together like a bow on the most perfect present.

I also must give a standing ovation to our waiter, the epitome of kindness. It’s rare to find a place where the food and service both shine like stars in the night sky.

So, if you ever find yourself roaming the lovely streets of Bainbridge, make a beeline for Joe’s Restaurant and enjoy the best pizza in Bainbridge!

Bene Pizza

937 Hildebrand Ln. NE #104, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110, United States // +12068552895

Last but not least, we have Bene pizza in Bainbridge, a place with cozy, community feel, which is the perfect backdrop for this intimate haven of Neapolitan-style pies.

The word “Bene” means good in Italian, and let me tell you, “good” is an understatement here. The moment I stepped into the space, I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere with whispers of old-world Italy. 

Aesthetically pleasing, you have a choice to make – watch the artisans at work as they craft pizzas in their wood oven indoors or venture out to the little garden that awaits. It’s a tough call, my friends.

Now, let’s get to the location – Bene is nestled in downtown Winslow, like a well-kept secret among the maze of restaurants. Tucked away from the hustle and bustle, it’s like a whisper that only true food lovers hear.


But let’s dive into the main attraction – the pizza. I had my eye on The Funghi and Margherita pizzas, and oh, what an outstanding choice it was. 

The Funghi felt like a walk through an enchanting forest, with mushrooms playing a symphony of taste. 

The Margherita was nothing short of regal – the classic queen of pizzas. Each bite was a testament to the craftsmanship that goes into these wood-oven wonders.

Bene Pizza is not just about eating; it’s an experience, a journey through Italy in the heart of Bainbridge Island. 

The combination of the artisan pizzas, the cozy ambiance, and the tucked-away charm make Bene a spot that deserves a standing ovation.

So, seek out this delightful corner next time you’re in Bainbridge. It’s a reminder that sometimes the best treasures are hidden just slightly off the beaten path. 

Questions Foodies Also Ask About The Best Bainbridge Island Pizza Spots

What makes the pizza scene in Bainbridge Island so special?

Bainbridge Island has this magical ability to blend small-town charm with big-time flavors. The pizza scene here is infused with that island coziness and doesn’t shy away from creativity. 

It’s a pizza lover’s playground, from classic Neapolitan to unconventional toppings like butternut squash!

Is it all about traditional pizza on Bainbridge Island, or is there something for the adventurous palate?

While you’ll find traditional pizzas to swoon over, Bainbridge Island is also a haven for the adventurous. 

From using seasonal Pacific Northwest ingredients to inspired combinations like the Roasted Butternut Squash pizza at Joe’s, there’s a slice for every kind of adventurer.

Any tips for a perfect pizza day on Bainbridge Island?

Start with a stroll around the island to work up an appetite. Opt for an early lunch at one place, maybe Via Rosa 11, for its Italian flair. 

Take a break, explore some more, and then hit up another spot like Bruciato for dinner. Take your pizza to-go if it’s a sunny day and enjoy it in a park. Don’t rush – let the pizza love affair unfold at island pace.

Wrapping Up: The Five Best Best Bainbridge Island Pizza Places

As our saucy journey through the captivating pizza landscape of Bainbridge Island draws to a close, let’s take a moment to bask in the afterglow of all the cheesy goodness we’ve encountered. 

We searched for the perfect slice on this picturesque island, and oh, what a ride it’s been!

One can’t help but be enamored by the sheer diversity of pizza Bainbridge Island has to offer. 

From the wafting scents of wood-fired ovens to the rustic charm of mom-and-pop pizzerias, it’s clear that this place is an authentic pizza sanctuary. 

Each crust, whether bubbly and charred or thin and crisp, tells a story. Each topping, locally sourced or classically Italian, adds to the narrative.

What strikes you most is the soul in each slice. The pizzas here aren’t just a quick bite; they’re an experience, a culinary hug that seems to say, “Welcome to Bainbridge Island, friend!” 

With their deft hands and passion, the pizza artisans are akin to poets, each pie a verse in a cheesy, saucy ballad.

Another commendable aspect is the sense of community permeating the island’s pizzerias. 

Whether you’re a local or a wandering pizza pilgrim, you’ll be embraced with open arms and probably leave with a few more friends than when you arrived.

And let’s not overlook the creative bravery on display. Traditional ingredients dance alongside bold, unexpected ones. 

It’s a testament to the fearlessness of the island’s pizza maestros and the appreciative palates of its inhabitants.

So, as we say our goodbyes to this pizza paradise, let’s make a pact – a promise to return, explore, and savor. 

Bainbridge Island isn’t just a destination; it’s a reminder of how food can bring people together, warm hearts, and create memories that last a lifetime.

Visiting other destinations in Washington State? Check out our other guide:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.